Advertisement

loader

Talk

Advanced search

Mildred Pierce on Sky 1

(17 Posts)
Overtiredmum Tue 05-Jul-11 22:43:03

Anyone been watching this so far?

sparkle1977 Wed 06-Jul-11 14:10:12

I sky plussed each of the episodes and just finished watching them yesterday, absolutely loved them. Was very shocked by the ending though, not at all what I expected. Hope there will be another series.

PaisleyLeaf Wed 06-Jul-11 14:12:23

I really like Kate Winslet, but I'm finding the acting in this a bit iffy.

blurdylurdy Wed 06-Jul-11 14:17:49

Hate it. One of my most favourite books of all time, but this is awful. No life to it, no spark. Kate Winslet totally wrong for the part. Must have read the book a dozen times, and it always offers more, yet this has no soul. Seeing a pattern with big Sky Atlantic things - they look great, but they're empty.

katkitya Wed 06-Jul-11 20:26:52

Like Boardwalk Empire? I know what you mean. I must admit, the only things I seem to watch on there are the oldies.

ThisIsJustASagaNow Wed 06-Jul-11 20:34:47

I don't have sky but have seen this advertised. I am intrigued because the film with Joan Crawford is one of my all time favourites. You'd have to go some to beat that. Why did they make it a series and not a film I wonder?

Not read the book but will make the effort.

blurdylurdy Wed 06-Jul-11 22:22:57

Exactly like Boardwalk Empire - should have been so good, but just felt soulless.

I agree - the film was so good, that any 5 part imitation was always going to fall short. I went back and read the book yesterday just to make sure it was as good as I've always thought!

I sound like I'm on commission for the original . . .

valiumredhead Wed 20-Jul-11 21:48:06

I have been watching this and I agree, utterly soulless! Which is a crying shame.

I haven't read the book and I am going to as I have a feeling the book will go to explaining her character in more detail hopefully.

My questions are -

* I'm not sure wether I am supposed to admire Mildred for being a business woman or loathe her for failing so spectacularly with her kids, does the book make her a more likeable character?

* The night she up sticks and goes off with gorgeous Guy Pearce is so confusing. Why would she just leave her kids? Is she at all guilty in the book? In the series it just seems a bit "Oh well, went off for a shag, came back and daughter is dead, let's get the restaurant open" SO unbelievable.

* WHY is the eldest daughter such a brat is Mildred is pretty down to earth - is there any back ground story there?

* Did she just shag first bloke - husband's friend to get back at husband/further her career plans and how does she get away with it? Surely back then she would be seen as a bit fast and loose, or not?

Sorry for all the questions - am definitely going to read the book!

KW is dire in this and I find myself drawn to her top lip and how dark it is - the make up artist should be shot and introduce Kate to some Immac.

Saying all that though, I am GLUED to it every Saturday night - next one is the last one isn't it?

turnitup Thu 21-Jul-11 09:42:31

Oh I LOVE this and I also love Boardwalk Empire - maybe its because I never read the books.

AnnThology Thu 21-Jul-11 09:42:58

I JUSY BLOODY LOVE IT

GetOrfMoiLand Thu 21-Jul-11 09:50:44

Oh I hope it is good. I have recorded the lot and am going to watch 'em all one weekend soon.

I love KW, and I loved the Joan Crawford film (not read the book however).

I have read very good reviews elsewhere. Mind you I loathed Boardwalk Empire, all style no substance.

AnnThology Thu 21-Jul-11 09:51:46

id never heard of it.
i got bored of BWE
why are we comparing the two?

limitedperiodonly Tue 26-Jul-11 18:12:43

It was very limp. Does the book end in that kind of, 'oh, never mind' kind of way? Never saw the film.

valiumredhead Tue 26-Jul-11 18:19:04

Yes, that's EXACTLY how it felt to me too limited

I kept waiting for the 'big shocker' but was disappointed that it was her dd in bed with Guy Pearce as that had already been shown in a trailer so massive let down in my opinion!

chickflit Wed 27-Jul-11 21:50:16

I watched every week but was really disappointed with it. It just felt so flat, and in my opinion didn't really go anywhere, I kept waiting and waiting.

Normally I love Kate Winslett too, but is it me or was she just not very good in this? Everything about her/Mildred really grated on me.

This has actually put me off reading the book I would be really frustrated if it plodded along like the TV show and some people have said it's stuck quite close to the book, but I really couldn't get into any of the characters.

Nancy66 Thu 28-Jul-11 09:24:23

I absolutely loved this - thought it was one of the best things I've seen on TV for a long time.

Really good, but subtle and underplayed, performances.

Thought Rachel Evan Wood as the older Veda was superb

turnitup Fri 29-Jul-11 17:21:56

Totally agree Nancy - Im amazed at the negative comments confused

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now