Is this really what teenage girls should expect to put up with?(44 Posts)
Dd is 15. She has a fair amount of freedom. Goes on shopping / cinema / day trips with friends. Always home well before dark.
This summer she has been inundated with really horrible male attention. A car with several young men has followed her for a hundred yards or so - calling for her to get in, only stopping when she reached home. On a train journey from Brighton to London with a friend, a middle aged man (with sad eyes, her description) sat opposite them, they were sitting one side of a small table, pulled his penis out and began masturbating. They got off the train, it hadn't even left the station.
Yesterday, on a bus, a guy yelled "oi blondie, come here, you're gorgeous" at her constantly. At the end of our road, just after she got off the bus, another man pulled his penis out and started waving it about.
Each time she has been with a friend.
She seems a mixture of "wtf" and angry. I have told her some men are just vile towards women when they think they can get away with it, and that it is wrong and horrid. But I want to make sure that I am giving her the right advice. For instance, for the man on the train, I said, instead of getting off the train you should have loudly shouted that he was masturbating in order to get peoples' attention. But I not sure what else to say. I am worried she will become worried about going out. I am worried that this is becoming the norm for her as a young woman. I am angry, really angry, that this is happening to a teenage girl. And sad.
Can anyone give me any advice please? Thankyou.
I'm sad for her too and sad that not much has changed since I was that age (only difference was that I got groped a lot - mahoosive boobs - and no willy wavers, they came later).
I think your advice about the masturbater was right as she was in a crowded place (guessing the train wasn't empty). If she and her friend were alone then getting off would have been safer I think.
As for the guys in the car, that can be really scary.
Maybe someone will be along who knows professionally about these things, but given how much CCTV we have, the car incident may have been captured. Is that something police can get involved in? Same with the willy waver at the end of the street.
My own experience - in hindsight - was that I knew these guys were freaks, but because it a) happened frequently and b) nobody ever seemed shocked by it (adults) I just thought it was kind of normal and that I was somehow attracting it. It did impact my expectations from men, not drastically, but the bar of what I deemed acceptable was definitely lowered.
My mother, for another reason, bought me a personal alarm. This was not useful: I didn't feel more empowered by it in the least.
What would have redressed the power balance (because that's what it's all about for the men) is if I'd known that IF I were attacked, I could have had an idea of how to handle myself. A good self-defence course - especially the Israeli one (forgotten its name) - would have helped that.
Sorry that your daughter is having these things happen and with any luck someone who really knows about how best to deal with this sort of thing will be along.
Thank you for your reply, cantreachmytoes.
Dd and her friend were on a crowded train, I think though that their first thought was to be safe, and that was fine.
It's interesting that you didn't find a personal alarm useful.
Dd has been trained in a marshal art, though not done it for several years. I think I will suggest a self defense course to her, that's a really good idea.
I was 15 in 1973 and it was exactly the same. I treated as a joke mostly, although I do remember a holiday in Italy being spoiled because I was groped all the time just walking down the street. I used to walk home after dark and I remember a flasher standing on a street corner. I never told my mother about any of it though.
Of course you don't want your DD to be harassed but it's definitely nothing new. Doesn't make it right and I don't think you can prevent it..
She needs to know how to keep safe and try to ignore. If she can't ignore she should pretend to ignore.
I remember it being similar when I was 14 or 15 in the 80's.
Being shouted at from cars, breasts groped, propositioned by older men when out.
No willy waving though, that's new!
I seem to remember it stopped as I got older, say by about 20.
I think a lot of men choose to intimidate young women, they are less likely to stand up to them maybe???
I hate it and think it's deplorable. Your dd has dealt with it very well, but she shouldn't have to
It happens to most women at some point I think.
Certainly happened to me! (Am only early 20s now). It stopped as I got older and obviously now I have DS with me most of the time
and obviously look less like a deer in the headlights
I do think younger women are easier to intimidate & less sure of what they can do about it etc. I.e, nowadays I'd have called out the creep on the train but aged under 20, I'd have probably got off, like your DD.
Happened to me from about 15-20yrs too.
"I think a lot of men choose to intimidate young women, they are less likely to stand up to them maybe???"
I completely agree with this statement. This sort of scum really enjoy bullying older girls/young women.
I was stood at the bus stop with DD2 a month or 2 ago. She's 13 - and tiny for 13. A passer by, if they were trying to give the oldest she could possibly be, would say 12 at most.
It was raining so I sat in the shelter. DD didn't seem bothered by the rain so was stood outside waiting to see the bus. It was about 4pm.
The number of men who, thinking she was alone, hooted from their cars or slowed down to a kerb crawl was both depressing and very scary. One old bloke of about 60 slowed to almost a stop. I got up and went out as I thought he was going to grab her. He sped off pretty damn fast when he saw me.
I want to give her indepenence but it does worry me. I want her to grow up empowered and confident, not having to deal with a pervert at every turn.
Photograph them and put on everyday sexism project? Get licence plates etc. May make no difference, but if everyone does this things will change.
Wow! How awful for your DD!
I have had lots of unwanted attention when young but never a flasher or masterbaters
Have you contacted the police?
Other than that I have no advise. I was always very lame about these things. I certainly don't think it's a new thing, though.
Weirdly blondes with long hair seem to get more unwanted attention than brunettes.
This is one of the few things that give me the rage, my ex's (who I still live with) daughter is 18 and had several of these incidents over the last couple of years. The most recent being when some body tried to force himself on her when she was coming home one night a couple of months ago. I insisted we contact the police if only in the hope they might pick up a pattern, however I don't hold out much hope given the muppets who came out.
I wish I had advice that would help.
She must carry a telephone with her and photograph / video the bastards.
Take pictures of the licence plates / remember them and note them down.
Go to the police with the evidence.
Your poor DD, I feel for her: the same happened to me, and I just hate male attention even now - they're such predatory wolves.
When i was 18 I got myself a rather big high status boyfriend, that stopped it for a bit: luckily for me he was a total gent too.
Maybe your DD needs a 'walker' to keep the dregs at bay?!
Please reinforce that she's not to uglify herself- she's done nothing to deserve being treated like an object: the men are wrong, not her.
Sounds less like a personal alarm and more like a very large pair of scissors are required to deter willy wagglers.
I am on her behalf, and can see this would be frightening for her and you.
Is there any kind of pattern, area etc she could pinpoint that would help the police if you called them.
The defence class sounds like an excellent idea.
That's dire. I think it's important she knows, as you have told her, that it is not in anyway acceptable or normal (common maybe but not normal) and that it says a lot about the horrible specimens doing it abs nothing about her.
I think your shouting advice was good - wanking at teenagers in public is not legal!! And is utterly vile.
These people are commiting crimes by intimidating abs harassing her and she should be confident in getting the police involve.
Hugs to her!
This is awful and the sad thing is that it was happening to me in the 1970s and it is still happening now.
It's good that your DD has told you about it.
My niece was groped in a crowded train. She grapped the hand and held it up and told the owner in front of everyone to stop touching her up and keep his disgusting hands to himself.
God nothing changes. All of these things happened to me too. I'm glad she could tell you. I wouldn't have brought it up with my mother.
Like chottie, I would tell my daughter to yell "get your disgusting hands off me you filthy pervert". or "stop masturbating on the train".
If my old flatmate is on mumsnet she will know who I am, but we were flashed at in Malta and we chased him and he ran towards the beach and we threw stones at him. My old flat mate was shouting at him "it's tiny you sad wanka". She had chutzpah that girl. I wouldn't have had the balls on my own. But when I think of that now I laugh. But when I think of the time I had to make a phonecall in a telephone box and turned around to see a man wanking I shudder and feel like I was used. I know chasing a flasher mightn't seem like a sensible idea but I have filed it differently in my brain. It's not a memory that makes me shudder.
When I was 16 we had a police woman come into school to teach us how to deal with sexual harassment. The main thing which stays in my mind is she told us to publicly shame the perverts. If someone is groping you was to grab their hand and raise it in the air and shout loudly to attract attention. The other ting she encouraged us to do was attend women's self defence classes
She should not have to put up with it, absolutely no way
But I am afraid the objectification of women starts very early and this is how it goes
I expect she will get some relief from it once she hits 40 or so, when women become virtually invisible
This is our woman-hating society. I expect someone will blame her for the negative attention she has received, because she is pretty and wears nice clothes or summat
< having a despondent evening, sorry >
Just to give you all a bit of hope, I was whistled last year, which I obviously ignored. I then heard the mans friends say "You shouldn't do that. Women don't like it." So maybe we are getting somewhere. [hopeful]
This is really sad
Why do almost all women have a tale to tell?
Thank you all for the replies.
To be honest, it's a depressing read. But it has given me some thoughts of possible ways forward.
I am going to contact dd's head of year at school, explain the situation, and ask if a police officer can visit the school and give some advice about what to do in this sort of situation. I don't want to advise dd to take photos etc if the police suggest that this could actually put her in danger. I am also to encourage her again to be far more vocal next time this happens to her.
I shall come back and update this thread. Thank you again.
But remember, everyone, we "don't really need feminism any more".
Encourage her to be angry. This behaviour is not OK and she doesn't need to put up with it.
What VenusRising said. Does she have a phone?
She needs to make it very obvious that she is taking photos and also photos of licence plates, and to make it obvious that she is calling someone to report right there and then.
I would be very worried that a car full of wankers now knows where she lives. If she could duck into a shop or some other place that would be safer than going straight home if this happens again.
When DD1 and DD2 were approached by creeps trying to lure them into cars (separate occasions) the police told them to use their phones and to shout 'I'm a minor' plus any other stuff they cared to shout. When perverts in cars are caught their defence is they had no idea the girl was a minor. So DD1 and DD2 were told to shout that they were minors. Neither one of them had enough presence of mind to whip out their phones and the police were disappointed they had no reliable vehicle description or plate number to run through their computer. Men in cars know what they are doing when they follow someone and lure them. Potential victims need to know what they should do too and should rehearse it and not be afraid of being loud.
Martial arts are absolutely no use and it should never get to the point where your DD has to be involved in any physical confrontation. She will lose against a fit young man no matter how good she is unless she is Olympic champion. Young men are simply a lot stronger than most teenage girls. Even older men are. Even older men with sad eyes and pathetic lives.
Message deleted by Mumsnet for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Replies may also be deleted.
Join the discussion
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.Register now
Already registered with Mumsnet? Log in to leave your comment or alternatively, sign in with Facebook or Google.
Please login first.