so, is this dress cool and relaxed in a funky sixties kind of way, or is it a sack?

[whyOwhy]

Am v drawn to it but still not sure!

[Hassled]

I'd go for cool and relaxed in a retro sort of way. I like it. You couldn't wear it and have a bit of tum on you, though.

[Blackduck]

sack...

[Lizzylou]

I like it, but am not sure of the ruching, bustle thing on the back though.

[Fimbo]

Oh no like. Looks like something from Primark.

[fishie]

i can see why you like it but it is indeedy a sack. and unless you are 6' tall it would be a mid calf sack too.

[SecretSlattern]

sack

[brimfull]

nice from the back

the front is sack-like and you'd need to be tall and slim to carry of any semblance of style I think

[pagwatch]

the idea is good but the fabric for the metallic bit is dreadful and looks really cheap.It is also cut really badly and hangs really badly,even on a model. If that is the best photo they could manage it is going to be even worse in RL .
Therefore = sack.

[whyOwhy]

Ah no, have tried it on (in another colour), and it hits the knee perfectly. Ruching thing barely visible, just gives a tiny bit of waist at the back. Tum not really an issue, just not sure about the whole effect! You lot aren't helping, can't you all decide one thing and stick to it?

[whyOwhy]

OK, cross posted, more sacks than likes by now - that helps!

[missmelly]

another vote for sack here.. i dont think that would be very flattering on anyone

[VinoEsmeralda]

sack here too

[ButterbeerAndLemon]

On Kate Moss it would be the cool retro one. On me it would be a sack.

[ButterbeerAndLemon]

and an unflattering sack, at that.

[ToutFucker]

sack

doesn't hang right, looks cheap and nasty

only Alexa Chung could get away with that, worn with pixie ankle boots, a choppy fringe and lots of kohl eyeliner

not for me, with my easy short hair, Birkies and 40 yr old vibe

[flier]

sorry but i think it looks very cheap and nasty

[DarrellRivers]

sack

[ihavenosecrets]

My immediate thought was sack. It looks like something I have rustled up on the sewing machine and for someone who can barely sew a button on that is not good.

[squeaver]

Sack and, really, does anyone think those shoes look good with it (or indeed anything)?

I hate glads.

[Lulubee]

A sacky sack from sackville. Kate and Alexa would look good in it but that's because they're models

[Greensleeves]

It is a sack even a potato would object to

put it from your mind

[Clure]

yes a bit sack like - not enough structure, needs a few "darts" to give it some shape!

[HollyBunda]

that is a sack and needs ironing!

[HuffwardlyRouge]

Oh good lord that is a terrible dress.

[ProfessorPhantomPlopper]

Horrid I'm afraid.