These M&S boots?

[MrsHoneybadger]

https://www.marksandspencer.com/block-heel-square-toe-chelsea-boots/p/clp60189525?image=SD01T025935AY0XEC_90&color=BLACK&prevPage=srp

I can't decide if these are stylish or not? I am a pretty young looking 39 year old, and want something I can wear with skinny jeans and skirts for smart casual at work and at the weekend. I am specifically looking for non-leather boots so these got a tick.

[Itsashame]

I don’t think so, sorry. They look very safe and don’t really commit to a look if you know what I mean

[HeronLanyon]

They are pretty bland but most of us need plenty of bland things in our wardrobe. Not objectionable (although I personally do not like the heel one little bit). Wouldn’t even notice the heel if someone was wearing them though.

[Bluntness100]

I think they are quite nice, would work well with skinny jeans, I'd not wear them with skirts though, Would be a bit frumpy.

[SpinySue]

I think the are quite 'fashionable' at the moment, asos is full of similar ones. But also they do look a bit frumpy but that's because frumpy and clunky is 'in' just now.

My mum has referred o a few people recently as 'a poor looking soul' not realising that they are on the cutting edge of trend, their clothes are band new and they have spent a lot to look to look that way!

[NK493efc93X1277dd3d6d4]

Both classic and stylish although not with skirts.

[MrsHoneybadger]

Hmmmm... maybe I will keep looking!

[OldGrinch]

I think they are quite frumpy looking but can't quite work out why, maybe the heel. I think you could find something similar but more stylish.

[Chefwifelife]

I'm torn. I think others are right it's the heel. Maybe something a little higher up the ankle. Mind you, go with what you like. Don't worry about what anyone else thinks

[MrsHoneybadger]

I am after black boots, preferably non-leather (I prefer the look and feel of leather but am trying to stay true to my vegan ethics), need to come in a 4.5 size, and comfortable enough to wear all day. I want to wear them with skinnies and knee length swing dresses and midi dresses. Not sure where to begin if anyone has any ideas I'm all ears!

[MrsHoneybadger]

How about these New Look ones? Not in a half size but I can use insoles if need be:

www.newlook.com/uk/womens/footwear/boots/black-leather-look-chunky-chelsea-boots-/p/630598101

[fantasmasgoria1]

Smart for work but sorry to say boring and bland for out of work. But then again I wear outlandish footwear so what do I know!!!

[MrsHoneybadger]

I've definitely discounted the M&S ones and am tempted by the chunkier New Look ones.

[Ineedanamechange79]

Tesco might be worth a look. I got some fab ones in there last year.

New look shoes are terrible quality in my experience.

[Widowodiw]

I’m sorry but these are boring as hell. A safe choice but perhaps that what you want. If you want to wear with skirts though I’d consider something with more panache.

[Anoisagusaris]

New Look ones are rotten. M&S ones are fine, perfectly functional and inoffensive for every day wear.

[Anoisagusaris]

I got a pair of flat black suede boots in New Look last year and they were so comfy.

[Ugzbugz]

Try asos, I'm not overly keen on these, it's the toe bit and stitch down the front

[raspberryk]

Heavenly feet have some IMO cool boots, they are also vegan.

[MikeUniformMike]

No.

[Zaphodsotherhead]

I wear ordinary jodphur boots with everything. They are comfortable, go with dresses or jeans and I can ride a horse in them.

Win win.

[oldmum22]

My Mum in her 80s would wear the M&s ones , I just don't like the style ,some would say classic others would say frumpy . Sorry

[IWantADifferentName]

No.

1. The heel is a bit splayed and ‘off’.
   
2. Boycott M&S because they have no respect for their core customers.

[Catsandchardonnay]

Umm if you like them what does anyone else’s opinion matter? Come on OP, you’re a big girl now, you can decide on your own style! (I like them by the way but that’s irrelevant)

[Mummyoflittledragon]

The New Look ones are nicer. I’m boycotting M&S anyway and you were right to discard them. They’re not nice.

[Dhautumn]

www.marksandspencer.com/block-heel-chelsea-ankle-boots/p/clp60275068?extid=ps_gglpla_Women&gclsrc=aw.ds&&gclid=Cj0KCQiAk7TuBRDQARIsAMRrfUajpmXimoUlRni7fl5LFxagM28zblKrXvEbWfaOm_Ukrg5f5jBdUD8aArUREALw_wcB

I got these for M&S the other week and they're really comfy. I've worn them casual and dressier. They're vegan friendly aswell