benefits "big beautiful eyes" discontinued hellp!!

[wibblewibble]

Hello,

Have been using benefits "big beautiful eyes" - the brown shades for a while and really like the colours and staying power. It’s been discontinued....what should I buy instead?! Bit of a novice so no ideas!

Thanks

[PeridotCricket]

Watching as I’m rubbish at eye shades and tha5 really suited me and was so easy...

[wibblewibble]

Agree it was super easy!!

[caterpuller]

I've heard good things about the Urban Decay naked palettes - No 2 looks like it has similar shades to the ones in your Benefit palette. Also Bobbi Brown is a good place to go for brown shades. You might be able to pick up single eyeshadows that are close to the shades you're looking for. I've got the Benefit big sexy eyes kit and love it - really easy to apply and the applicator is really good, it puts 2 shades on at once, the dark on the lid and the lighter colour to highlight.

[foxtiger]

The Nude Rose palette from Collection (formerly Collection 2000) has very similar colours in it, but more of them, including a sparkly black similar to the one in Urban Decay Naked 3. It's really cheap (I think £4) so you don't feel as frustrated when you have to throw away the colours you use less because you've run out of the best ones. (I loved BBE but hated the fact that you got the same amount of the lightest colour, which I instinctively wanted to use more of, and I always ran out.)

[Rufusthebewilderedreindeer]

Watching with interest

I would say that the naked two doesnt have the pink shade, or anything too similar

But i think number 3 has all the rose tints so that might be a better match

[Rufusthebewilderedreindeer]

fox

Yes, ive got barely any of the pink..a decent amount of the light brown and masses of the dark brown!

[13200w137]

Hello! Did you ever find a replacement?

thank you in advance!

samantha