Which Ash starry trainer?

[polyhymnia]

I've ordered these two pairs of trainers in the Ash sale, fully intending to send one back.

www.ashfootwear.co.uk/women-c1/ash-majestic-star-motif-trainers-silver-emerald-green-leather-p2452
www.ashfootwear.co.uk/women-c1/ash-majestic-bis-star-trainers-black-vinyl-leather-leopard-print-p2453

Trouble is, I really like both of them and just can't make up my mind. And can't really afford both.
Can anyone help me with views please? I expect some people may not like the style at all but I definitely do!

[QueenieMum]

I'm one of those who doesn't like them but willing to help! I prefer the black as they'd go with more outfits, especially in winter. The silver ones are more spring/summer to me, do you think there'll be any left in a couple of months?

[neveradullmoment99]

I like them but prefer the first ones. Not overly keen on the second ones [black ones].

I really like these too:

hush

hush
The second pair are out of stock but you could try John Lewis [online] as they do hush things.

Next also do a pair but think they are not leather

www.next.co.uk/g22318s10#152212

www.next.co.uk/g22318s3#176950

www.next.co.uk/g22318s5#445833

www.next.co.uk/g22318s4#718806

Maybe you could buy the white ash ones and a pair of the cheaper dark next ones?

[ABuckToothedGirlinLuxembourg]

I really don’t like the first pair, they look like kids trainers, second pair for me.

[CoffeenoTea]

They are not to my taste. My daughter who is 9 would love the silver ones .

[10thingsIhateAboutTheDailyMail]

Love them

Have white ones with silver stars, which I wear in.summer. so comfy, buttery leather.

In your case.... hmmm, I like the silver ones best, but the black ones you could wear with opaque tights!

[barefoofdoctor]

These are £50 something on Brandalley currently in both colours. PM me if you want me to recommend you as a friend for a £20 OFF your first £80+ spend. Get both!

[barefoofdoctor]

PS. I know you asked for opinions but pfttt life's too short to be a dull miserable git (at 38 I have the light up Irregular Choice influx trainers - hideous but love them to bits!).

[Theconifers25]

Barefoot I’ve PM’d you if that’s ok.

[barefoofdoctor]

Done it Theconifers25 anyone else?!

[Theconifers25]

Thanks

[CountFosco]

I like the silver ones.

[goose1964]

I liked the silver until I saw the black,but how much? My timberlands were only £30

[problembottom]

I have these ones, sadly not for the sale price!

www.ashfootwear.co.uk/sale-c6/ash-majestic-star-motif-trainers-white-leather-silver-accent-p2393

Really love them now but they were horribly hard on my heels for quite a few wears. Once broken in they’re really comfy.

[polyhymnia]

Thanks so much for comments. Still dithering. Many thanks for offer, barefoot. Not sure how to pm people but will check up on MN site.