Your ultimate, perfect eyeliner

[IncidentalAnarchist]

I think I've tried most eyeliners under the sun!

Liquid ones don't seem to have enough pigment - tried stila (probably the best), Kat Von D, Charlotte Tilbury etc

Pencil liner - probably perversion by Urban Decay is best for pigmentation but good god it doesn't last more than 3-4 weeks!

Besides which they all seem to end up panda-ing my eyes by 5pm

I've now read reviews of the Marc Jacobs gel pencils and the liquid eyeliners. They're ££ but I'm happy to pay for good pigmentation and a lack of smudge! Has anyone tried these or have I missed any other decent ones?

[girlwhowearsglasses]

Rimmel. Has a long brush. Simple and been using since approx 1993. I've tried loooooads.

You need a steady hand though

[friendlyflicka]

I find the best is to use some good quality powder eyeshadow with a very fine brush, dry. I use a dark brown Chanel one. I have never found a pencil liner I really like that is fine and dark enough. And I have grown out of liquid although I find YSL the best for that.

[YoungGirlGrowingOld]

I love my Bobbi Brown gel one in a pot. The BB one is also the only one I have tried with a thin enough brush. It stays put!

[Blackbutler86]

I like my liner super black and the best one I've found is soap & glory smoulder kohl, it also come with a handy sharpener in the lid.

[minniebear]

I second Bobbie Brown gel eye liner. Make Up Forever and Mac also do lovely Ines.

[RoryItsSnowing]

L'Oréal superliner- liquid with lots of pigment, never ever smudges. Best one I've ever used.

[Crumbs1]

Bobbi Brown waterproof pencil is only one that stays put.

[RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie]

Currently loving Mac Technakohl. They are twisty ones, so don't need sharpening. Gave up on Urban Decay for the reason you mention.

[Hellywelly10]

I use a pencil and set it with powder on top

[Holliewantstobehot]

Avon glimmerstick. Love it. Goes on really smooth and twists out so no sharpening.

[TheFifthKey]

Essence twist up ones from Wilko. £1.50 and I like them better than Glimmersticks! I have them in five colours! So easy to apply and stays on all day.

[NashvilleQueen]

Poundland. Seriously. I buy five at a time.

[iggleypiggly]

Mac PowerPoint. Best thing you will ever buy!

[NashvilleQueen]

www.google.co.uk/amp/www.cosmopolitan.com/uk/beauty-hair/makeup/reviews/amp30619/poundland-makeup-review/

[NashvilleQueen]

www.google.co.uk/amp/www.cosmopolitan.com/uk/beauty-hair/makeup/reviews/amp30619/poundland-makeup-review/

[mamado]

Nars are amazing

[FoodGloriousFud]

I like the No7 pencil eyeliners.

[MeganChips]

Seventeen Tattoo Me. Very black liquid eyeliner which never moves and absolutely everything else smudges on me.

Plus, it's a fiver.

[Degustibusnonestdisputandem1]

I like Urban Decays 24/7 pencil in zero!

[Housewife2010]

DHC is fantastic. It is a superfine brush which looks like a felt tip. You can get the finest line. My friend complimented me on it today.

[IncidentalAnarchist]

Wow.
I'm going to be trying a load of eyeliners as there seems to be very little consensus!!!

[ChardonnaysPrettySister]

I use Nars Larger than life and while they aren't as precise as the liquid ones they Do.Not.Budge.

Clinique Quickliner intense are nice, bur smearier.

[Chicinwellies]

Bobbi brown waterproof pencil. I get Lots if comments, and it doesn’t budge!

[DameDiazepamTheDramaQueen]

Essence ones are fab!

[Pistachiois50pmore]

When I used to do gel and a brush every day (which I think looks better than liquid), my favourite was Shu Uemura painting liner. But you can't get that any more. Topshop was a good 2nd. Both much better than MAC fluidline.

Now I have a kid so I do the more idiot-proof bronzey smudge (MAC Powersurge and Teddy pencils blended together).