Which of these bags would you buy??

[KoalaDownUnder]

They're on sale and I adore them (love a soft, slouchy leather bag), but - which?

I usually much prefer tan leather. However, the black is growing on me (and would stay looking nice longer). Argh!

Can someone decide for me?!

[Ponks]

Black without a doubt.

[PiratePointyTits]

I'd go for the black but only because I'm a muck magnet and that lovely tan one would get marked within day.

[KoalaDownUnder]

Pirate - my concern exactly!

[Loyly]

Black for sure.

[hoddtastic]

tan

[jewishprincessofchigwell]

Black vote from me.

[KoalaDownUnder]

Ooh, hodd, the voice of dissent!

[KoalaDownUnder]

The other thing is, the hardware is pale gold, not silver - I thought silver would look better with black leather. Or not?

[youngestisapsycho]

I only like silver hardware on bags and nearly all bags are gold....

[KoalaDownUnder]

Me too, youngest. I think pale gold looks ok with tan, though. Not sure about black.

[BadTasteFlump]

Definitely the tan - really classy looking (I want to buy it as well actually) - the squishiness of the leather is lost on black.

[AFierceBadRabbit]

I love the black!

[LadyOfTheCanyon]

hard to tell exactly from the picture but the tan looks cheap and the flap looks badly proportioned.
A vote for black if I had to but mainly on the basis that the tan will get trashed quicker.

[KoalaDownUnder]

Lady, Hmm. I think (hope) that the flap only looks like that because of the angle of the photo.

[QueenMortificado]

I wouldn't buy either and spend the money on a bench instead

The black, definitely!

[TSSDNCOP]

$299 I could buy a field of goats. And a bench.

In real life, I'd have the tan. Summers a-coming!!!!!!

[KoalaDownUnder]

The $299 is with another 25% off (I've already checked ). So it's actually < $225, or half the original price.

I mean, it's basically free.

(TSS - I'm in Aus, so winter is a-coming!)

[Aderyn2016]

Black. The tan one looks cheap to me, which for nearly $300 is not what you want.

[TSSDNCOP]

Those are my kind of math Koala.

Still tan though, looks great with black in winter.

[olderthanyouthink]

koala my sole mate, yes that basically free!

Ideal world tan. Depends how hard you are on stuff.

[MusicToMyEars800]

it's a hard one but I do like the tan one.

[KoalaDownUnder]

Depends how hard you are on stuff.

Umm. Pretty hard, tbh.

Then again, the tan will look good for both summer and winter, whereas black is a bit 'heavy' with summer clothes. ?

Aaargh!!!

[minipie]

Black. I usually prefer tan too but don't like that particular tan colour, plus the logo is very very obvious on the tan version which I dislike.

[BusterGonad]

Tan, the black is boring imo!

[KoalaDownUnder]

This is not as helpful as I thought it might be.