Talk

Advanced search

Can an apple wear pleated midis?

(18 Posts)
Loftyjen Fri 17-Feb-17 22:34:33

I'm a huge of nork (HH's!) short (5ft 2") apple shaped (worst feature is my 16ish waist, have no bum/hips)
I've seen this skirt in Sainsbury's (and with 25% this wk) and can't work out whether it would look fab or awful/what on earth I would wear with it.. any advice oh wise ladies/chaps?!

burnishedsilver Fri 17-Feb-17 22:40:15

I tried something similar on today. It looked great on the hanger but I didnt buy it because it didnt do my tummy any favours. Based on that I'd say try it on but don't get your hopes up.

Archedbrowse Fri 17-Feb-17 22:48:25

I got something similar, looks the same but silver, this week from a charity shop for £3.

I'm not apple shape, but I am short (5'3) and the length made it look like a little old lady skirt on me; it looked so frumpy not all what I was envisioning.
I've reluctantly concluded this style suits the tall and willowy best. If I'd got it from a real shop it'd be going straight back(and I would have tried it on before buying anyway, should have done this time really!)

spinduffy Fri 17-Feb-17 22:49:36

I'm apple shape and this style makes me look like a mountain!!

TSSDNCOP Fri 17-Feb-17 22:52:14

No

Brontebiscuits Fri 17-Feb-17 22:53:57

I'm an apple. I would say no. And no again.

Notagain2017 Fri 17-Feb-17 22:55:22

I am a pear and I bought a gorgeous one (well it was on the model) and I looked huge.

AmberNectarine Fri 17-Feb-17 22:59:09

Probably not, I think. To look anything but frumpy, so need to show your waist. I am an hourglass size 8 and while I have and wear a couple, they're definitely not my most flattering garments.

ShoutOutToMyEx Fri 17-Feb-17 23:01:38

I'm an apple - size 10 and 5'10 but still an apple - and they don't look right on me at all.

elephantoverthehill Fri 17-Feb-17 23:06:37

DD beanpole yes, I have bought her a similar style dress for her Bday. Me, apple too, no way.

empirerecordsrocked Fri 17-Feb-17 23:09:18

I bought one and wanted to love it but no!

SwedishEdith Fri 17-Feb-17 23:11:01

I'm an apple and, no, not good. They need a flat stomach.

Judydreamsofhorses Fri 17-Feb-17 23:12:27

I think these skirts only work with a small waist/flat tummy, and something either tucked in or slightly cropped on top.

Loftyjen Fri 17-Feb-17 23:26:45

Thank you all - think I knew before posting but wanted to confirm there wasn't a magical get out clause 😆

Really annoying as the material felt gorgeous - so soft and heavy!

elephantoverthehill Fri 17-Feb-17 23:42:25

I know what you mean about the drape, so I suppose you could wear it with a long tunic type top......possibly?

FookyNell Sat 18-Feb-17 00:00:17

Step away from the pretty skirt. Pleats are only friends to twigs.

Us apples have very few friends outside of maternity wear...

chanie44 Sat 18-Feb-17 08:10:26

I tried one on a few years ago. The combination of being short and having s tummy meant it looked horrendous.

user1477282676 Sat 18-Feb-17 08:11:30

As others have said, nope. The only people who can get away with that is those who are over 5.8 and very slim.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now