Help me pick

[NantucketNightbird]

I'm very torn, the brown are replay and very cheap. Which do you all prefer?

[prettypidgeon]

Definitely the first ones, they'd go with more stuff too.

[NantucketNightbird]

The grey?

[MrsLettuce]

It depends entirely on your style.

I'd go with the brown ones myself, they'd work with a few things I like to wear, whereas the grey ones would look dreadful with most things I own. I've plenty of friends who'd choose the grey over the brown though. Also, grey suede wouldn't last 5 minutes on me.

[Thingvellir]

I can see a beige and a brown. I prefer the brown but the beige ones are smarter. They are both nice, depends what you need them for - work or casual?

[MrsLettuce]

yy, the first ones look more beige than grey on my screen too. The op said grey though so I'm guessing that's what they are.

[NantucketNightbird]

I guess they do look more beige I'm a sahm, usually style is a little bit hippy, I usually wear my velvet floral docs. Dresses/skirts with thick tights and cardigans or knit jumpers. I'm 31

[mysteryfairy]

If the brown are very cheap, get both?

I'd get the first pair if I had to pick but your style sounds more like the second.

[NantucketNightbird]

Yes I'm going for the brown I don't think the others would go with as much of my wardrobe, thanks

[Thingvellir]

Good choice! Now could you post a link as I'm rather liking the brown ones for me

[NantucketNightbird]

I'm no good at links but they are 39.99 on tkmaxx, also have them in pewter on there

[Thingvellir]

Thanks!

[MrsLettuce]

yy, the brown ones sound like the right choice in that case.

[MrsLettuce]

Oh! They are fantastic in pewter. Would go with more stuff than brown too. Get the pewter replay ones

[NantucketNightbird]

I've ordered the brown... But the pewter are nice and my foot is generally a 3 I may have to have them (plus the two come to near enough the price of the grey/beige)

[MrsLettuce]

Both would be perfect, well, assuming they're comfortable.