Hi, I saw your other thread and never got round to responding, but thought I would respond to this. My skin sounds very much like yours and interestingly I used this moisturiser for years and years and loved it. However, I was finally diagnosed with rosacea about 18 months ago and tried Metrogel - didn't help much and then earlier this year had a bit of a lightbulb moment and realised that this moisturiser was actually causing my skin to react. I ditched it along with the Liz Earle cleanser and through lots of trial and errror - Clarins/Clinique/LRP/Avene/Simple etc. have found Boots Simply Sensitive cleanser and moisturiser (not the one with SPF) really good.
The redness has massively reduced and finally after 18 months no spots on my chin. I do still occasionally breakout, particularly if I've eaten too much sugar, but my skin is soo much better.
I think (though not certain), that SPF really irritates my skin and makes my eyes sore and I'm currently looking at bismuth oxychloride (?) which seems to be in most makeup, as there is still something irritating my eyes.
I thought I might give the Allergenics a try that DameDiazapam recommends - I have tried many of her recommendations - I think we have very similar skin.