Talk

Advanced search

Quick Vote - which scarf?

(27 Posts)
polyhymnia Sun 04-Jan-15 19:04:38

To wear mainly with my dark navy quilted coat. Not a lover of 'brights'. Want something not too 'woolly' feeling.

This: www.the-dressingroom.com/item/Becksondergaard/O-LOUISELLE-SILK-and-WOOL-SCARF-GREY/86R1#.VKmNAzdyY5s

or this: www.atterleyroad.com/printed-grey-wool-aya-scarf.html

or possibly this www.comptoirdescotonniers.co.uk/eboutique/accessory/scarves/6742-salane-color-charcoal-salane.html

Obviously there are some price differences.

Quick votes, please.

TIA.

FabULouse Sun 04-Jan-15 19:10:57

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Cocolepew Sun 04-Jan-15 19:11:29

2nd. Or 3rd. First is horrible.

HeffalumpsnWoozles Sun 04-Jan-15 19:12:04

3rd gets my vote.

TwentyTinyToes Sun 04-Jan-15 19:13:22

First one

TickleMyTitsTillFriday Sun 04-Jan-15 19:14:15

1st

AmberNectarine Sun 04-Jan-15 19:37:17

Comptoir

LaCerbiatta Sun 04-Jan-15 19:38:26

Don't think any of them go well with navy - sorry

mimiasovitch Sun 04-Jan-15 19:43:56

I love the first one.

dexter73 Sun 04-Jan-15 19:45:53

I like the 3rd one, then the 2nd, then the 1st.

Trills Sun 04-Jan-15 19:48:31

I like the Comptoir (3rd) best

Number one is the nicest, but personally I wouldn't pay anywhere near that much for a scarf. The other two look cheap and flimsy though.

polyhymnia Sun 04-Jan-15 19:54:42

Thanks for votes so far. Seems to be between 1 and 3.

Take the point that both may be a bit sombre with navy but have tried and like the Comptoir one with that coat - and also intend to wear scarf with my khaki parka.
On price, have paid that much before ( L K Bennett, Liky and Lionel) and not regretted it.
Do keep views coming.

MarshaBrady Sun 04-Jan-15 19:55:37

three

gonegrey56 Sun 04-Jan-15 20:22:06

It's the 1st for me

PrimalLass Sun 04-Jan-15 20:23:28

BECKSONDERGAARD - sorry, C&Ped the caps in, not shouting. They just drape so beautifully.

pourmeanotherglass Sun 04-Jan-15 20:27:16

I'm not sure abut dark grey with navy, so I'd go for the lighter one (2).

polyhymnia Sun 04-Jan-15 21:00:13

There is a nice light blue version of the Comptoir one which would be good with navy but think it might be a bit summery for now?

LovelyMarchHare Sun 04-Jan-15 21:03:15

First

AgentProvocateur Sun 04-Jan-15 21:12:14

First one.

MakeMeWarmThisWinter Sun 04-Jan-15 21:12:55

The Becksondergaard one is stunning! That one by a country mile for me.

Don't like the second at all. The Comptoir one is just meh.

WowserBowser Sun 04-Jan-15 21:15:27

First

cardamomginger Sun 04-Jan-15 21:36:16

1. But something paler for more of a contrast might look better, in which case 2 (although still prefer 1). Don't like 3 at all.

nooddsocksforme Sun 04-Jan-15 21:46:00

first one

Bakeoffcakes Sun 04-Jan-15 21:48:41

First one. I think the other two look cheap and flimsy.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now