Talk

Advanced search

If you were my glamorous sister in law...

(62 Posts)
Jennys2108 Thu 27-Nov-14 20:46:25

Would you like this for Christmas?
www.johnlewis.com/dior-iconic-overcurl/p1561269

And if not, what would you suggest (budget about £50)

Thank you....

kaymondo Thu 27-Nov-14 20:56:54

Hmmm depends on how well you know your SIL as make up is quite a personal thing. I have a few friends who will only wear certain brands or v fussy about colours so I tend to avoid buying make up (save for stuff like nail varnish).

Sorry no ideas for alternatives but I shall be watching this thread as I have my own super glamorous SIL to buy for still!

ReluctantCamper Thu 27-Nov-14 20:59:43

Dior makeup is lovely. I have dark brown hair and fair skin and would wear that colour palette, so would be delighted with that present. What's your SIL's colouring?

ThinkIveBeenHacked Thu 27-Nov-14 20:59:48

Make Up is so personal, so I would avoid and go for a bag like this

TheOriginalWinkly Thu 27-Nov-14 21:08:32

I agree that make up is personal. I would suggest the Rolls Royce of cleansers here

BelindaAllWorkedOut Thu 27-Nov-14 22:00:24

No, I'd rather one of these www.johnlewis.com/jigsaw-silk-camisole-top/p1221257?colour=Black

ICantFindAFreeNickName Thu 27-Nov-14 22:16:54

I would not buy the make-up or the cleanser as I think both are very personal. If you know what perfume she likes could you buy her something like an expensive body lotion or shower gel to match, as unless people have a lot of money they tend to just buy the perfume not the matching items. Likewise if she has a favourite skincare brand, she might like the bodycare products from the same company.

Chumhum Thu 27-Nov-14 22:20:05

Yes to the Dior make up and no to the handbag.

SunnySomer Thu 27-Nov-14 22:28:06

Definitely no to the handbag. But the cleanser would go down VERY well with me. Or something like a good quality make up bag.

AgathaF Thu 27-Nov-14 22:44:54

Don't like the handbag at all. The top is lovely, although depends what shape of top she prefers. Cleanser is nice too, although a bit boggling at the price!!

Fcukfifa Thu 27-Nov-14 22:49:59

I'd say a bag was a more personal choice than make up. Especially a mascara and neutral eyeshadow palette.

My sister bought me some ysl mascara for my birthday and I was over the moon with it......fantastic mascara bye and came in nice box etc

Longdistance Thu 27-Nov-14 23:02:17

Yes to the make up. I quite like it myself, and wish someone would buy me something like than.

irregularegular Thu 27-Nov-14 23:08:00

I bought my sister an Eve Lom gift set (including cleanser) for an excellent price from strawberrynet

Eve Lom is well known as being really good - though I agree that it is still a bit risky. My mother bought my sister the cleanser last year and she loved it but it's too expensive to buy herself - so I'm hoping she'll be really pleased.

RJnomore Thu 27-Nov-14 23:08:27

I'd say that's fab you can't go wrong with black mascara and the palette is neutrals. I love dior makeup too it feels sooo nice.

irregularegular Thu 27-Nov-14 23:09:37

I think a good mascara is a nice choice. And eye shadow too if you know what sort of colours she wears.

polyhymnia Thu 27-Nov-14 23:09:44

Really don't think it's ever a good idea to give makeup or skincare unless you know that's exactly what the recipient wants. Way too
personal. I would not be happy with someone else's choice of that or perfume at all as I have very strong likes and dislikes.

I think a Space N K voucher would be a much better gift for someone stylish.

mrsdimmock Thu 27-Nov-14 23:12:10

I agree fcukfifa, i'd prefer to get this ..I think make up is a tricky one to get right tbh..

JustSpeakSense Thu 27-Nov-14 23:12:40

I think make up is a very personal choice, unless you specifically know what she wears and what she needs I wouldn't risk it!

coffeenut Thu 27-Nov-14 23:16:56

yes to the makeup you first linked to. My fave mascara and the eyeshadow palette looks very wearable too.

In terms of posters saying make-up is very personal, I think most S&B gifts are (I personally don't like the bag and probably wouldn't wear the camisole as it's too low cut for me).

Riverland Thu 27-Nov-14 23:19:13

Definitely no thanks to the bag.

The make up you can't go wrong with. A great mascara and good quality neutrals are a lovely lovely gift, I'd be thrilled to receive those. Very thoughtful!

Jennys2108 Fri 28-Nov-14 06:39:35

Thank you for all your replies! Honestly, she's the woman with everything already!

WildBillfemale Fri 28-Nov-14 07:21:45

Yes to the Dior makeup, it's neutral so would suit most. The eve lom cleanser is lovely and luxurious but......maybe a little on the practical side.
The bag - a big NO, Bags are very personal choices so avoid.

Floisme Fri 28-Nov-14 08:17:45

I was once told I was 'looking glamorous - as always'. Just wanted to get that in grin
Anyway despite my glamorous credentials, I never wear mascara (it irritates my eyes). I would avoid any make up or skin care unless it's a brand you know for certain she likes.
How about a spa voucher?

atticusclaw Fri 28-Nov-14 08:19:51

I'm hoping I'm your glamorous SIL. I'll have the Eve Lom cleanser please because I'm running low and its the sort of thing I can't justify going out and spending money on myself.

atticusclaw Fri 28-Nov-14 08:20:31

I'd say avoid a spa voucher. My friends bought me one for my birthday but I don't really want to go to a spa on my own.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now