Talk

Advanced search

Have we talked about Mary Portas' new collection, and if not, can we?

(66 Posts)
EllaDee Sat 08-Oct-11 12:10:37

I know, I know, I should never have expected it to be anything good. Write up in the Guardian:

www.guardian.co.uk/fashion/2011/oct/07/mary-portas-melanie-rickey-fashion-power-couple-intervierw

Is it just me who thought that, um, if you have 100-200 to spend on a dress, it's not especially hard to find one, and the real 'gap in the market' is finding decent grown up clothes for less than than? What did you think to it?

NhameCage Sat 08-Oct-11 12:15:29

I think it just proves how difficult it is to produce a stylish, well-cut and high quality range of clothing and still make a profit. I think we live in an era of wanting it all and not realising what things really cost. Sorry to rant. For what it is worth I think a lot of thought has gone into the collection and it works well.

EllaDee Sat 08-Oct-11 12:21:42

Yes, that's true - maybe I am being harsh. I agree it's better to buy something lovely for 150 than something shoddy for 45 (and more ethical sometimes too). It's just I would have liked some acknowledgement that these prices aren't really 'gap in the market' territory and I didn't see anything I loved in those pictures. Is it that different from trailing round Whistles/Karen Millen/Jigsaw?

Maybe the cut is lovely, I'll hold out hope! smile

Gillybobs Sat 08-Oct-11 14:38:16

There have been a few threads discussing this, I'm not bowled over by it tbh, but then I disagree with Mary that there arent any shops catering for the over 40s already. With a few notable exceptions, I think most shops are fair game, its just that a 40 something would style a blouse (for example) differently to a 20 something iyswim. I didnt see anything terribly different in her collection that Id splash out on. Hasnt quite lived up to the hype imo

EllaDee Sat 08-Oct-11 14:51:40

Oh, I'm sorry. blush I looked back over the last couple of pages and didn't see them.

slug Sat 08-Oct-11 16:07:40

Why, if you are marketing these at women in their 30s and 40s, do you use models with no body fat and no boobs?

Euphemia Sat 08-Oct-11 17:10:04

I think Mary looks ghastly most of the time and her "style" would look ridiculous on larger women, so I'm not impressed.

Her Clarks shoes are clumpy and hideous.

TracyK Sat 08-Oct-11 17:24:54

I loved everything she was wearing in episode one. Can she not just sell that stuff? Though she is very slim so might not work on everyone.

ggirl Sat 08-Oct-11 17:30:55

I really like the look of this dress

cyb Sat 08-Oct-11 17:33:52

My mate tried that dress on in black gg and it was a bit weirdy. cut strangely across neck. i wasnt impressed with the range in the shop- lots of patch pocket blouses. the best stuff was from different designers. Still v v £££

ggirl Sat 08-Oct-11 17:35:31

really?
some of the reviews say it's more suited to curves so was hoping that meant fat grin

LillianGish Sat 08-Oct-11 17:38:25

"Is it just me who thought that, um, if you have 100-200 to spend on a dress, it's not especially hard to find one" - I wholeheartedly agree with you EllaDee. I watched her on TV this week with high hopes, but looking at the collection on the website my heart sank - very disappointing. I think Mary looks great, but what looks great on her wouldn't necessarily look great on everyone else her age and I think the collection just looks like her wardrobe. Maybe she spotted a gap in the market for her (and people who look like her), but I'm not sure it's what everyone else is looking for her. I wouldn't buy a single thing on there. That dress looks OK ggirl, but the neckline is far too high imo and for that price you'd certainly have lots of choice elsewhere.

cyb Sat 08-Oct-11 17:39:06

Well its like a sack really, with a twist in it

ggirl Sat 08-Oct-11 17:40:48

haha I like the sack with a twist
<<heads off to shed for old sack>>

TracyK Sat 08-Oct-11 17:41:08

It looks like the day burger dress I got a couple of weeks ago and it certainly is v flattering.

TracyK Sat 08-Oct-11 17:42:17

Berger

Georgimama Sat 08-Oct-11 17:42:33

I really like the collection but tbh £100 to £200 is not where I see a gap in the market for stylish clothes. £50 to £100 more like.

ggirl Sat 08-Oct-11 17:42:58

special dress for macdonalds?

Euphemia Sat 08-Oct-11 17:55:05

Is there a school run dress, then you change into the Breakfast at McDonald's dress? confused

AnnetteProfit Sat 08-Oct-11 17:56:36

i think all her clothes are based on her shape - tall and angular.
none of that suits tits

cyb Sat 08-Oct-11 17:57:18

She has one cracking tits dress

cyb Sat 08-Oct-11 17:59:05

has sort of almost standy up collar, looks fab on

Euphemia Sat 08-Oct-11 18:01:19

Given that most women round our way look like this, I just don't see it working.

AnnetteProfit Sat 08-Oct-11 18:02:08

cyb

two words

carol Vorderman

lec0rnsillk Sat 08-Oct-11 18:04:09

I like that black dress cyb . Wish they'd show them on a model though.
Isabella Oliver are good for over 40's I think.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now