Please help me decide which pair of boots between these 2....

[PetiteMum]

I love them both! It seems the m and s ones are more practical, but are they frumpy?

m and s

javari

[Karbea]

Prefer the 2nd ones I think, but if you are petite won't they come up very high on your legs?

[ggirl]

I think the M&S ones look very comfy and more of an everyday boot. I like them.
The fly ones are nice but agree they may look a bit puss 'n boots of you're short.

[worldgonecrazy]

I prefer the fly ones.

[KurriKurri]

Is it for everyday wear? - If so I prefer the M and S which do look comfortable.

Actually I don't like the Javari ones - that zip is odd. But I am quite a frumpy person - so feel free to ignore

[SilveryMoon]

I prefer the second ones. They look smarter.
The first ones are nice, I do like them, they look more comfortable, but think I'd go with the second ones.

[madammecholet]

2nd ones.

[RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie]

1st - I really don't like the heel on the 2nd. But am not overly fond of the heel on the first either, so am no help at all.

[gregssausageroll]

Both!

[pink4ever]

I prefer the number 2 but have actually been coveting number 1. Put off by tethers talking about mumsy boots on another thread. God I remember the days I wouldnt be seen dead in shoes with less than a 4 inch heel

[tethersend]

I prefer no.1

pink, I was slating biker boots- they ARE the new mumboot

[BikeRunSki]

M&S ones.

[PetiteMum]

Oh cromer, I might have to buy both! I've ordered the fly ones and will let you know how I get on with them..... As they're smarter was hoping they might do double duty. That's if they aren't too high for casual wear!