Advanced search

Ok you lot. Which coat? Investment issue.

(17 Posts)
moondog Wed 31-Aug-11 05:37:50

This one

Or this?

nakedandangry Wed 31-Aug-11 05:45:54

Hobbs one for me, very classy, beautiful colour. The Jaguer not as flattering.

Papyrus Wed 31-Aug-11 05:46:21

Definitely the Hobbs one. The colour is gorgeous!

moondog Wed 31-Aug-11 05:50:56

I thik so too but Jaeger perhaps better in black than red

raspberryhead Wed 31-Aug-11 05:54:24

Definitely the Hobbs one <<sighs with longing>>

dexter73 Wed 31-Aug-11 06:18:16

I prefer the Jaeger in black. Not sure what it is about the Hobbs coat that I'm not so keen on. It might be that the shoulders look a bit pointy.

peggyblackett Wed 31-Aug-11 06:51:17

Hobbs. I would be buying it myself if I wasn't pg and therefore the size of a small whale!

MissBeehiving Wed 31-Aug-11 07:10:53

I like the Hobbs one but the colour will date really quickly. On balance I'd go for the Jaegar in black -it won't date.

moondog Wed 31-Aug-11 07:14:29

You think?
I don't see how a colour will date tbh.
Not planning to wear it for ever ewither...

noddyholder Wed 31-Aug-11 07:28:56

I like the red one better the shape is nicer. The other I don't like at all esp the colour and cut is a bit old fashioned. Would prefer black though.

MrsCampbellBlack Wed 31-Aug-11 07:42:27

I'd personally wait another month until more coats come into the shops.

They're both ok but not wow - unless you've tried them both on and they look great.

gregssausageroll Wed 31-Aug-11 07:51:25

Jeagar one for me. Really don't like coats that don't fasten fully at the front.

moondog Wed 31-Aug-11 07:51:47

Thanks for feedback laydeez...

ameliagrey Wed 31-Aug-11 07:57:23

Have you looked at

There is a boiled wool coat which is nice- I have the 3/4 version from a year or so back and it's worn well.

I don't like the colour of the Hobbs coat BTW,- too bright.

Recommend you keep an eye out at Jigsaw's- when in stock- and also have a couple of classic coats that look nice.

Bellavita Wed 31-Aug-11 07:59:04

The second one without a doubt. Tis lovely.

knitknack Wed 31-Aug-11 08:06:27

Oh that Hobbs coat is a thing of utter beauty! Hobbs hobbs hobbs, it's gorgeous!

thestringcheeseincident Wed 31-Aug-11 08:08:25

Hobbs coat is lush. I don't love the colour but the style looks perfect.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now