I can't decide between these two pairs of boots!

[PetiteMum]

can anyone help? I am looking for a nice brown boot that I could wear casual and slightly smarter too. Not seen either in person, has anyone else?

Would be sooooo grateful for some opinions thanks!

www.clarks.co.uk/find/department-is-women/producttype-is-boots/subproducttype-is-kneehighboots/product-is-20341832

www.marksandspencer.com/Autograph-Leather-Strap-Riding-Boots/dp/B0051KGJPO?ie=UTF8&ref=sr_1_15&nodeId=835441031&sr=1-15&qid=1313071394

[Bonsoir]

I like the Clarks ones much more than the M&S ones!

[noddyholder]

I can't see them

[NewChoos]

I have got the clarks boots in Black and wore them loads last year, very comfy and versatile.

[worldgonecrazy]

I prefer the M&S boots, I think that they are a bit more flexible and could look either smart or casual.

[FakePlasticTrees]

Prefer the Clarks ones. If you really can't decide, go for the cheaper ones.

[mankyscotslass]

I've got the Clarks ones in black, I wore them a lot last year and loved them.

[RedBlanket]

Prefer M&S, they look smarter.

[sparkle1977]

I don't love either but I would say the M&S are a bit better.

[AmongstWomen]

Clarks

[fluffles]

i think the clarks ones are nicer if you genuinely want a casual boot, but the m&s ones are smarter if that's what you want...

[noddyholder]

Def Clarks

[superjobee]

clarks for sure

[Yr1Mum]

I have the Clarks in black and my SIL has them in brown. The brown ones have an "already worn" kind of finish which increases over time making them look less smart. They're still lovely boots (and I'm happy with my black ones) but if you want them for casual and smart use I'd say go for the M&S ones deffo.

[dexter73]

Clarks

[harassedandherbug]

I like the Clarks ones best, but I like both!

I think the M & S ones would keep better. I have some Next ones in similar finish to the Clarks ones, and after two winters they look very worn!

So if you want to be able to wear them for smart then the M & S ones.

[Clarabumps]

Def Mand S!!!

[PetiteMum]

Hmmm, more votes for Clarks it seems... And now I've seen these!

www.clarks.co.uk/find/department-is-women/producttype-is-boots/subproducttype-is-kneehighboots/product-is-20341377

[mrmistoffelees]

I like both but prefer the M&S boots. I got these last year, or possibly the year before and they have worn really well and are very comfy.