Help me decide

[bubbles4]

Which of these two coats would you have

this or this,have both in my house both are returnable but cant decide which one,so thought I would ask MN.

[MadreInglese]

oooh I like both, but the M&S parka a little more than the superdry one

[purplepeony]

They are both v. different.

2nd one is more country walks and the 1st one more townie.

where and when do you plan to wear them?

[purplepeony]

for me, the superdry one has too many big pockets and unless you are a skinny 8 or a 10 i think it would look v. bulky.

[bubbles4]

The superdry one is a proper wax jacket and thats what I originally wanted (dog walking etc) but its a bit too short ,the M&sS one is longer but looks to me like its a glorified mack but will keep me drier in the rain,ds2 says the M&S one,ds3 the superdry one,dd just rolled her eyes and muttered not another coat and DH just said whichever you thinks best so think I will have to let ds1 decide because I cant make my mind up.

[MadreInglese]

lol @ not another coat

[purplepeony]

if you can afford it, Barbour have some very fashionable stuff ( online) that are similar but they are closer to £200.