Advanced search

Here some suggested organisations that offer expert advice on SN.

Pointing - what's the big deal?

(40 Posts)
MummytoMog Mon 19-Nov-12 10:44:01

Seriously, I just do not understand why pointing or the lack of it is SO serious. Our evil speech therapist made us an oso helpful list of stuff that was ‘wrong’ with DD (aside from the thing we asked help for, that she doesn’t talk much at 3.3 ):

She doesn’t answer her name
She doesn’t make eye contact
She doesn’t play with other children
She isn’t pleased to see us (her parents)
She doesn’t imitate us
She doesn’t play imaginatively
She won’t focus on activities
She isn’t potty trained
She has stroppy tantrums when thwarted by her brother (honestly, which toddler doesn’t?)
She can read
She likes numbers
She likes music
She likes computers
She will watch videos over and over again (this is actually my fault, because I record phrases for her for fun on the iPad, and she watches them over and over again until she can say them. DD saying ‘now is the winter of our discontent made glorious summer by this son of York’ is about the cutest thing ever)

We either disproved these ‘problems’ (first seven on the list), or explained to the Ed Psych why we don’t think they’re a problem particularly (I mean, if she was talking normally, who would be ‘concerned’ because she could read – they’d be telling us we were wonder parents) and so the educational psychologist with a triumphant air said ‘yes, but you say she doesn’t point!’ as though it were a necessary and sufficient condition of an ASD diagnosis. She doesn’t point, she never has. She points at words and letters as she is reading them, and points at objects in books when she is naming them, but she doesn’t point at things that are far away. This is something I was going to bring up with the opthamologist at her next appointment, as I am blind as a bat and poor DD may well have inherited my childhood myopia, but it is not something that concerns me about her behaviour.

I really really resent the way that DD’s teacher, evil speechie (not the nice new ones, they’re lovely) and the Ed Psych are trying to make me concerned about my child. She’s not typical no, but we don’t all have to have cookie cutter children surely? She can be different from the norm without having to have some kind of pervasive developmental disorder? And how is an ASD diagnosis, if we managed to get one which I seriously doubt, going to assist DD at all? If she could talk and was potty trained, I would have absolutely NO concerns about her. NONE. And the potty training is more annoying than really worrying.

Her new speech therapists think she has tons of receptive language, and that she’s picking things up incredibly quickly - she’s had two sessions of PECS and is now going to her book, picking out what she wants, getting my attention and giving me the symbol while saying the word and making eye contact, and is using effectively about 100 symbols including action symbols. Just working on getting her to say ‘I want’. She has also started making and using three part sentences, adapting rote phrases to make new phrases, creating an external narrative when watching TV (Oh no – train running away!) and when playing imaginatively and lots of other brilliant language development, not to mention social development of the kind they like (I couldn’t give two hoots if she plays with other children, she plays with her brother and that’s all I need from a three year old, but she has started playing more with her classmates). So why on earth, given this wonderful progress she’s made, is the fact that she doesn’t point to distant objects the be all and end all of the Ed Psych’s gloomy prognosis for her? I don’t want to get to the point where I’m teaching her to do stuff simply to get the educational psychologist off my back. I probably could teach her (like a trained monkey) to point at distant things, but I honestly do not see why it’s such a big deal? Am I missing something?

BTW, someone told me to get ‘When Babies Read’ on another thread, AWESOME book, thanks for the recommendation!!

saintlyjimjams Mon 19-Nov-12 20:04:34

It's certainly none if my business whether someone pursues a diagnosis or not, and really I have little opinion on the route that 'should' be taken by other families. I've never thought in terms of pro or anti dx. I found the dx helpful as everyone around me seemed unable to accept there was anything wrong, and treated me rather as if I had MSBP, the practical help we received in the early years was less useful maybe, other than the stuff we sorted ourselves.

My point is simply that lack of pointing can be very significant and while the NHS is unlikely to offer anything of much practical use I think they are doing their job highlighting it.

Imitation and learning through observation is very positive indeed. Also makes it easier to introduce things like Makaton which can kick start speech quite effectively.

bialystockandbloom Mon 19-Nov-12 20:32:56

Agree with jimjams too.

Has your SALT told you about PECS, or started using it?

MummytoMog Mon 19-Nov-12 21:50:37

She's had two pecs sessions, which I would consider to be the most helpful thing thus far aside from starting nursery. She picked it up much quicker than I thought she would, given the first speech therapist just sort of shoved a symbol in her face and expected her to do an exchange. We have two therapists there, and as she can read a fair bit, she's picking out symbols very quickly and generalising them. So even though the picture of cheese looks nothing like babybel, the only cheese she has ever eaten, she picked it out straight away and brought it to me when she wanted some cheese. This was a bit of a revelation, as she's never asked for a particular food before, just dinner or banana, which she and DS use as a word for food in general. I absolutely didn't want to do pecs, but I am really pleased with how it's worked out, and apparently we get to do colourful semantics soon, which looks fun.

lingle Mon 19-Nov-12 22:11:01

she sounds like she learns visually?

MummytoMog Mon 19-Nov-12 22:19:14

Yes, although she will mimic like a parrot too, particularly if you use a hilarious intonation or sing.

marchduck Mon 19-Nov-12 23:58:07

MummytoMog, your DD sounds lovely.
I'm not in a position to give anyone advice. My DD (3.10) was showing some red flags from an early age, and I ashamed to say that I did not pick up on them. I knew that she had speech delay, and I had a nagging feeling that things weren't quite as they should be, but I wanted to listen to everyone else around me who told me that she would catch up in her own time, and that I was comparing her unfavourably to her older brother.
My DD has made fantastic progress over the last while, but she has not caught up with her peers. She can now point, talk in sentences, and respond to questions when she wants to. And I am so delighted about this, because I know that she will continue to progress. However, there is still no proper conversation between us. She is popular with the other children at her pre-school, but she has no concept of friendship. It is coming up to Christmas, and the peer DDs of my friends have long lists for Santa - my DD does not.
She has been seen twice by a developmental paed. The last time she said that DD was demonstrating behaviours consistent with ASD, and that she would like to refer her for assessment for ASD, and for assessment by EP. She said it was completely up to us though what we decided. We chose to proceed with the assessment for a number of reasons. Mainly, because the difficulties were there and we hope that the assessment will help will help with provision, but also because all the things that DD has difficulty with, my DS could do without any teaching, demonstrating or explaining - he just did everything intuitively. I suppose deep down that I am worried that the gap between my DD and her peers will widen as she gets older. When all this first started for us, I was terrified of the word autism and had no understanding of it. Now, I know a bit more about it, and I can deal with the (strong) possibility.
You know your DD better than anyone else, and it is completely your decision what you do. As everyone has said, it's not really about being pro or anti dx. It's about taking forward in the best way for your DD. All the best to you both.

saintlyjimjams Tue 20-Nov-12 07:28:26

Yes PECS was a bit of a revelation to us as well. Definitely helps with frustration. If she's imitating well I'd start using Makaton as well. My don has always been very communicative but now in his teens has only developed one clear word. He has a very swish communication aid (for the last year) which is now his main method of communication as he can easily produce sentences with it (and has massively improved his speech actually) but he still uses sign, PECS, google maps, photos, vocalisations, words, and very occasionally typing to communicate.

SALTS often stick to one method, but if you have a child keen to communicate they will, ime use many methods. Makaton is faster than PECS so although ds1 was unable to use Makaton for years as he couldn't imitate it has stuck around even now whereas he doesn't use PECS now unless someone insists.

It was someone on here ( thanks davros) who suggested using Makaton alongside pecs and I've often thought what a good bit of advice that was. Again sign encourages speech.

Handywoman Tue 20-Nov-12 09:57:57

I would like them to raise issues they think are of concern, but the bias towards diagnosis we are encountering, not to mention the out and out lying, is making me feel like DD would be better off without their 'support'.

Is it possible that it's not what these professionals are doing, so much as how they're going about it, ie not being led by your concerns or individualizing the assessments and so on? And where has the lying come in? Is this stuff they have said about your parenting/home etc.? Because if so then this is a huge barrier, which can lead to anger and resentment, which can lead to a breakdown in communication from your part, too. I have been there with nursery school staff (dd with a hx of severely delayed language). It was an emotive experience, and not a happy place.

That said, if you have one prof who is truly your partner in all this (namely your lovely new SaLT), then I would listen to him/her above all others but be mindful to let things unfold with the EP and keep them in the picture. You never know when they might come into their own. Ultimately it sounds like the language skills are coming along very nicely, and over time, everything should come together.

In our case, following angry and resentful experiences with tactless and inappropriate comments from nursery school staff, rubbish developmental paediatric registrar, useless NHS SaLT, in the end we have gone round the houses and ASD is back on the agenda. Aged 7. You really never know how it will pan out.

There is no need to 'teach' your dd pointing, but there is loads you can do alongside your lovely SaLT to maximise your dd's other non verbal communication skills.

It is hard to walk that fine line between being 'critical' and 'forgiving' of these well-meaning profs. But it's worth doing.

Handywoman x

saintlyjimjams Tue 20-Nov-12 10:03:55

Oh the other thing wrt to the 'lying' is use video.

We were told that ds1 didn't make eye contact, didn't understand x, wasn't able to do y. This was in the days before easy videoing so I just argued with them (unsuccessfully - it was important as SALT was refused because he wasn't 'capable of anything' hmm - never mind that that might be seen as a reason to prioritise therapy, apparently not).

However, fast forward a few years and I wanted school to up their game with him a bit. So I videoed what he was doing at home. They said 'wow' and changed the way they worked with him. I use videoing with SS as well.

I never 'tell' the professionals anything now, unless they know your child well they are unlikely to see them as you do (and your child probably will behave differently with them). However, I frequently 'show' them. Just short videos, a couple of minutes is more than enough to make the point you need to make.

MummytoMog Tue 20-Nov-12 10:20:54

With the lovely ST, DD is exactly as she is at home, and at nursery she is generally as she is at home. But with the EP and the evil speechie, even when they were at our house, DD was uncommunicative, tantrummy and resolutely refusing to make eye contact with them. But she was cuddling the new therapist within half an hour and chatting away (in nonsense) by the second session. Partly it would have been the beard on the EP, she's very intolerant of people when she can't see their faces properly, but partly it was the way they interacted with her.

Thanks for all the advice - we generally do film her when she's doing fun stuff, or playing nicely, so we'll make more of an effort to catch her doing the things they say she doesn't. Evil speech therapist has left, and EP might improve on closer acquaintance. Nursery teacher is actually being very conciliatory, although she still doesn't believe that DD reads, even when shown her reading a book she's never seen before. I don't claim she understands it, but she's certainly reading by sight.

Learning70 Tue 20-Nov-12 10:42:32

Hiya the whole thing is a minefield. I felt the same as you at 3 my little man wasn't talking and although I knew he was late, the same thing happened with his older brother who turned out fine by the time he started school. The A word was never mentioned to me in nursery although he was under early years and SALT. Once he started school the sh@t hit the fan and all sorts of behaviours and anxieties came out, along with his speech difficulties, pretty much had the year from hell. The A word was mentioned, or hinted at, pretty early on but I was still adamant it couldn't be that, partly due to his brother and my limited knowledge which only stretched to my friend's son who is completely non verbal etc. To cut a v long story short, he is now 5 and I am anticipating a diagnosis of ASD pretty soon. But tbh the diagnosis seems pretty irrelevant now, we KNOW what his weaknesses are, school are very good and helping with the statementing process and actually I can see him developing and making progress all the time, so diagnosis or not, I am not writing him off but I will have it up my sleeve if and when I need it.All I am saying is, keep an open mind. It can feel like they are criticising your child or you - I swear my child's SALT doesn't have an ounce of warmth or compassion in her soul, the stark way in which she writes her reports - but, I think she just understands the system well and writes in such a way to gain maximum support.

Learning70 Tue 20-Nov-12 10:48:03

Ps forgot to say, my little man is hugely different at home and always made eye contact, played with his brother etc. We are also quite routine led so our way of life doesn't present huge anxieties for him but once in school or somewhere unfamiliar he wouldn't make eye contact, even with me. I think we had unconsciously worked our life around his difficulties as they gradually crept up on us without even realising that we were.

saintlyjimjams Tue 20-Nov-12 10:50:17

Well yes, ds1 once had his private and NHS therapist visit him together in school (when he was in the evil mainstream school). His NHS therapist arrived first and they ignored each other. His lovely private one arrived and ds1 grinned and climbed on her lap and gave her a cuddle. NHS one stated that she didn't know 'he was capable of that' hmm Leaving communication programmes doesn't generally morph into a working relationship with a child.

I do think it's important to note what a child doesn't do easily with therapists etc just because they're unknown, but it is also important that the therapists don't just write the child off because they've never seen them do x, y or z. I think it's much better if everyone working has an idea of the range of behaviours/abilities a child might show. We've been very lucky in the latter years that the people working with ds1 are very aware of his abilities, whist understanding his difficulties. BUt these people are with him day in day out. For everyone else video can make the point.

saintlyjimjams Tue 20-Nov-12 10:51:54

Eye contact has always been one of ds1's main ways of communicating. He uses it in very skilled ways, to play jokes for example. But he won't use it with people he doesn't know.... or he won't use it if he thinks he's being tested, it's an effective avoidance strategy, being skillfully used (but observed as a deficit).

lingle Tue 20-Nov-12 11:04:49

mummytomoog, I'd recommend you start reading Stanley Greenspan. He was the leading child development expert of his generation and believed in building up a profile where you judged a child's abilities according to how they are at their best - as opposed to a deficit-based model. He was a great man and respected by everyone. I think it was reading him that gave me the strength to get the profs. to see things my way. is a good place to start because it is the script of a radio broadcast he made in 2008. He speaks well but his books are challenging - his prose is a bit dense. If the link doesn't work google "the misdiagnosis of autistic spectrum disorders +stanley +greenspan"

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now