Advanced search

This topic is for discussing slings and backpacks. If you want to buy or sell slings and backpacks, please use our For Sale/Wanted boards. We've spent weeks researching and testing slings, baby carriers and baby carrier backpacks in real homes with real families. Read our baby carrier and baby backpack carrier reviews to find out which ones were awarded Mumsnet Best.

Best sling for large-breasted mum with back pain?

(29 Posts)
missuswife Tue 23-Apr-13 22:35:16

My dd is two months old and weights 12 lbs. She is happy in the Baby Bjorn but every time I wear it my back and legs hurt the next day. I am 5'7", size 16 and have huge boobs (36K). I'd like to be able to breastfeed my dd in the sling.

I heard the Baby K'tan is good for all the above. Has anyone tried it? Can anyone recommend a good sling for me?

Also I have tried a ring sling and it did not work for us.

ClearlyDad Tue 23-Apr-13 22:58:49

This is a soldier's suggestion, I hope you don't mind me being blunt.

A different sling probably wont help too much. It's not the weight, it's where you're carrying it. You're carrying all the weight at the front (baby/boobs). The muscles that hurt are the ones that keep you leaning back/upright.

Buy/acquire a cheap backpack with padded straps, and then put 6kg (up this as your baby grows) of weight it in (evenly distributed) Put it on over the baby carrier, and tighten it up so it doesn't swing about. You will then be carrying roughly equal weight front and back (I've slightly over-egged the weight of the baby as I'm not sure what your boobs weigh), and whilst your legs will work a little harder when out on a walk, your postural muscles will not be under permanent tension.

This will work and the pain will go. The first couple of days you will know you're carrying extra weight, but your body will get stronger to compensate.

AnythingNotEverything Tue 23-Apr-13 23:02:44

Bravo Sir. Excellent idea I think.

ilovemountains Tue 23-Apr-13 23:04:24

Or get a buggy!

ClearlyDad Tue 23-Apr-13 23:06:32

As an aside, if reliant on shank's pony to get to and from the shops, it can be a good idea to make your backpack weight up with tap water in disposable/reused bottles. When you get to the supermarket drink some water and throw the rest away, and fill up with shopping. This will let you carry far more shopping than with carrier bags alone.

missuswife Tue 23-Apr-13 23:08:12

Thank you for the suggestion ClearlyDad. I get what you're saying. I have been thinking that an African-style sling worn across the lower back might be more comfortable for just that reason, except I would feel weird wearing my dd on my back where I can't see her.

Your suggestion would probably work but it would be inconvenient to carry that extra weight around for no reason (besides comfort.) I also have to carry my handbag too. I might have to give in and stick to the pram, as dd will only continue to get heavier.

TolliverGroat Tue 23-Apr-13 23:10:43

Mmm, but in addition the Bjorn just doesn't distribute weight well. It tends towards dangling the baby from your shoulders.

Personally (but I'm only an E cup) I tend to use a stretchy wrap until they get to 4/5 months (you can spread out the fabric over your shoulders to ease the pressure, and if it's tied properly (with baby high enough) then much of the weight is transferred to your hips). and then switch to a mei tai (to give more structure).

ClearlyDad Tue 23-Apr-13 23:17:42

In my defense, I don't have boobs, which seem to be a major factor... and I have spent many years carrying extra weight round "for the sake of it" (or at least that was always my impression of why our PTI asked us to do anything!)

orderinformation Tue 23-Apr-13 23:20:44

Kari-me sling brilliant for boobs and ok for back pain.

QuintessentialOHara Tue 23-Apr-13 23:23:49

Why a sling at all if you are in pain? You dont have to wear your baby in a sling just because it is fashionable if your body is hurting! Use a pushchair!

Limelight Tue 23-Apr-13 23:32:54

Baby bjorn's are the devil's own nightmare for back pain I think. I had one with DS and ended up ditching it for a pushchair after about three weeks.

I carried DD full time however because I used a moby wrap and an ergo (which I still use periodically in fact - she's 3).

I too have reasonably substantial boobage and suffer from lower back pain. No probs at all with these slings.

TolliverGroat Tue 23-Apr-13 23:33:06

I must have missed the post where the OP said she was a slave to fashion hmm. I wore my babies in slings (a) because DC1 hated prams/pushchairs with a passion (and he could summon up a lot of passion) until he was a toddler and (b) it was much much much much much much easier on the tube, train and buses (and navigating around shops and cafes).

The Bjorn is notorious for causing back pain. If someone uses a thin teatowel to take baking trays out of the oven and burns themselves would you suggest giving up on cooking ("you don't have to cook just because the Great British Bake-Off has made it fashionable", perhaps?) and eating out instead, or replacing the teatowel with an oven glove that does the job properly?

WouldBeHarrietVane Tue 23-Apr-13 23:34:44

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

QuintessentialOHara Wed 24-Apr-13 00:02:36

Not sure you can compare using a pram for your baby to buying ready meals, dont be daft!

BlastAndDalmatians Wed 24-Apr-13 00:07:17

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

TolliverGroat Wed 24-Apr-13 00:09:25

Not sure you can dismiss all slings on the basis that one particular brand that is almost universally acknowledged to be crap and cause back pain is... well, crap and causes back pain, don't be daft!

(Not that I mentioned ready meals, as it happens)

missuswife Wed 24-Apr-13 01:35:04

I've heard that about the bob, sadly after I bought it and too late to return it.

Seems like carrying the weight on my hips would be more comfortable. Can anyone provide specific links/brand & model info for the various suggestions?

Trust me, am anything but fashionable. Just want my hands free to get things done.

Cravingdairy Wed 24-Apr-13 02:11:37

Is there a sling library in your area? They would be able to let you try different types. There might also be a babywearing consultant who could give you a tutorial.

If these aren't options you can hire slings from Slumberoo online.

Put the BB on ebay!

Meringue33 Wed 24-Apr-13 02:50:15

I have the Closer wrap sling and it seems to distribute weight well, the Wrapsody also worked. I also have big boobs and a terrible back! Tho these slings were good for back pain may now give up due to knee pain as haven't shifted that pregnancy weight and baby is only getting bigger!

PurplePidjin Wed 24-Apr-13 04:45:09

Put the BB in the bin more like! You want a carrier that hold the baby underneath from knee to knee, and that spreads the weight between your hips and the strong muscles on your shoulders. Don't bother with forward facing carries either, they mess with your centre of gravity

Buckle brands worth looking at: Connecta, Ergo, Manduca, Beco

Same shape but ties not buckles, look for a mei tai (Palm and Pond are cheap but small so won't last long)

Or look at a woven wrap sling - ultimate adjustability and various carries so you can pick one that suits you.

Wtf is the idea of carrying a whole load of extra weight?! Just get it distributed properly in a product that actually does the job hmm

Limelight Wed 24-Apr-13 06:32:25

Yep I thought that was pretty strange. Because obviously the thing you want to do when you're carting a baby and all it's associated weight around is to carry a load more unnecessary weight. wink

Or you could bin the baby bjorn and get one that works. I'm starting to think that new parents should get a health advisory notice about the bloody things.

If you want something that sits on your hips, get an ergo. smile

MrsHoarder Wed 24-Apr-13 06:47:00

I had to get an ergo at this stage enormous baby outgrew bb and the relief on my back was incredible. He goes in it for back carries now and is still comfy.

PurplePidjin Wed 24-Apr-13 08:02:18

It's not that they out grow the baby bjorn types, it's that those type of carrier aren't fit for purpose unfortunately the stockists won't listen, the recent webchat with Mothercare proved that angry

pootlebug Wed 24-Apr-13 10:19:44

I wouldn't get an Ergo because you'll need to use the infant insert for a while longer yet, and 1) it is warm in hot weather and 2) there is a stage where the baby is too small for the carrier without insert and too big for it without that is annoying.

I second the suggestion above to go to a sling library or meet and try some things to see what is comfortable. You can put your postcode in here to find what is local to you: Different shaped people suit different things (so even if someone says 'I have big boobs and used X' they may have a longer back than you, or a shorter one, or a bigger baby, etc). You don't have to use a carrier with a waistband to spread weight better....if I want to carry my nearly 4 year old or my 5 year old the comfiest thing for me (not necessarily for everyone) is a woven wrap, which doesn't have any kind of structured waist. A good sling will hold your baby very close to you, so that their centre of gravity is very close to yours. The Bjorn holds the baby slightly away from you resulting in upper back pain for many people using it. A stretchy wrap or good-quality mei tai type carrier would not have that problem.

ClearlyDad - I get what you're trying to achieve with the weight thing, but you can achieve more by making sure the sling works to hold the baby's weight in the correct way. I wouldn't recommend that someone 2 months post natal carry around a significant amount of extra weight....they are likely to still have their joints affected by the hormone relaxin (especially if breastfeeding) which will make them more prone to injury.

ClearlyDad Wed 24-Apr-13 11:05:18

Yeah, as I said, my focus was on solving the problem... Interestingly, for a large, broad shouldered, boxing dad... baby bjorn carriers seem just right!

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: