Hello,
I'm looking for opinions about how strong my appeal case is as we currently live overseas (not crown servants) so attending the hearing will be difficult and costly. We have these options:
- pay for flights back to the UK and take holiday from work to attend the hearing in person
- pay a solicitor to represent us (it seems this is not received well by panels)
- ask one of our son's Grandparents to attend in our place (in the nicest possible way this may hinder, rather than help us !)
The house we own (and will be living in by Sep) is a mile from the school. The furthest successful applicant lives 13 miles away. The school we have been offered is also a mile from our house so we can't argue distance is an issue. We didn't get a place as our application was late and our overseas address was used - I accept this, just giving a bit of background.
Our appeal will be based on the following:
(1) The school's PAN does not align with its actual capacity.
The school (an academy) has recently built a new building which news reports say will be ready to use this June. The news articles say this will increase the capacity by 60 pupils. However, no increase has been made to the PAN (209 per year). The D of E website says the capacity (before the new building has been taken into account) is 1045, in May last year they had 957 pupils on roll.
(2) The school offers a more comprehensive education in my son's specialist subject than the one offered. My son is particularly good with technology, specifically coding. I appreciate this isn't (yet) measurable like sport, music or even other academic subjects. However, he applied and was accepted into a 'hard-to-get-into' coding club at his current school and the school we're appealing for offers a coding club too (the one offered doesn't). I can provide a copy of his acceptance letter into the club. The preferred school also offers 2 different KS4 ICT qualifications, while the offered school only offers one.
(3) Other (less compelling) arguments such as friendship groups and an oddly reassuring message from the school about getting a place
There is the existing friendship group argument but I understand this holds no sway. There is also some surprising advice re admissions on the appeal school's website, suggesting that it's unlikely anyone would be unsuccessful, eg. " in recent years we have been able to offer a place in Year 7 to everyone who wanted one". I don't know if this will indicate a flexibility on the part of the school to the appeal panel?
Anyway, I hope for a few viewpoints on the strength of this appeal which might help with our decision making.
Many thanks in advance