Anyone used a solicitor for a school appeal?(58 Posts)
Our son didn't get any of his three choices and had been allocated a brand new school miles away in a very run down high crime area. The school is just six portacabins at present and there won't be permanent buildings for over another year. We are appealing for his first choice which is massively oversubscribed and allocates places at random from throughout the county. We are thinking of hiring a solicitor to help us with the appeals process but wonder if having a solicitor represent us at the appeal will work against us with the panel. Has anyone ever used a solicitor for appeals? Was it worth the money? Do you wish you'd just done it yourself? Amy info would be most helpful!
I can't imagine why you would want to pay for a solicitor. The whole appeals process is designed for parents, it's not like a tribunal or family court.
You can't appeal against your allocated school, only why you should have been given a place in your chosen school against the admission criteria. Are you on the waiting list for your chosen school, because there may be a lot of movement over the next few weeks. Take a look at the advice given by prh47bridge and tiggytape who know the system inside out (apologies if I've missed some of the other experts).
There are two sides to this. If you do not believe that you will be able to give a concise sensible set of reasons why your child should have a place then there might be good reason to use someone like a solicitor to do it for you, who can remain calm and collective.
If however you are capable of doing this yourself then my experience as a Chair of admission appeal panels is that unless you use a solicitor who is an educational expert they do not usually do a particularly good job. They tend to assume that if they nitpick away at detail that they will create reasonable doubt but the whole basis of the appeal is to balance the two arguments and so it is on the basis of what is more likely. So they expend vast amounts of energy creating a smoke screen that is usually of no help to the parent in the appeal. They will also cost you a small fortune.
Assuming you are appealing based on balance of prejudice and not a legal infringement of the admissions code, I would echo the previous posters. I also sit on appeals panels.
A solicitor will have a tendency to see everything as a legal nuance to be argued, whereas your appeal will rest on how you well you can show that your child needs this school and that the prejudice to the school is outweighed by that need. Only you can know your child and their needs well enough to do this.
Appeals panels are used to parents being nervous, or not having the arguments off pat. A solicitor is highly likely simply to cost you a lot of money and run the risk of being at best irrelevant and at worst an irritant.
I generally recommend against using solicitors. Very few are experts in school admissions. Even some of the leading education lawyers are hopeless when it comes to admissions. I have come across far too many cases where solicitors have given extremely poor advice to parents. As others have indicated, solicitors who haven't got experience of admission appeals sometimes approach the hearing as if it is a court of law which can irritate the panel. They won't decide against you just because they don't like your lawyer but it won't help.
Of course, a solicitor or similar who has experience of admission appeals can be useful if you don't feel able to present your case yourself. If you go down this route make sure you check that they have worked on admission appeals in the past (and, ideally, have won some of them!).
If you want to present your case yourself you will get a lot of help from the experts on Mumsnet if you post details of your case.
Agree with the others. What you need to do is show how that one particular school is the most appropriate place for your child on the basis of your own individual child's educational needs and that those needs will not be met anywhere else. You are the person best placed to be able to argue that.
The panel will be sympathetic to the fact that you are nervous, that this is important to you, that you might not phrase things using key words because you don't know what they are and will work from the assumption that you know your child best.
What they won't appreciate - and what a solicitor will often do -is a minutae filled takedown of allocation policies or other irrelevancies.
So tbh I wouldn't bother. What will back you up better are statements from people involved in your child's education or welfare setting out how your chosen school is the one that will meet his needs. And you honestly don't need a solicitor to get those.
I actually found the appeal process very intimidating. Just me, across a very formal table with 3 panel members, the council person, and a scribe.
I have a phd and am used to presenting arguments, but i think it was the formality and freaking length of the whole thing that bothered me. And the fact that the school obviously had done this before and had their arguments down pat, pages and pages of them.
I think a person with experience of appeals would have been very useful. Not necessarily a lawyer, but someone to read through all the schools stuff and walk me through what i needed to do and say, how much of it was a genuine argument, and what was filler fluff.
Business opportunity prh47bridge? ;)
I left the panel with the feeling that if the school had it so bad and couldn't pull their finger out their arse to manage class sizes and resources, i didn't want my child there anyway. Some of it was incredibly petty. One of them said the classroom was so crowded they couldn't fit the teacher in!
Business opportunity prh47bridge?
My wife keeps telling me I should offer my services for a fee! However, having spent years telling people to do it themselves if possible, it would feel a bit hypocritical to offer a service and I certainly don't want to stop offering free advice on Mumsnet. I am vaguely wondering whether it would be worth producing an online course on how to do it yourself.
Some of it was incredibly petty
If the admission authority is throwing the kitchen sink at a case it normally means the case to refuse admission is weak so they are adding anything they can dream up in order to strengthen it. I would hope that an appeal panel would see through this but, inevitably, some are taken in.
If it's oversubscribed and allocates places randomly then on what grounds are you appealing?
Are there other schools you'd consider? Get on the waiting lists for all of them.
I am a solicitor. I did the appeal for my son's admission myself (ticking the are you using a solicitor in the No box!)
It was the most nerve racking thing I had ever done as the outcome mattered personally to me. This is despite having been a solicitor for over 15 years at the time!
I approached the paperwork as a lawyer though, read and reread. Made sure my arguments were arguments that an appeals panel would consider (rather than as people say above - nitpicking etc). I was also incredibly lucky that I had advice from a friend's mum who sat on appeals panels.
We got out place. Phew!
Good luck - there is some really brilliant advice from various posters on here - prh47 knows her stuff.
If it's oversubscribed and allocates places randomly then on what grounds are you appealing?
Appeals are not just for mistakes. The OP can appeal on the basis that the disadvantage to her son from not getting a place at this school outweighs the problems the school will face from having to cope with an additional pupil.
hi prh47bridge, We have decided to try and do this ourselves as we just cannot afford professional help. I tried to look for details of the PAN for the school today and others have mentioned I need to look into the past numbers of pupils (in relation to whether results went up or down due to extra pupils) and also square footage of space etc. Am starting to feel overwhelmed as I could not find this information via a google search. Are there specific sites where I can find this information and also would the school have to provide me with the information if I asked for it?. I feel like I am just reading reading reading lots of stuff and not able to actually get the individual information we need to put in our appeal.
The school must provide you with relevant information to aid your appeal - do ask them.
I'm so glad you aren't using a solicitor. There really isn't a need to. Try to remember that the panelists are all volunteers who have been trained to consider each case fairly and impartially. If, at the end of the appeal, they genuinely believe that adding another child to the school will cause more harm (prejudice) to the effective education of the existing children at the school than it will to refuse your child a place, you will lose, no matter how eloquently you argue your case. If, however, having heard the arguments and seeing any evidence, they genuinely believe that the harm (prejudice) to your child by being denied a place at this school outweighs any difficulties it may cause the school in fitting him in, you will win, no matter how faltering and inelegant your argument is. Because that is the job of the panel.
Remember that you are arguing for the appeal school. Try really hard not to mention portacabins, rough areas, high crime, new schools, etc. - The official stance is that all schools deemed operational are suitable to educate all children and a panel cannot be seen to agree that a school is unsuitable for a child, so don't try to convince them. Instead, focus on what your school of choice does do, does have, does provide, does offer, etc. - positive, positive, positive.
You can ask questions in writing and the school should provide the answers. If they can't, the LA must. Send a polite email.
"a panel cannot be seen to agree that a school is unsuitable for a child"
I should be more careful - I mean as an establishment. There may be certain social reasons why it is blatantly unsuitable, such as a child suffering a sustained bullying campaign with a school move, then it happens that both primary schools feed into the same secondary school. Or a social worker parent who works in child protection work having clients at the allocated school, which may put the child at risk. Or a child placed through kinship care (no looked after child priority) is allocated to a school where a relative's child attends and can't be identified for their own safety.
But in general, all schools are deemed 'suitable', even ones that are in special measures.
In addition to the great advice here it is worth looking at elevenplusexams.co.uk. Look on their appeals forum. Although predominantly aimed at selective appeals there are some useful checklists for oversubscription.
PAN might still be available on the LEA website. You will get the school's case a few weeks before or if you can find anyone who has appealed before they may still have the paperwork and some advice. Your head might know someone or ask around those with older siblings.
Also look through the clubs offered at the schools you want and what they will offer. Focus mainly on why it is a good fit for your ds.
I went through the hell of two failed appeals for the same school and we had the option of possibly using a solicitor for the second one, i however found prh47bridge
He is amazing and very discreet, We did not win our case due to "petty" reasons too I believe despite lots of evidence and even camhs came with us to support ds, we were told as he is tall it may cause a problem!
The headteacher blatantly lied about funding for new buildings etc and ultimately a solicitor wouldn't have done better than my amazing brother, we had a brilliant case but it wasn't to be.
You need to live and breathe this appeal and believe in your case, get as much evidence to support you, remember not to bad mouth the other schools and above all, remain calm and do not let them rush you like I was rushed.
Very best of luck, fwiw, my ds is now in year 9 in a school that has turned itself around massively and is doing extremely well and would not move to appeal school now he tells me
I got loads of bumpf from admissions that was from the school about fire escapes, square footage, numbers of Teaching Assistants etc.
Holymoly- we asked the school for numbers for each year and they were all over PAN, some quite a lot over.
A good question to ask is " have there been any accidents say in the corridors due to the overcrowding you are alleging?" And the answer is very likely to be no.
It's a common statement that schools make.
Please ask the for any information that is not covered in the case that you will receive from them.
Are there specific sites where I can find this information and also would the school have to provide me with the information if I asked for it
The admission authority (the LA if it is a community school or VC school, the school itself if it is an academy, free school or VA school) must answer any reasonable question you ask to help prepare for your appeal.
Zoflorabore - Thanks for the reference! Glad I was able to help.
P.S. OP - I am also glad you have decided to do it yourself. Good luck and feel free to ask if you need any help/advice.
Phew, lots to think about! I am so not legally minded but I guess I'm going to need to just get my head together and try and make this work. Thanks guys. Keep the great advice coming!
Hi I would really welcome some advice...dd was not allocated first preference back in March 2017 but was placed on waiting list for school. She is currently in the high teens on the list but it will be disbanded at the end of December. We didn’t appeal straight away as we hoped she would get in from list. The over subscription criteria is in relation to proximity to school. The current school she is at is rated outstanding but Dd is suffering emotional and social issues being there. She has changed from an enthusiastic, independent and capable student to one who needs to be taken to school by me every day because she doesn’t want to be there. She is stressed from the idea of being harassed by rival schools as she journeys to and from school. She socially has no peers to travel with or have gone from her own primary school to this secondary school and has tried to join after school clubs but with no success. I have spoken directly to the school about her feigning illness at the weekends and I see her each day reluctant to go in. She desperately wants her first choice school and I am really afraid she may start to develop into an Emotional School Refuser: the transition is proving very difficult. Technically she has not been refused a place but I don’t hold out any hope before the waiting list is abandoned. I have asked this week for an independent appeal. Am I doing the right thing? The first preference school is in Bromley- we live 500 yards away in Croydon. Her friend who lives approximately 30 yards distance between us as the crow flies to the school was offered a place in September. Any advice would be sincerely gratefully received.
The first thing to say is that the waiting list is not necessarily disbanded at the end of December. By law the admission authority has to hold a waiting list till the end of december. After that the school will make their own decision about exactly how they operate a system which allows them to fill any places that come vacant. You need to ask the school what they do.
You have nothing to loose by appealing for a place. However the reality is that you need to have a strong case to put before the panel to have a reasonable chance of success.
What written evidence do you have of daughter feigning illness and the conversations that you have had with school? Your case will be much stronger if you can show that you have been in written correspondence over the issues. However when you appeal you are appealing for a school and not appealing against a school. So you need to establish what are the issues that the proposed new school can resolve that the current school cannot, so for a start a secure friendship base , with friend who lives 30 yards from you but what else can you form the appeal on.
The other point to make is that you only have one appeal per academic year, so you do need to be sure that you have the best possible case before you submit.
Join the discussion
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.Register now
Already registered with Mumsnet? Log in to leave your comment or alternatively, sign in with Facebook or Google.
Please login first.