(WALES) Welsh medium secondary school- pros and cons(3 Posts)
Anyone with children in Welsh medium secondary schools please? I am stil not sure how I feel about them. Are your children happy there? Do you have any regrets? How do you deal with homework help if you are not a Welsh speaker yourself? I'd like to hear your stories please.
DD (currently in yr 9) is in the Welsh stream of a bilingual secondary, so a bit of a half-way house. She studies maybe 2/3 of her subjects through Welsh (basically all the humanities, plus PHSE, music, maybe another?).
We had the choice of English stream in the same school, or fully Welsh medium in another school (although actually to complicate matters she would still have studied science/maths in English). I know lots of friends with DC at the Welsh medium school, so have a reasonable view from both sides.
Homework has never been an issue - TBH at secondary, the actual doing of it is their problem - though in yr 7 we did a fair bit of reminding to make sure it happened. Both in dd's school and the fully Welsh medium one they do lots of vocab work to make sure the pupils have the appropriate knowledge, they're well aware that many/most come from non-Welsh speaking homes.
There were specific school related issues - not language based - that put dd off the Welsh medium option here. They do (as is usual I think for Welsh medium) get extremely good exam results, and IMO they are overly results focused, which means that other things suffer. But of course that's a school-specific issue.
Most of the DC I know who are in the Welsh language school are perfectly happy there. The one language thing that I know has been a problem for some dd's friends (and dc of friends of mine) is that they are very, very hot on Welsh only for the pupils,. That includes situations where, to give examples, a pupil is suffering severe bullying, or has major health problems and is in a meeting including a parent who doesn't speak Welsh. Again, that's a pastoral issue, and I suspect would differ across different schools. There's also a certain amount of Welsh vs English tribalism, though I think it varies greatly by school year.
I'm not a mum but in yr 11 in a Welsh secondary and my sister has joined yr 7 in the same school , both my parents and whole family only speak English so they had the same worries but homework was never really a problem, teachers and friends understand and can help, and there are usually homework clubs at dinner. I found the majority of my homework was given to me in bother lauguages, or it was maths which is self exclamatory. About half of my school have English parents so you ur child won't be the only in this situation.And there always google translate 😉.
I see a lot of kids move school in the first term because they struggle with the Welsh, so if ur child isn't 100% comfortable with Welsh it would be a pain to have to move them mod term.
I might be being biased here but I do feel that Welsh schools are usually more of a 'family' and more caring as everyone shares this ability, and it would be a real shame stop learning after already being educated in the launguage
Join the discussion
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.Register now
Already registered with Mumsnet? Log in to leave your comment or alternatively, sign in with Facebook or Google.
Please login first.