School uniform too strict?(29 Posts)
DD started new school, and the uniform includes a blouse, tie, wool jumper, and blazer along with a skirt and thick tights. The jumper and blazer are both required, and they have to keep both on all the time unless permission is given. Most of the time she spends the entire day wearing both. The classrooms are heated and she says she gets too warm, but it seems to be expected that they stay in full uniform unless the outside temperature is extremely warm. Has anyone else experienced this? It seems a bit extreme.
No. At DD's school:
- jumpers were optional (we never even bought one),
- blazers could be removed in lessons with permission which was freely given.
- Short sleeve shirts permitted all year if desired, DD never owned long sleeves.
- tights we thick or thin, or you could wear ankle socks.
My school has a jumper and blazer but the jumper is optional, to be worn under the blazer when it's cold.
They have to wear their blazers between lessons but can ask permission to take them off in lessons. My room's an oven so at the start of the year I issue blanket permission so I don't keep getting pestered with requests.
The majority of girls who wear skirts wear thick black tights, whatever the weather. Only y7s seem to go for socks.
Jumper and blazer is overkill.
At the school I work at all students are required to wear blazers at all times, although the classroom teacher can give permission for them to remove blazers in exceptionally warm weather. Years 7-9 must also wear jumpers under their blazers. The students used to be able to request permission to remove blazers and jumpers, but it became too much of a disruption in class. Now, the teacher will announce at the beginning of class if they are allowed. I generally give permission in extremely warm weather.
The school I work in has the same rules as Nobles. I've never known a teacher not give permission for blazers to be taken off most just give blanket permission at the beginning of class.
Teach her how to faint. They will soon reconsider.
With 30 students in can become a disruption when you're asked 10-15 times. That's why we switched to a blanket permission at the beginning of class. Like I said, I give permission of it's extremely warm.
Dds has compulsory Blazers and optional jumpers, they have to have permission to take off blazers in class but so far it seems to be forthcoming. Shirts are long or short sleeve, and they can wear any thickness of tights or socks.
How ridiculous, I couldn't stand to be restricted from appropriately judging my own body temperature, it's such a basic thing. So I wouldn't expect DD to be restricted from doing so either.
I think it's mad when schools insist the blazer has to be worn when the classroom is very warm.
DD's school has blazer and jumper (which must be worn in Autumn and Spring terms but is optional in summer), however although the blazer must be worn between lessons they can take them off in class if they wish. Shirts can be long or short sleeved.
At both my children's schools (private) jumpers are optional. Ds hates jumpers so I havnt bothered to buy him a jumper.
Curious as to what the staff wear when the students are in jumpers and blazers.
ridiculous - so the message is that them being comfortable and being able to work at a normal temperature is not a priority?
I really have no idea what goes through people's heads when they make up rules like this.
ridiculous. a rule that needs fighting.
cannot be comfortable or conducive to working. there is no reason for that rule. none at all
My son has to wear a blazer. He would boil in a jumper as well though. Do they have to be thick tights?
I find rules like this completely crazy. There is no good reason for it. How on earth are children supposed to concnetrate and work their best if they are overheating. If these school have classroom temperatures anything like the schools my DC attend most pupils would overheat.
DS1 has just started high school and he hardly ever wears a jumper, not even to walk to the bus stop when it's only 5 degrees. He is only just getting used to wearing trousers after wearing shorts year round in primary. He would hate being that trussed up and hot all day.
This seems to be a bit of overreaction. It wouldn't be much of a uniform if they were allowed to remove everything at will. Businessmen wear suits and ties to work in. I understand that not everyone agrees with uniforms but many schools (and parents) feel that it is best for the students.
Ds2's (grammar) is like this. Blazers even when it's boiling. Lots of boys in hot stuffy rooms sweating in Blazers. Detention for your shirt hanging out. It's all so petty & seems more about power relationships than anything useful. It just means the ones who don't care care even less & the ones who do get end up in a state of constant anxiety.
If ds3 gets his first choice secondary school (please do) he'll be going sonewhere were he'll be allowed to decide how many layers to wear. Luckily. As he's far too shy to ask to take things off (especially if, as in ds2's school asking can lead to a reprimand) but has a habit of throwing up when too hot.
Can't she just ask? I always let pupils take their blazers off. I assume it's not a new school rule though. You signed up to send her there, you can't moan about it now!
We have optional jumpers and compulsory blazers but I have never known anyone refuse permission to remove the blazer. What's annoying though is when they wear a hoodie under their blazers and think we can't see it if they tuck the hood in...
I understand that many adults have to wear suits and ties but I don't see the point of forcing the students to wear a jumper as well. It should at least be jumper or blazer, three layers at all times just seems extreme. When have you ever seen a teacher wearing a shirt or blouse, jumper AND blazer?
I hate the "you signed up to the rules" BS. sometimes there is little choice where you go and homeschooling isn't an option.
in a classroom no one is going to see everyone's busynworkimg so who would even care. it's for no reason other than a power trip. no one's asking to pole dance in a tin foil thong. just remove an item of clothing when it gets too hot.
oh and one persons idea of hot is not important because guess what, some people get hot some people are cold and one person can't speak fir all.
when brain cells and the ability to behave start to grow in cheap polyester they may then have a point. however as it stands eight now it's just point proving nonsense
This does seem very extreme if they aren't being given permission to remove jumpers and or blazers in class. How weird that teenagers aren't allowed to be in control of their own temperature. Males (especially teenage) generally feel warmer than females so might be boiling by the time a female teacher decides it's hot enough to remove blazer. Or a girl who has her period might feel or hotter/colder than other girls. Some people have poor circulation and might be fine while everyone else is sweltering. They might have just finished strenuous excercise and be overheating in their three layers in what the teacher thinks is a moderate temperature. It doesn't make any sense at all, everybody is different! Most schools I know of are compulsory blazer moving between classes and permission to remove in class, optional jumper, and tights or socks option.
Join the discussion
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.Register now »
Already registered? Log in with:
Please login first.