Talk

Advanced search

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide, which can point you to expert advice and support.

Please help me rationalise this

(53 Posts)
Bananahannahblah Wed 18-Oct-17 19:29:48

Ok. We live in as very small house. Dh daughter came here 2 weeks ago as split up with bf. I'm fkin fuming. The house is so small I have no privacy. Dh can't see what the problem is. She is here every evening I just want to run away. I haven't been consulted but dh thinks there are no alternatives. Am I right to be pissed off??

Bluntness100 Wed 18-Oct-17 19:31:52

How long will she be there for and how old is she? It’s your husbands house too and I would expect him to be able to take his child in in when she has no place to go.

Do you have kids?

Bananahannahblah Wed 18-Oct-17 19:34:11

She is 23. Doesn't earn much.
I just feel like it should have been discussed with me. We have a 5 yr old too

Allabitmuchisntit Wed 18-Oct-17 19:43:09

How long is she staying for?

Joysmum Wed 18-Oct-17 19:51:15

Of course she should be able to turn to her father whilst she’s struggling. Why the hell should she not be able to. You’d soon kick up a stink if someone tried to get between you and your child.

Butterymuffin Wed 18-Oct-17 19:52:36

I can see she would need somewhere to go quickly and you couldn't turn her away. Neither can you expect her to go out all the time - if she's staying with you she can expect to spend time there and treat it (respectfully) as her home for now. However you could broach with DH how long she's expecting to stay and what rent etc she should pay if that's longer than the short term.

Bananalanacake Wed 18-Oct-17 19:57:12

Give her a deadline by when she has to move out. She should pay a little rent if she is earning.

Cricrichan Wed 18-Oct-17 19:57:35

Yabu. It's his child and she needs him. I'd like to see you turn your child away!!

thatdearoctopus Wed 18-Oct-17 19:58:22

How will you feel if one day your dd turns to you for help in a similar way? Boot her out?
My children are 19 and 21, so not dissimilar ages to your dsd. Our home is theirs for as long as they feel the need for it to be. Maybe your dh feels the same way, and if so, good on him.

YABU.

Lookingtothehighlands Wed 18-Oct-17 20:02:42

YABVU
She's your dh's daughter. Presumably you would not expect him to turn away your 5 year old if they need support as an adult?

ShoesHaveSouls Wed 18-Oct-17 20:04:31

When your DC is 23 and needs parental support for a while, presumably they'll get it?

ButIDontHaveTheRightShoes Wed 18-Oct-17 20:07:21

There may well be no good alternatives in the first few days after splitting up. It is lovely that her father is there for her, so many men are not after a marriage ends.

I doubt that a previously independent 23 year old wants to live in a tiny house with her step mother.
You could support her to find her independence again.

Be nice. Help her look for a flat share, encourage her to be a bit fussy, don't try to shove her into the first hovel you see. Everyone wins in the end.

Chottie Wed 18-Oct-17 20:09:51

Please show her some kindness and compassion.

Mooncuplanding Wed 18-Oct-17 20:12:38

Where do you want her to go?

Would you be ok with being the reason for a father letting down his daughter?

chipscheesentomatosauce Wed 18-Oct-17 20:14:29

I think it's actually one of the few things that doesn't need prior discussion. I'd say in most families, it's a given that if the DC need somewhere to go, then the first place they should be able to go is home to their parents.

AnyFucker Wed 18-Oct-17 20:14:35

Wow

What a piece of work you sound

fantasmasgoria1 Wed 18-Oct-17 22:11:04

If that was your child in the scenario would you be as pissed off? Bet you wouldn’t

hotbathsdontmeltfat Wed 18-Oct-17 22:28:45

Hello? OP? Not the answers you were hoping for?
YABVU

missbattenburg Wed 18-Oct-17 22:42:28

"Am I right to be pissed off??"

Nope.

In fact, if your DH was pissed off with you I would consider that much more understandable. She is his daughter and she should be able to turn to him for help and he should be free to give that help. Kicking up a storm is reminiscent of kind of 'step mom' fairy tales are made of and most children dread: the ones that expect their spouse to deprioritise any previous children. Just because he is no longer with her mum does not make her any less his child and does not mean you and your son automatically go to the top of the priority list. She is just as important.

DailyMailDontStealMyThread Wed 18-Oct-17 22:45:03

Where do you expect her to go?

Is she ok?

Topseyt Wed 18-Oct-17 22:52:40

If your child ends up without nowhere to go at 23 following a relationship breakdown then I take it you will see her out on the street!

That is what you are asking your DH to do to his DD.

Your living conditions are clearly less than ideal space wise, but surely you aren't expecting him to just boot her out with nothing?

AcrossthePond55 Wed 18-Oct-17 23:01:20

You're being very heartless. I'm sure his DD is hurting and feeling rejected enough as it is, no matter who initiated the split. Give her a chance to recuperate and make her plans.

She should contribute something towards the household, even if it's £10 a month. She should keep her 'space' neat and tidy and help out with the housework.

When you say she's 'here every evening' and you 'have no privacy' does that mean that she doesn't have her own room?

thatdearoctopus Wed 18-Oct-17 23:50:18

You need to understand that everything you feel for your own dc, your dh feels exactly that for his dd. You cannot airbrush that inconvenient fact out of your neat little family picture.

ConcreteUnderpants Thu 19-Oct-17 00:06:49

YABU.
In fact you sound like a total bitch.

Pipsqueak11 Thu 19-Oct-17 00:20:39

Ugh!!! Poor dd - you sound most unkind!

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now