I have NCed for this but I am a long term poster. I am not a troll, and the dilemma I am about to outline is something I am finding very, very difficult. Let me start by saying that I am a feminist, that I have myself been raped, and that I fully understand that questioning the testimony of a rape victim is an appalling addition to the pain of undergoing that crime.
Here are the facts:
- Someone close to me claimed that their boyfriend raped them.
- As a result of this claim, they gained access to a lot of financial assistance/care from a second party over many years. No legal claim was ever made, police were not involved.
- The person claiming rape has longstanding form for lying and for manipulating others for gain.
- The boyfriend is a jerk with abusive/anger management problems, however, no question.
- However, after the claim and assistance was given, the person in question went on meeting the rapist in secret. They were seen very much together by not one but three reliable people on several separate occasions. At the time, they were publicly saying they were NC with the person.
- In addition to this, a number of letters were exchanged between them after the alleged incident, in which there is no indication of any allegation of wrongdoing, and which make clear that the relationship was very much still on between them.
- The boyfriend denies that any rape happened (but I think he would even if it did).
I just don't know what to think. Every instinct of feminist solidarity says that I should stand with this person and that it is a terrible thing to add to the pain of rape by disbelief. But I honestly, hand on heart, have doubts whether they are really trustworthy here, because of the amount that they have gained over the years from the situation (a huge amount of money/care), the continuing relationship after a pretty serious claim of rape had been made, and the form for lying.
WWYD? My tactic to date has been support-with-evasion of the issue, which has led to accusations of denial and being part of the problem. These are totally justified if the incident happened. I honestly don't know if I've done the right thing, or if I've done something really, really bad. I just don't know.