Talk

Advanced search

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide, which can point you to expert advice and support.

A moral imperative to stay?

(21 Posts)
DorothyL Mon 27-Jul-15 23:48:29

If your partner has mental health problems and a history of alcohol abuse, but was now getting better - but the relationship was not a proper relationship anymore - but leaving would mean your partner's health deteriorating, to the extent they couldn't care for the children, but taking the children would mean devastating your partner - is there a duty to stay until the children are old enough?

DragonsCanHop Mon 27-Jul-15 23:56:06

There is no duty to stay if the relationship is horrible and in repairable.

Is it?

DorothyL Mon 27-Jul-15 23:59:59

It's not my relationship. The struggling partner wants to carry on, but the other wants out. What about the children- there is no way things will be good for them if they split. Don't the parents owe it to them?

RealityCheque Tue 28-Jul-15 01:18:51

No. They can leave. There is no duty at all here.

LadyB49 Tue 28-Jul-15 01:36:56

I stayed for 22 years with a h who was civil engineer but unfit to work, who was in bed at least 20 out of 24 hours, and when out of bed paced the floors or drove the car aimlessly. I worked part time but my earnings were taken off his benefits. His social worker did not tell us that his long term sickness would allow me to earn and keep a reasonable sum so each time he came out of psychiatric hospital, he signed on for unemployment benefit and received income support.
The OP would have described me for 22 years.

When I left his family coped for about a year and the he went into hospital care permanently where he remained for about 15 years until he died.
Upon leaving him I waited the requisite two years separation and then started divorce proceedings.
By the time I left guilt was not a factor. His paranoia and other issues just about destroyed me and I'd done all I could.

I would now tell anyone in that position to make the break.

goddessofsmallthings Tue 28-Jul-15 01:41:31

How old will the children be when they reach an age which is 'old enough' and have you considered that living in the circumstances you describe can cause them immense psychological damage which could result in them replicating their dps' behaviour in their adult relationships?

Of course the alcoholic 'struggling partner wants to carry on' because they've become accustomed to making false promises and using their alleged mental health problems and love of the demon drink as a form of control by guilt-tripping their partner into staying with them far longer than they should have done and this is further evidenced by the, also allegedly, recovering alcoholic bleating claiming that they'll inevitably relapse if their partner chooses to vote with their feet and take the dc out of the no doubt toxic atmosphere of the family home.

Regardless of what you personally may believe parents owe to their children, it's clear that one of the dp's has failed to prioritise the needs of their dc, and of their partner, above their love of the bottle and this has now come back to bite them on the bum.

I therefore have no hesitation in saying that the dc will be far better off living in a peaceful and secure environment with their non-alcoholic dp, and the sooner this happens the better it will be for them.

There's no reason why this transition can't be made in a civilised manner and the dc can continue to see their alcoholic dp but, depending on their ages, it may not advisable for them to have overnight stays until such time as there's been a lengthy period of sobriety and evidence that any mental health issues are under control by medication or other treatment.

Aussiebean Tue 28-Jul-15 04:07:52

I would have thought the moral thing to do was to protect the children from an alcoholic abuser with mental health issues.

Also, Not have them watch as said person was in the process of getting better ( which would be very hard and probably involve relapse).

heyday Tue 28-Jul-15 04:36:24

I think our 'moral' duty, if one exists, lies with our children first and foremost; their protection, their happiness.
This sounds like a very complex relationship and hopefully the person concerned can access full advice on the various issues likely to face the family if they decide to separate and can engage the partner's family, friends, professional care workers to offer help for the already struggling partner to lessen the obvious fall out that will arise.
Human lives can be so very sad at times.

DorothyL Tue 28-Jul-15 06:39:18

Does it make a difference if the struggling partner is the wife?

DisgraceToTheYChromosome Tue 28-Jul-15 06:49:47

Not once the children are on solids, as Terry put it.

Footle Tue 28-Jul-15 07:01:34

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

MakeItRain Tue 28-Jul-15 07:07:06

I think the fact that the struggling partner's health would deteriorate if her partner leaves is a big factor in him needing to go. Her health isn't his responsibility. That must be impossibly stressful for him. She needs support to try to become independent. It's obviously a really sad situation, but it does sound like her partner and children do need to leave and set up a stable home, with times arranged for her to be with the children.

DorothyL Tue 28-Jul-15 07:09:53

Ok, sorry for dripfeeding, but things are evolving... Turns out now he has a girlfriend and no plans to take the children, totally unclear how she will
cope... Totally unsure how to help or what to advise!

EhricLovesTheBhrothers Tue 28-Jul-15 07:22:24

Oh god well that's worse- he still has no obligation to stay with her but it doesn't sound like he's meeting his obligations to his children in that case

MakeItRain Tue 28-Jul-15 07:46:30

That's really difficult. So it sounds like he wants to leave both her and his children. I don't think that's really an option for him. His children sound really vulnerable in this situation. Your friend needs to start letting people know (health visitor, GP) so that support is available to her if he does suddenly leave.

Cabrinha Tue 28-Jul-15 07:54:22

I'm finding it a big unclear.
So the wife is an alcoholic with MH issues, unable to properly care for their children alone, and he's got himself a girlfriend and now wants to swan off to his easy new life leaving his kids behind, insufficiently cared for?

That's immoral.

He should leave.
He should ideally have not got himself a girlfriend until he had done so confused
And he should keep his kids with him, enabling as much contact time with their mother as she is able to safely manage and is still healthy for the children.

If I read this correctly and he's planning to just dump and run on his kids, he's an arsehole.

Cabrinha Tue 28-Jul-15 07:56:41

As to how to advise?

If he's a friend at his wits end and about to make a bad choice, I'd talk him into seeing a solicitor to talk about how to ensure he is resident parent for his children, and talk to SS about support for his STBXW.

If he's quite happy with his decision to just dump the kids there, I'd be wondering why I was involved with him at all.

goddessofsmallthings Tue 28-Jul-15 08:08:34

I doubt the fact that the dw is the struggling partner with an h who's taken up with an ow and plans to abandon her and his dc has 'evolved' over the last hours which begs the question of what relation are you to this conflicted family?

DorothyL Tue 28-Jul-15 09:02:21

This is my brother and sil, I am enclined to think my brother is an arsehole but was wondering if I was being unfair.

TheSilveryPussycat Tue 28-Jul-15 11:08:01

Living with him may well have been a contributing factor in her mh - this was certainly the case with me.

He's going to argue that his wife's mh drove him into the arms of OW, isn't he?

DorothyL Tue 28-Jul-15 11:14:42

Yep hmm

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now