Advanced search

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide, which can point you to expert advice and support.

Which dating site is best? Opinions please..

(66 Posts)
MumWithCamera Fri 10-May-13 11:27:06

I have a male friend who's had a bad time of it with cold-hearted ex-gf last year and he's now single and looking for love. He's signed up to Plenty of Fish but doesn't seem to be having much luck finding Mrs Right.

I dont have any experience with dating sites, so wonder if its this website that's the problem - should he try Match or eHarmony instead? If anyone has positive experiences which sites do you recommend for finding a love-match? So far he's had a few dubious people - one was saying she wanted to come live with him when hadn't even met him and only messaged him twice hmm

Thanks in advance for suggestions - you will (hopefully) be turning my friend's life around and bringing a bit of happiness smile

And before you suggest it - I am happily with DP and we have a DD together, so I'm not in the running! Just looking to help a friend!

MsFanackerPants Sat 11-May-13 02:03:25

Met DP on the Guardian. Together 3 years and I'm expecting our first baby in November. POF was good for a fling and had a few dates through OKC.
As well as the advice about pictures etc be prepared to travel for dates. I lived in a big city but was willing to travel upto 50 miles or so. As it turned out DP lived 5 miles from me and knew my best friend when we were all teens (more embarrassingly he also knows 2 of my drunken shags from uni)

Squeegle Sat 11-May-13 07:49:32

Waffly, that did make me chuckle- that's exactly what I thought!

I have chatted to, but not met, a few nice people on OK Cupid. I quite like it, I like the questions and the matching thing- but as I say not met anyone yet. There are fewer people who just message Hi Babe, how are you? than on POF. But no harm in joining both I wouldn't have thought; they are free after all.

I joined a site called single with kids. It was £25 I think for one month- what a waste of money- it's syndicated I think, so there are all sorts of people on there, most of whom are not single with kids (one of them joined a site called, yes really, and was wondering why there were not more skinny people.)So avoid anything run by this group- I think they're called global personals.

I did meet a nice chap from POF, but he's not for me- I guess it's all the luck of the draw. I am 47, so not what a lot of these geezers are looking for, but at the end of the day, were only looking for one aren't we? I think the trick is not to take it too seriously.

People start talking, stop talking, disappear, don't reply, etc etc. it's not real life really- just a way to hopefully start something. And as long as you don't take it to heart, it can actually be great fun! I must say I am quite enjoying it.

WafflyVersatile Sat 11-May-13 11:28:48

Many years ago I did love@lycos which doesn't exist any longer. I went on a number of dates. Very few of them unhinged. didn't meet any boyfriends but had some nice evenings out. All but one were somewhere along the line to balding though...

I like okc as it's quite fun to explore the site and even if I've not really gotten into dating (it's me, not them) I did meet a 99%er and although there wasn't going to be any romance they had obviously matched us pretty well.

On any dating site you have to expect to be messaged by entirely unsuitable men who have not read your profile. It's ok to entirely ignore them. And I never use the chat function as it invariably turns into them trying to get you into sexxxxy talk after about 3 seconds.

IGuessIHadYourLeavinComing Sat 11-May-13 17:41:33

I don't have that much OD experience, but I will say that I've found POF absolutely woeful and agree with everything Velvetspoon said about the men on there - IME of course.

I've been on POF for about three months (I'm in my late 40s, which doesn't help), had a fair bit of interest and one disastrous date, which still makes my skin crawl when I think about it! I never send messages now because barely anyone replies... even when I feel that I'm punching well below my weight.

It's worth a go because it's free, but I would tell your friend to keep his expectations really low then he's got nothing to lose.

Not sure about the paid sites, I've had very mixed reports, but I may try one of them myself for a few months and then knock it all on the head.

Anyway OP, I hope your friend has more luck than me.

Missiehappy Sun 26-Oct-14 21:09:21

Avoid RSVP - they are misleading and dishonest. I asked them if there were plenty of guys my age before joining. They lied & said that there were. After paying over the almost �1000 joining fee, I discovered that there were very few guys my age & none that matchedd my criteria - reasonable job. Now they refuse to give me back my money. Their contract states that they cannot guarantee introductions. I was very clear when I asked of there were guys my age who had reasonable jobs when before I joined up, they lied & said yes, I would not have joppoined had they been honest with me. Please all, do not join RSVP!

Elidillon Thu 05-Feb-15 12:44:09

RSVP worked wonders for me, matches were great good quality guys I disagree with the previous post I found them fantastic. I will not hesitate to take advantage of my lifetime membership if I need to in the future ��

penniechews Thu 05-Feb-15 12:51:02

Nobody has mentioned Tinder but in London most single people seem to use it, not as just a hook up site.

Fantasmicos Thu 05-Feb-15 14:27:25

My male friend is on E Harmony & says it's rubbish. Keeps pairing him up with people who he has nothing in common with at all. He did manage to get a few shags out of it apparently but was looking more for a long term relationship. He's a really lovely easy going gentle guy with a great job so not exactly hard to get on with. He also says it keeps crashing etc. I'd probably swerve it on that basis. I think the bigger sites are better but you need to filter the weirdos out. Lots of horror stories about people using photos from 20 years ago so keep an eye out for any outdated clothing in the pics, dead give-away!!

Fantasmicos Thu 05-Feb-15 14:31:29

I also had a look recently out of interest, on a site called (read about it on here actually, someone had discovered their husband using it) and it was obviously a fake site where the profiles are set up by the site owner - it was obvious as we live in a posh village in Surrey but there were far too many 'matches' for such a small place, from people who obviously didn't live here, also every female profile on there claimed to be into anal sex whereas in the UK population the true figure is definitely under 5% so another indicator that it's a fake site - recommend you AVOID.

umbongoumbongo Thu 05-Feb-15 15:06:20

I met my lovely other half recently on Tinder. I found Muddy Matches very slow due to nobody wanting to pay (I paid for one month) and I chatted to a few nice people on POF and have several friends who have met on POF.

I rejoined Tinder in Jan after a break from it over Christmas as I liked the more instant messaging rather than waiting days for email ping pong on other sites. I think there are some decent, genuine people on Tinder (it isn't just a hook up site) although I was lucky as my guy had been put on there under protest by a younger relative and I was his first ever Internet date. The way it matches friends and interests in common from your Facebook account is handy too.

I met my ex on Match 4 years ago but I think since the explosion of free sites and apps it isn't as busy as it used to be from what I have heard.

Xenadog Thu 05-Feb-15 19:47:33

EHarmony worked for me and DP. The free sites, I found, do tend to have rather a lot of undesirables on them and Match might be the biggest but can be a bit of a meat market.

I guess you just have to choose what suits you but I can definitely recommend eHarmony.

nooyearnooname Thu 05-Feb-15 19:55:02

I met my OH on Guardian Soulmates (5 years ago), and one of my friends also met his fiancee on there and she is stunningly gorgeous and lovely. I did also meet lots of nice interesting men on there, a couple of which I had short termish relationships with - nice guys but not right for me.

I also did Match for a bit and tbh there were a lot of creeps. Dating Direct was the same but I don't think that exists any more. I've never done PoF but I know people who have and I've not heard much positive about it.....I get the impression that a lot of people use it for hookups rather than relationships (not meant to offend anyone who did meet their OH on there, just what I've heard).

nooyearnooname Thu 05-Feb-15 20:01:43

I should also say that neither me or OH read the guardian (maybe once in a while when we can bear to pay 3 quid for a paper on a sunday), so it's not full of guardian readers (reading the guardian not being a problem obvs but recognise that some people might have ideas about it that might put them off using it, but shouldn't)

megamegalove Fri 28-Oct-16 12:42:19

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

EvansOvalPies Fri 28-Oct-16 12:53:51

DD is on Tinder, after an acrimonious split from her boyfriend. A friend of hers set her up on it for a laugh (she wasn't too keen on the idea, it was a bit of a joke) , and tbh, I was very folded arms and bosom hoikey about it initially, threatening to follow her and demanding details. But she has met some very lovely young men, many of them are friends with mutual Facebook friends of hers, who in turn provide useful and helpful info regarding the type of person DD's date might be.

My sister met her husband on a dating website (can't remember the name of it though) as she was a nurse working very antisocial hours and quite shy. They now have two teenage children and will be celebrating their 25th Wedding Anniversary soon.

Just, whichever you decide to go for, make sure you are safe and someone knows where you are going, give them some details about who you are meeting, etc etc.

Have a lovely time

EvansOvalPies Fri 28-Oct-16 12:57:37

Have just reported Megamegalove as spam. Twats

PopFizz Fri 28-Oct-16 13:01:58

I did POF. On and off for 3-4 years. Met a couple of ok guys I dated for three months or so. Met a fair few weirdos - but no more than I would have met in pubs and clubs if I hadn't had the commitment of work/kids. Met DP three years ago, and couldn't be more perfectly matched.

EvansOvalPies Fri 28-Oct-16 13:49:19

Oh, after nearly an hour after reporting Megamegalove's post, it still remains. Is it now permitted , MNHQ for people to advertise their wares on threads? I thought that was only restricted to sponsored pop-ups.

I will report again, just in case you missed my first report.

LisaMumsnet (MNHQ) Fri 28-Oct-16 14:34:42

Hi there, just to let you know we've zapped Megamegalove's post - we had a very high number of reports about various things on Mumsnet today so it just took a little while to get to this one. Thanks for reporting it.

EvansOvalPies Fri 28-Oct-16 15:01:39

Excellent - thank you, Lisa

Princesspinkgirl Tue 01-Nov-16 21:58:24

Met my other half on meet me app

LesisMiserable Tue 01-Nov-16 23:23:32

Tinder is unapologetically straightforward and all the better for it. Met my lovely DP on it, our two year anniversary is tomorrow and our honeymoon next year is already booked (just need to sort a wedding now grin )

Justtypicalman Fri 19-May-17 22:32:22

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

countryside8 Sat 20-May-17 17:44:44

None they are all a load of shite. Bitter and jaded with online dating and given up.

countryside8 Sat 20-May-17 17:54:17

The trouble i found was all the people i was interested in weren't interested in me and just wanted to chat. Maybe online dating works if you live in a city but if your in a rural location like myself there are few people. I would never use POF again as that site seems to be cesspit and full of unhinged fruit loops. I think Tinder is the way forward and will persevere with Grindr but other than that i think sites are 'dead'. Most people have smartphones today and use the dating apps. I have no interest nor the time for a long distance relationship. How far do you all travel/meet your dates? Good luck to you all :-)

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now