Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide, which can point you to expert advice and support.
Mother in law who lacks boundaries(38 Posts)
I am expecting my dc2 (14 weeks this week). My ds1 is 2 and a half, very good and goes to nursery 3 days a week.
My problem is this. My mother in law is very overbearing/domineering and caused a lot of upset when I had ds1 by pushing to look after him on her own from week 2. Up until this point she came over every day to cuddle ds1 (not help). When I said I didn't need that kind of help she created a storm of a row and demanded to see ds1 without me present. When I tried to be assertive with her over not wanting to be parted with my new born baby she physically attacked me and was verbally abusive (I had just had a c section and she dragged me through her house, pushed me to the ground and stood on my back - this tore the muscles in my stomach and I was left with carpet burns and severe bruising). From this time on she treated me like sh!t and ran me down to my husband, extended family and gossiped to friends. This went on for some time until it upset me so much that I put a stop to it by insisting she see ds1 with me present.
She created many rifts over the following 2 years (all when things didnt go exactly her way), nearly destroyed my marriage by manipulating and pressuring my husband, ruined my sons 2nd birthday party by having a tantrum in front of all my friends etc....you get the picture.
She has never apologised or admitted her wrongdoing.
My husband and I have been through the mill with it all, but have come out strong and united. I can't deny that she did her best to ruin my experience as a new mum. I had a c section and needed time to recover and bond with ds1. All I got was her interfering and getting in the way of me resting. She also made lots of negative and condescending remarks during her visits.
My problem is that as soon as she knew I was pregnant again she started openly assuming she would be looking after the baby. She has spoken about taking it to her house and all sorts. Now that ds1 is older he will pop to her house to play, but only likes to stay an hour or so as she bosses him and is quite sharp in her manner (something he isn't used to). That's ok as he is independent, and its only every so often as there are some trust issues.
It's one thing to offer to help if needed, but another to basically tell me this is what's going to happen. Anyway, it's freaking me out because of the trauma I went through after the birth of ds1. I can't go through that again and am not sure how to handle it. I'm concerned she will blow up again when I refuse her help. I've been feeling quite anxious and I don't want it to ruin another precious time.
My husband and I have agreed that she will not be looking after the baby due to our experience with her and our concerns. Plus, we don't need it.
My question is: am I best to ignore her assumptions as I have not agreed to them, or clear this up now by explaining that I don't wish to have time away from my newborn baby?
Sorry for the long post, but its complex. Thanks for any helpful comments.
I would be rather blunt and say "After what happened when you assaulted me after my last birth, no I won't be wanting any help from you".
When you're home from the hospital keep the door locked and don't let her visit until you are ready (if it all!). If she rings you tell her you don't want visitors. Your H must support you 100% or the blocking her out strategy won't work.
She absolutely cannot get away with this sort of behaviour, it's disgusting.
I don't see what is wrong with direct honesty.
'You have got to be fucking kidding and if there is even a fraction of your previous behaviour we will use the full weight of the law against you and you will never see either child again'
Completely coming from your H 100% backing you.
Fuck me! I would have had her prosecuted, and I do not exaggerate. That is ABH at the very least.
If that was my MIL and she asked to see my baby I would say 'No, you can fuck off'.
If your husband wants to be in contact with her and make sure she is alright that is up to him, but I would have nothing to do with her and would not let her near the children.
However I fear that if you kick up a fuss now she/your DH might not take any notice, as you have been accepting her horrendous behaviour up to now. I think you should definitely start being very firm though.
Is your DH an only child? If not, are there other DILs or SILs around? How do they deal with this woman? Could they be allies? I'm asking this but getting the impression that DH is an only child, given the intensity of MIL's focus on you. :-(
Hi there! I have just registered with mumsnet after reading your post, tmonster. I think your husband needs to stand up for you more and speak to his mum himself. Why should you have all the stress? I can't stand your mil and I have never even met her!!!! I wish you all the best for the future.
My MIL has caused me stress. However, I am thankful that my h is not a mummy's boy and he does stand up for me. She is very overbearing and looks down her nose at me when she visits. She seems to think she is perfect. Luckily she lives 120 miles away and only visits about every 6 weeks. I do get anxious about her visits though.
What is it with these stupid women???
I hope you have a better experience with your 2nd child. In solidarity xxxxx.
Another one here who is shocked at her assault of you and yet still sees her Son and your child.
I don't understand why you you and your dh continue to allow her figure in your lives, she's unstable and prone to violent outbursts.
To be honest, I would have severed contact completely after she assaulted you. I would also have been inclined to get her arrested for said assault.
I can't believe you are still including her in your family's life. Do you want your dcs to grow up with her influence??
im shocked she's still in your childs life tbh
you need to tell her now... not later. if she keeps hinting at looking after your new baby, and you say nothing then she will continue to think she is getting her own way. the sooner you tell her, and make her understand, the better
Honestly OP, I don't understand how you can allow this dangerous and unhinged woman anywhere near your DS1 with or without being present yourself. As someone else said, her husband, no matter how lovely he is, is enabling her.
She's unpredictable and toxic and you have no way of knowing whether she's likely turn on DS1 and whether her husband would be able to protect your child if she did.
In your position I would disengage with her and not allow her in my home or my children near her. I don't think you can reason with her and explain why you don't want her baby sitting. Her behaviour is way beyond reason.
I had just had a c section and she dragged me through her house, pushed me to the ground and stood on my back - this tore the muscles in my stomach and I was left with carpet burns and severe bruising
Poor you OP, plus I could have written your post, my MiL is a copy of yours only that my
fugly SiL did the physical assult in public. Very unpleasant people! My STBXH was completely emotionally blackmailed, so awfully he aways sided with Mil . I'm thrilled they are ALL out of my and DD's life for Good! I just couldn't live an intoxicated life knowing there was never going to be a solution! we are in a refuge
Good luck OP and congratulations on your DC2. These are for you .
Not at all surprised to see that MIL had a dysfunctional childhood; it sounds like she is narcissistic in terms of personality.
No point in trying usual methods with such people as you are dealing with someone who is completely operating outside all normal social norms. Usual rules therefore go out the window as you are not dealing with an emotionally responsible let alone stable personality. She will in no way accept your reasoned argument as such people simply cannot be dealt with.
Would also suggest you keep your eldest child away from this lady and her enabler of a H as well.
I don`t understand why this awful woman imagines that you would allow her to be any more involved with your new LO, than she is with DS1. However, given her deluded thinking, you are absolutely right to lay down the rules.....immediately. This is not about her in any way, and you need to spell that out to her.She gave up the right to be an involved grandparent when she attacked you. Please never allow her to be alone with your lovely children. She sounds very dangerous.
How about "MIL, have you forgotten that you assaulted me only a few days after DS? Because I haven't and never will. I'm polite to you because your my husbands mother but I really don't want you to ever babysit my children. You can't be trusted not to lose your temper. Don't ask again, because if you do, I'll just cut you out. Back off"
Of course, I'd not let someone who'd assaulted me anywhere near my DCs.
You let an abusive verbally agressive woman near your son?
I am sorry for your Dhs childhood, it must be very difficult for him, but you can stop the rot.
Stand your ground.
Thanks ladies. When I next see her she is bound to bring up baby sitting. I've decided that I'm going to lay things out very clearly that we won't need any help with ds1 or 2 when the baby arrives. I am also going to state that that won't change and that its the end of the matter. I'm going to record the conversation on my phone so she can't deny I have made things clear. Then I can carry on with my pregnancy and enjoy it.
Ps frequent flyer I logged the assault so that if she came between my husband and I, I could stop her ever having any contact with ds1. She'll never get the better of me and when she dies I'm having one hell of a party with her stacks of money left to my hubby.
I also have a difficult MIL and was reading your OP thinking "yeah yeah, same here" until I got to the bit about her assaulting you
That is really off the scale and you are totally justified in restricting contact with her as much as you see fit.
I can't believe you still even look in her direction or let her near your child after assaulting you she sounds like a maniac, I'd have nothing to do
With her OP, I would hope most people would back you up on that one.
I am very sorry for you.
To answer your question, I think I would make it very clear to her once, while other people are present so she cannot pretend that she did not know. I was going to suggest a letter tu this can be 'lost'.
Then I would ignore and adopt the broken record stance.
I am so glad you logged her first assault with the police. Well done.
There is no way she should have anything to do with your baby - or even your DS1.
What happens when your DS1 gets a bit older and starts asserting himself more - is MIL going to stand on his back too?
Actually my FIL has really helped as he has bollocked her on a few occasions now. He isn't my husbands Father, but he is a decent man. He has a job that takes him away so he only sees half of her behaviour.
Attila, my husband has already joked that I am choosing the home...I'm going to hold him to that! The children and I won't be visiting either.
My husband is in a difficult spot as his father committed suicide when he was 6. Hence he feels responsible for her and too guilty to turn his back. Attila you are spot on. She had a very bad childhood. Mother was sectioned many times and father lived away. She was put in boarding school from a young age. She has no relationship with her parent and is emotionally baron.
My husband has been conditioned by her, but over the course of our 10 year relationship I have managed to persuade him that things aren't as she says they are. He becomes a better person every day.
When my son is around she is always sickly sweet to me...she isn't daft! I know my son and he won't develop any real relationship with her. However, he does love his step grandpa who is a lovely guy.
"My son only sees her without me present when my MILs husband is there (a very nice, normal individual)"
He is also playing a role here in this overall dysfunction; FIL is likely to be a bystander and such weak men act out of self preservation and want of a quiet life. He failed to protect his son from his wife didn't he and he continues to fail now. Your son is fed up with his grandma after 1 hour's visit to their house for good reason.
Your H is very torn I think between loyalty to you and to his mother even after all the havoc she has caused you as a family. He won't let you choose a poorly run nursing home for her.
I would have called the police and insisted that charges were brought if that had been done to me but I do understand why you might not have felt able to do that.
Honestly I wouldn't have her anywhere near me or my family but as you are planning to do so I would be quite up front in telling her that if there is so much as a hint of similar behaviours I would be contacting the police, making a formal complaint and she would never see my dc again.
She doesn't bring anything to our life as she isn't really in it.
She sees ds1 about once a month if she is lucky.
What does your H think of his mother now, does he want a relationship at all with her?. Do you for that matter?.
Does MIL live close by?.
BTW you both did not cause this lady to act this way. the damage done to her was likely done by both her parents in her own childhood. Do you have any idea of what her own childhood was like, that often gives clues.
You have likely come from a family where this type of familial dysfunction is thankfully unknown so this is also difficult to deal with. However, the "normal" rules of engagement when dealing with such emotionally dysfunctional people like your MIL go out the window. I was not at all surprised to see that she has never apologised nor taken any responsibility for her actions; such toxic people do not and never do.
You both need to protect your own selves and that of your children here; if that meant cutting her off completely from your lives so be it. I do not write such things at all lightly but she's certainly brought enough chaos into your lives these past few years and will continue to do so.
Your H certainly needs to talk to her but she could well not listen (or turn on the tears). Also you may need to consider that he on some level is too afraid of his mother to actually do this. This is not due to him necessarily being cowardly but due to inbuilt conditioning at her hands. He may on some level not want to admit to himself that his mother is really very much damaged and was a toxic parent to him as well as well as being a rubbish model of a grandparent now.
Where is FIL, I only ask as he is not mentioned at all in your post.
I would think about the matter of DS1 going around there as well for infact any length of time from now on (small wonder he gets fed up with her after an hour, he's probably frightened of her). This is because if you are being treated badly by your MIL then that behaviour she shows you can too easily be transferred to your DS as well. She is also showing DS1 a rubbish role model of being a grandparent as well as still behaving awfully to you both.
I would also suggest you read "Toxic Inlaws" written by Susan Forward as this may well help you.
Join the discussion
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.Register now »
Already registered? Log in with:
Please login first.