Last night a red wedding dress came on the tv. I casually said "oh, my relative wore a burgundy wedding dress, it was lovely" - my boyfriend (of 4 months) visibly tensed up, muttered "umm" followed by an awkward silence ...
It was only a throw away comment! is it not the done thing to mention weddings/marriages etc when you're in a new relationship or was he just being weird?
I think a bit of context is important here. If you'd been in silence all evening until a wedding dress appeared, very much as the focus of whatever the programme/ad was; then a reasonable person might well see the comment as loaded, even if it was purely inadvertent on your part.
If it was a minor part of something you'd been watching and chatting about all evening, then you'd expect him to chat back as he had been doing all evening. Which might include just going "umm" because he has no fashion vocabulary.
But - for you to have seen and noted his facial expression, you must have turned away from the screen and looked him full in the face. That may have been more concerning to him than the words.
Or maybe he was just thinking about something completely different, didn't really hear your remark, and thought "uh-oh, looks like I'm expected to say something here, wonder what she said?" Maybe he'd just had a blinding flash of inspiration concerning the answer to world peace, sustainable pollution-free energy or the cure for the common cold, and your remark about dresses drove it completely out of his head. There are a lot of possibilities.
I am inexorably reminded of this scenario (don't ask me why it's on a horse forum, other than that a figurative horse gets a passing mention; I remembered it from somewhere and this is what Google offered).
Volume clearly it wasn't a topic your DH thought should be forbidden then.
I've discussed marriage with newish partners on a hypothetical basis applied to the actual institution of marriage rather than a "shall we get married" one. It doesn't hurt to know if they are pro or anti marriage and to see how they view commitment generally. Same goes for children.
Any guy that can't see that this is a relevant topic of conversation in the braod sense and doesn't mean you want to get married and pop out a child next week is someone who probably does have commitment issues or is a little immature IMO.
DH asked me where I wanted to be in 5 years' time! This was about our 4th date, and we'd had a few drinks. I was a bit surprised, but told him I hoped to be married and considering children soon, but if that hadn't worked out I'd hope to be doing X at work, seeing loads of my nephews and nieces etc.
It was an unexpected early-date conversation, but made sure we were both on the same page. He was late-30s, I was early 30s, and we really liked each other - if he or I had said we were planning to move abroad, for example, it would have put us on notice that our fledgling relationship might not be a goer.
Oh Blimey we talk about marriage, weddings and babies all the time. I hint all the time . We've only been together ten months but this sort of chat probably came up around the 5 month mark, then initiated by HIM at about 6 months. You're bloke is probably stumped at a fashion related conversation!
Bloody hell, get yourself a hobby! You will hurt yourself if you start overanalysing every conversation with a little flashing light in your head going 'Will he marry me? Will he marry me?' all the time.
He was almost certainly thinking about something else and your comment made him jump, that's all.
When me and DH had been going out 4 months it was the Royal Wedding so it proved fairly unavoidable. I tried not mentioning it but we had gone for a weekend break - and every single shop/restaurant/bus shelter had a wedding related display.
Well, it broke the 'wedding talk' barrier for us bigstyle. And this turned out to be a good thing as nobody really wants to waste their time on something going nowhere do they?
Years ago I had a big row with an ex who was messing me around. He wasn't behaving in a committed way and in fact I think this was the occasion when he'd disappeared for a week before rocking up on my doorstep like nothing had happened. I was seriously contemplating ending things, but was torn because I loved him - and at 20 you don't always have the life experience to make the best decisions. We had this huge barney and in the end I told him everything; how he'd made me feel, how hurt I was yet again, what I wanted from him and the relationship.
He went very quiet and serious, and thought for a long time. I was so glad he was finally listening to how I felt and taking it in. After a long silence, I asked 'what are you thinking?' and he replied: