Is it me or is Rob Brydon just not doing it for you on ISIHAC?

[johnworf]

I've really stuck it out listening to him in the chair but he's just not doing it for me. I wish they'd take him off. He's ruining it for me!

[Ponders]

Jack Dee seems to have the best handle on the job...I like Rob Brydon but he hasn't got it right (& Stephen Fry is just irritating)

[policywonk]

I only heard the last one but I agree, it wasn't working (and I usually find him quite funny).

They should stop with the Samantha stuff IMO. It was funny when Humph did it because his delivery was so impeccable, and his ancientness made the sex references incongruous (not that ancient people can't have sex, but YKWIM). Whereas when Brydon read out that joke about seeing her stuffed beaver, I thought 'a) that's nicked from the Naked Gun and b) bleeugh Brydon, shut up!'

Didn't hear Fry (annoys me at best of times) or Dee.

[Threadworm2]

I like the chairmanship being a guest spot -- emphasises that no one can own it post-Humpf.

Sephen Fry is an annoying person but wasn't oo bad. Best by far was Jack Dee, because he already has the 'Christ this is boring and I am pissed off' persona that Humph used.

Agree that the Samantha stuff was Humph-dependent and ought to stop.

The resurrection is less distressing than I thouhgt it would be. It still feels like they are all committing adultery with Humph's wife though. Even though ISIHAC is actually his widow

[policywonk]

Yes, I can see that Dee's persona would fit. How does he do on the double entendres?

I don't know about the guest spot thing. It works well on HIGNFY because Angus Deayton's role was only ever, as Hislop and Merton loved to point out, 'reading aloud' (albeit with comic timing). But the ISIHAC chair is much more crucial to the comedy of the show - with a bad chair the whole conceit of the quiz (that it's entirely meaningless but we all pretend to take it seriously) seems to collapse.

God I'm in an over-analysing mood tonight.

[Jux]

I thought Fry did it pretty well; completely missed Jack Dee. Can't stand Rob Brydon at the best of times, and I thought he was utter shit on this. (That means they'll pick him, and I'll never be able to listen to it again, btw!)

Don't mind the Samantha stuff though; I thought it came better from Fry though.

[peachygirl]

I have heard all three and would agree that Jack Dee was the best.

[Yurtgirl]

I wasnt that keen on Jack Dee tbh

I like Stephen Fry but I prefer him on QI

I hope they keep it as a guest presenter like Have I got news for you?

[msled]

I think they should get Michael Aspel. He made me laugh a lot of HIGNY. He has the essential quality of being old, with all the mannerisms of the impeccably respectable, without which the filth is just...filth.
He also has something slightly disreputable about him which just peeps through the respectability. He as funny about the ghastliness of Miss World for example.

[Jux]

I think they should find someone not so obviously 'showbiz'. I had thought John Sargeant but he's out of hte running since the Dance thing (as far as I'm concerned anyway).

My brother would do it pretty well

[msled]

They have to have the appearance of utter respectability but have quiet louche side. and definitely have to be old. I fear that Humph is irreplaceable - can't imagine anyone being as good really.

[policywonk]

Aspel and Sargeant would both be good. Agree that basically, we need someone elderly and a bit filthy.

[policywonk]

Prince Philip?

[Jux]

policywonk; he'd be great wouldn't he?

[AitchTwoOh]

oh yes, aspel is genius, good thought. sargent also good but aspel would be a surprise choice and utter FILTH.

[policywonk]

[Tommy]

agree - the beaver joke was just yeuch

I think JD is great anyway

I read somewhere that since it is suppoed to be the "antidote" to panel games, having panel game master (i.e. SF) on it defeats the point.

I'm not a huge fan of RB but thought he was ok.

It's a tricky one alright

[Ponders]

oooh, what about David Mitchell?

Granted he is actually quite young, technically, but does come across as surprisingly elderly (bless him )

(not filthy though )

[Ponders]

failing that, what about Lionel Blair?

[ilovemydogandmrobama]

John Sargeant absolutely. He has that mischievous /innocent appeal that is so appealing. Not sure about the filth element though. Think teddy bear meets mud

[ButterbeerAndLemon]

I always felt they should offer the chairmanship to Samantha. She's very familiar with the show, after all, and knows the rules of Mornington Crescent inside out.

Humph was effectively just "reading aloud", but his timing and delivery were SO spot-on that no one else quite measures up.

[Threadworm2]

Michael Aspel formerly of Antiques Roadshow and former straight man in Crackerjack?

Nooo. He is oily.

I really think they should let ISIHAC die with dignity.

It was brilliant because it started as a parody of quiz shows at a time when everything was played straight and sincere. Now everything is a pastiche of everything. It is on borrowed time and sooner or later it will be awful.

[policywonk]

I think I might be developing inappropriate feelings for David Mitchell. I've missed him twice on Desert Island Discs this week (damned Roy Plumley Estate and its steam-driven objection to Listen Again).

[Threadworm2]

David Mitchell was lovely on DID. It is a biot embarrassing, though, that very interviewer acts like his mother now: 'When are you going to find a nice girl and settle down?'

[Ponders]

ditto, pw

he is so effortlessly witty & just damn nice (& I missed his DID too, except for the last few mins last Sunday - forgot about the repeat on Friday, dammit)(his song of choice was kermit's Rainbow Connection you know)