Advanced search

Note: This topic is for discussing pushchairs. To find out which pushchairs have won Mumsnet Best, read our lightweight pushchair and pram reviews. If you want to buy and sell pushchairs, please use our For Sale/Wanted boards. Please feel free to report buying and selling in this topic.

Bugaboo Cam Vs Icandy Apple

(35 Posts)
notso Fri 23-Apr-10 13:44:00

Can anyone help with comparisons of these please? and also help with the following.

Does either fold with the seat on?

Can you used the carrycots for longterm overnight sleeping?

Price wise how do they match up, can't see a price for the apple anywhere?

Thanks in advance.

faddle Fri 23-Apr-10 17:18:44

Cameleon does not fold with the seat on either way. Not sure about the icandy.

Bugaboo is lovely to push either way, even with a large heavy toddler in it, can still be steered and go up and down kerbs with one hand. Havent tried an apple, but have used a pear with single seat and found it horrible to push after the bug, and very very heavy.

Hardbodied for icandy, takes up loads of room to store. Doesnt say if its safe for overnight. 84cm long.
Bugaboo - Soft body with rigid base, and can be used for overnight as it has the aerosleep mattress. 90cm long

Icandy - 12.9kg with the seat on, 15.7kg with carrycot.
Bugaboo, 9.28 with seat, About the same with carrycot.

Bugaboo - 3 position recline forward and rear. seat 90cm long.
3 position forward and rear, 89cm long.

Both have a 2 year warranty, personally I feel bugaboo is a lot better made, and the covers etc are a lot easier to get off and wash. Also, the hood on the bugaboo comes off totally, which is a big plus as you can replace if it looks worn and get a brand new looking pushchair. Both brands hold their value really well.

Rockbird Fri 23-Apr-10 17:30:34

Aha, well I say the opposite Have an Apple (have only played about with a Cam) so can't really comment on that.

The Apple folds with the seat attached doesn't matter which way the seat is facing. It's a dream to push, feels solid and substantial but turns on a penny and glides along. Whatever attachment you have on it, car seat, seat unit or carrycot is nice and high up (the Cameleon has the baby down by your kneecaps).

The carrycot that I have can be collapsed. I haven't done it but it can be done. I don't know if they have changed the design... Is safe for overnight use.

The Bugaboo seems flimsy to me, the Apple looks like it will stand a lot of wear and tear (it does, DD is 2.3yo now)

The hood does come off completely and it can be changed although tbh, I prefer the more classy look of the black rather than the gaudy multi coloured Cam (ok, I'm stirring a bit now wink but I do prefer the black/silver combo). If you don't there are coloured add ons but it's not as customisable as the Cam.

I looked at both and the Apple ticked more boxes with me. Much as I would like a Cam for a little while, I would not have swapped the Apple for it. Given my time again I would still go for the Apple.

When I bought my Apple it was £499 including the carrycot so allowing for a couple of years' increase... The Apple is definitely the classier option wink. Think Joanna Lumley vs Jordan

notso Fri 23-Apr-10 18:07:56

Thanks both of you for your great reviews, I am still undecided, perhaps I should buy both grin

Rockbird you made me laugh with your stirring.

Anyone else like to add their twopen'orth?

faddle Fri 23-Apr-10 18:19:40

As I said, I only tried the pear not the apple and its not the same. Horses for courses though. I love the bright colours on the cam, black is so BORING LOL (stir stir wink)
You can customise either one to be honest, poshbugs and snunkie do liners and footmuffs.
I will say, the raincover on the icandy is better as the bugaboo one is a PITA and takes up loads of space, but the icandy footmuff is teeny compared to the bugaboo one which will still fit a larger toddler.

notso Fri 23-Apr-10 18:26:45

I have to say at the moment it is the bright colours that are luring me towards the cam faddle, but DH really likes the look of the Union Jack apple thats coming out soon.

Rockbird Fri 23-Apr-10 18:27:29

<takes offence, sticks nose in air>

I'm trying to remember when DD grew out of the footmuff... I think I tried to put her in it around Oct when it got colder. She would have been 21 months and her toes were right up against the zip so yes it's quite small (although very cosy).

Rockbird Fri 23-Apr-10 18:29:03

WHAT UNION JACK APPLE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! shock

<DH hides wallet>

notso Fri 23-Apr-10 18:36:08

Haven't you seen it, the ad has been at the top of my screen on here tempting me!

I always wanted the ziko Alfie for DS but really couldn't justify it, maybe I should get the apple to finally console myself.

Rockbird Fri 23-Apr-10 18:37:30

I have the ads turned off (sorry MNHQ)

Damn... how can I coax DD back into a pushchair?

notso Fri 23-Apr-10 18:39:47

Rofl, am imagining you childcatcher like trying to bribe your DD!

notso Fri 23-Apr-10 18:49:04

Also how do you turn off the adverts, I could do with saving money if I'm going to be buying one of these beauties.

faddle Fri 23-Apr-10 18:52:18

Poshbugs will do you a customised seat cover footmuff and hood set for a cameleon either in union jack or in st georges cross.

notso Fri 23-Apr-10 18:56:20

I am going to have to look at Poshbugs faddle, do they do Paul Frank as well?

faddle Fri 23-Apr-10 19:24:42

Yes she does paul frank, she is fab

OnlyWantsOne Fri 23-Apr-10 20:05:08

notso I have a bugaboo cameleon which I love and will be using again for this one

Was that enough opinion?

No does not fold up with seat unit on

Yes, used the cary cot stage for about 5 months as moses basket at parents / friends houses

notso Sat 24-Apr-10 10:37:17

Thanks OWO grin

Can you use it right up until DC doesn't need a pushchair, if we do shell out then I know DH will be dead against buying an umbrella type without selling the Cam.
Which would mean me resorting to the knackered old Maclaren in the Cellar.

faddle Sat 24-Apr-10 18:21:27

I'm still using mine for DD who is 4 in july. she still fits, and it still steers with one hand. She is about average height and weight.
I'm downsizing to the new bee plus shortly though as we hardly use it but yet it takes up a lot of space in the boot just in case......

OnlyWantsOne Sat 24-Apr-10 18:55:44

Uh, I never had an umbrella pushchair as well, however, I drive a mini and when DD was 2, I bought a quinny zapp as it fits in the boot of my car really well (however, I only have used it twice so a complete waste of time) at least the maxi cosi car seat fits on both chasis (using different clips)

VictoriaC Sun 25-Apr-10 23:19:53

I have the Bugaboo and love it. I had a bit of trouble putting it up to start with but once I got the hang of it have never looked back. It looks nice and it's so comfortable. I have tried DS (18 months) in the recently purchased Quinny Zapp and he refuses to go in it, he's never done that with the Bugaboo. It still looks new too a year and a half later.

Good luck choosing!

notso Mon 26-Apr-10 13:36:07

Thanks VictoriaC, I'm looking forward to going somewhere to have a go with one!

mel2005 Mon 26-Apr-10 14:16:05

i have had both the icandy and bugaboo and have to say the quality of the bugaboo is much better than the icandy. my fold bit on the icandy handle broke not long after i had it. i did love it as i converted it to a pear for my twins but wouldnt have bought it over a bugaboo (i keep hoping they will make a double bugaboo). the bugaboo feels lighter and easier to push, the fabrics are better quality but the basket is smaller. another great thing with the bugaboo was that i could take the wheels off and fit it in tiny spaces between the seats when i had a boot full of shopping. there is a knack to folding it but when you have it sorted its really quick and easy. there are some great bargains on e-bay i have seen them as low as £150 for a cameleon so you could buy one and sell it back on for a profit if you hate it. i would be wary of buying a secondhand apple. i had the frog for my first child and a gecko and cam for my second.

mel2005 Mon 26-Apr-10 14:19:34

oh and the zips break really easily on the icandy seat fabrics, i had to replace them as well.

notso Mon 26-Apr-10 15:29:39

Thanks mel2005, it's good to hear from someone who has had both.

felicity10 Mon 26-Apr-10 17:08:50

Why buy the apple when there is the Peach? Peach has a lighter chassis, the carrycot can be used overnight and it looks pretty smart with the shiny crome. I've been using mine since feb and have no fault with the build quality. Admitedly, not used the oushchair attachment yet, but the carrycot isreally comfortable and i'm really glad i picked this over he bugaboo. You get no drafts with the icandy, but the bugaboo does around where the hood meets the carrycot.

happy shopping!

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: