Correct me if I'm wrong, but I find Godalming to be uber-quaint, but the housing stock in the village to be nothing special.
Haslemere is so leafy and green, that most of the village's residential strrets appear to be canopied by rows of tall, stately shade trees making the residental streets incredibly beautiful and dignified in their appearance. The High Street, however, was nice, but nothing special like Godalming's. Petersfield get's an incredible amount of good press, but I can't help but think most of it is hype, because it didn't seem all that special to me. Again, though, I just had a short walk around the centre of the village.