Advanced search

Get £10 off your first lesson with Mumsnet-Rated tutoring service Tutorful here

Told off because he couldn't do something

(60 Posts)
OrmIrian Mon 12-Oct-09 20:19:46

DS#2 told me tonight that he was told off because he couldn't do him sums or use the number square. Now I know he can use it more or less as we used on for hw recently. But apparently he couldn't in school. So he was told off. And made to sit in the cloakroom to do his work - even after the others had gone out to play sad

Problem is DS#2 is a stubborn little chap and he won't ever cry if he gets told off. He doesn't seem to know when to back down. His teacher is extremely strict - every child in the school knows Mrs C by reputation and she is not well-liked. To say the least.

He cries when he goes into school. Most days. He pretends he's ill.

Is it right to tell a child off for not being able to do something?

It's parents evening next week. What, if anything, can we say to her. Short of 'you evil witch, stop terrorising our son' grin?

thisisyesterday Mon 12-Oct-09 20:21:45

hmmm could there be more to the story? perhaps he couldnt do it because he was messing around with friends, hence being put somewhere else to do it?

i don't know. based on what he has said then her behaviour is absolutely unacceptable. but you need to know exactly whathappened realy

bigTillyMint Mon 12-Oct-09 20:22:28

No it's not right to tell him off because he can't do it. He's probably petrified of her which makes him even less likely to be able to concentrate....

OrmIrian Mon 12-Oct-09 20:22:49

Oh yes thisis, I appreciate things may not be quite as it seems. But how do I tell?

MusterMix Mon 12-Oct-09 20:23:13

something is going on.
go in adn see the head first imo

OrmIrian Mon 12-Oct-09 20:25:02

His refusal to cry when he's being told off is only just becoming to clear to us. We thought it was that he wasn't upset but I am beginning to realise that isn't the case. It's almost as if he can't back down sad

ATm I am feeling that she is the worst teacher possible for him.

Hulababy Mon 12-Oct-09 20:26:11

I would say to go in and talk to the teacher first. IMO the head should only be sought if you cannot reconcile this with the teacher herself. TBH the head would be likely to refer you to a meeting with the teacher in the first nstance anyway.

FlightAttendant Mon 12-Oct-09 20:27:14

Orm when this happened to us I went in and had a quick meeting. We discussed it (she wanted to in front of ds, which I felt was wrong but she just grabbed me iykwim)

the truth never really did come out, I didn't know what happened but made it clear that I didn't want him kept in at playtime, boys need to run about, and I didn't think he ought to be punished for being slow or confused.

I don't think it happened again.
I am sorry to hear he hates it that much to cry and pretend to be ill.

All I will say is I hated school and was terrified enough to do that sort of thing - the fear was very very real, I just uearned for someone to listen to me and take me home sad

Please don't ignore it. It was like torture for me every single day, I feel I lost a lot of my childhood to just dread and fear. Especially with one teacher everyone hated.

If you stand up to her in front of him it will really empower him and should help - make him feel he won't be hurt by her again, and you are stronger than her.
My parents didn't do that and I think had they tried it I'd have felt safe again.

I know you are brill and really totally on his side but just my own experience iyswim smile x

thisisyesterday Mon 12-Oct-09 20:28:40

howold is he? he sounds like my ds and i was saying the same thing earlier to one of the other mums. she said how lucky he always goes into school without a backward glance. the problem is, that doesn;t mean he likes it, or is happy, just means that he doesn';t show it

i guess i would come straight out and ask her. if you feel you can. say "ds says this happened" and just wait and see what she says.

if you aren't h appy with how she is treating him in the classroom then something has to be done, so i suppose the next step would be headteacher?
is there another class in his year he could m ove into?

OrmIrian Mon 12-Oct-09 20:30:09

Oh I won't go to the head. I will speak the teacher first at parents' evening. But what do I say?

It's such a shock. I've never been a 'oh my poor little precious child, don't you are tell him off' type of mother. And I have two older kids that muddled through OK. Even when my eldest cried when he had to go into school every morning for 2 years sad I was OK because I knew the teachers were on his side and doing their best to make him happy.

thisisyesterday Mon 12-Oct-09 20:32:08

i would say that he is unhappy about going to school, very reluctant togo in and that from what he has said you are worried he is being penalised for not being capable of doing things.

see what she says,
i say all this, i am awful at confrontation myself, but it's what i would want to do (and then get dp to do for me!)

thisisyesterday Mon 12-Oct-09 20:32:12

i would say that he is unhappy about going to school, very reluctant togo in and that from what he has said you are worried he is being penalised for not being capable of doing things.

see what she says,
i say all this, i am awful at confrontation myself, but it's what i would want to do (and then get dp to do for me!)

OrmIrian Mon 12-Oct-09 20:32:45

Thanks everyone. Feeling a bit shell-shocked. He is hard work! I have worries about him anyway but so far at school he has always been OK.

I need to talk to DH about this - he is out atm picking up DS#1.

Hulababy Mon 12-Oct-09 20:33:30

TBH I would be tempted to arrane a longer than normal appointment if you can fpr parent's evening. Normally you only get 5 minutes which probably isn;t going to be long enough.

Just tell her what you know so far, and make sure she is aware at how upset he is getting. Ask for her take on things and take it from there.

OrmIrian Mon 12-Oct-09 20:35:20

Thanks thisis, that sound right. I will try and tackle her tomorrow. The TA is nice and so is the teacher who helps him with reading.

I keep thinking about little things he has said, and others have said about him, and putting 2 and 2 together. I worry that something serious is wrong. I think I have been guilty of a little complacency sad

franklymydear Mon 12-Oct-09 20:36:23

he wasn't unable to do it

he could do it at home so he obviously knew how

he'd probably done it before in school

I'd have told him off too for messing around - I think you're being unreasonable

FlightAttendant Mon 12-Oct-09 20:38:09

Orm, try not to worry too much. I am sure you will make a good go of it.

What I found was there was a bit of a stand off, when I said 'well I don't really agree with that way of handling it' or something - and she didn't know what to say, so just sat there - she isn't used to being stood up to, v v confident etc - and I sat there, and the tA was like shock and ds was like blush and anyway - we all just smiled and that was that, meeting over. It didn't matter that we didn't agree - we'd both said whatw e thought in front of ds and he knew I was there and they didn't have Total Power.

You will be FINE but don't be scared of her.

franklymydear Mon 12-Oct-09 20:38:18

but crying before school and pretending to be ill needs dealing with

just don't confuse the two - they aren't the same issue at all

OrmIrian Mon 12-Oct-09 20:40:41

They are probably not the same issue frankly. I think they are part of the same thing - he has become scared of her. I don't think that sending him out to finish his work in the cloakroom is the answer.

kid Mon 12-Oct-09 20:42:00

I think you should speak to the teacher to hear what she has to say.
You can just casually mention that he seems upset about coming to school and ask her if she has noticed any change in him at school.

You can then mention that he was really upset about the maths incident, but don't necesarily tell her word for word what he told you. Let her give her version.

It might then all blow over, it might not, but at least you have let her know that your son does come home and tell you things.

FlightAttendant Mon 12-Oct-09 20:45:20

No i remember what happened now...after the stand off, I said something or she did and it sounded like it had actually been a big misunderstanding and I ahd got the wrong we all laughed and it seemed Ok. Then I thought back to what she ahd said, and realised it had NOT been a misunderstanding, at all, in fact, just everyone was tense and the issue had got confused - so I emailed and made it clear that way. She didn't attempt to deny it and agreed to do things differently, or something - I was happy with it anyway.

Don't be fobbed off.

OrmIrian Mon 12-Oct-09 20:46:57

Thank you flight. I am going to have to tackle her arent I? <gibber>

bigTillyMint Tue 13-Oct-09 06:34:06

Yes, you must speak to her and get her to realise that she will not get him to learn by terrorising him.

You said she sent him out to finish his work in the cloakroom hmm WTF - You could as her if she thinks he has difficulty concentrating in class, and then say was that why you sent him to finish his work in the cloakroom? ... then tell her that he came back really upset and worried, etc.

Good Luck!

ICANDOTHAT Tue 13-Oct-09 09:28:18

Orm what are the 'worries' you have about him already?

Bucharest Tue 13-Oct-09 09:33:18

I came onto this thread prepared to say "pah, another PFB ish-oo" but then saw it was Orm so knew there must be more to it...

It's definitely not right if he was told off just for not knowing how to do something- so if that is the whole story then you need to let them know it's not acceptable..I can't imagine it being acceptable in the general ethos of a school tbh.....does the HT know she's a bit of a tyrant? The fact that he also doesn't want to go to school, or gets worked up before he goes, means there's summat afoot, I'd say.....

Good luck and hope you sort it out....

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: