Advanced search

Maths question

(11 Posts)
JustCallMeJones Mon 30-Apr-18 18:48:47

I’m rubbish and hope you can help.

Out of the 240 children in ks2, 3:8 children have blue eyes. This is half of the proportion of the KS1 children. If there are 180 children in KS1, how many KS1 children have blue eyes?

120. 190. Or. 135

What is the ratio
What is the proportion

OP’s posts: |
MangoBiscuit Mon 30-Apr-18 19:01:30

I'm not sure the notation is correct. I thought 3:8 meant 3 to 8, not 3 in 8, but otherwise the options don't work.

Double 3 in 8 gives 6 in 8, or 75%. 75% of 180 is 135.

xyzandabc Mon 30-Apr-18 19:01:55

It's a badly worded question. Not particularly clear at all.

If 3/8 is half the proportion of the KS1 with blue eyes, then the proportion of KS1 with blue eyes is 6/8.

6/8 of 180 is 135. So 135 have blue eyes in KS1

The ratio of what?
90 KS2 have blue eyes, 135 KS1 have blue eyes so the ration would be 90:135
This can be reduced to 2:3. So for every 2 KS2 blue eyed kids, there will be 3 KS1 blue eyed kids.

The proportion of what?
Proportion of KS1 with blue eyes is 6/8 = 3/4 = 75%
Proportion overall would be (90+135)/(240+180) = 125/420 = 29.7%

xyzandabc Mon 30-Apr-18 19:04:20

Mango is right, I think my way is what they are looking for, but it should have been written 3/8 not 3:8.
I stand by my 1st sentence, it's not a well written question!

JustCallMeJones Mon 30-Apr-18 19:09:38

Thank you, no wonder Ds and I are confused confused

I’ll have a good read through your answers in a wee while.

OP’s posts: |
JustCallMeJones Mon 30-Apr-18 19:12:10

They are currently going over ratios

OP’s posts: |
TheThickenPlots Mon 30-Apr-18 19:25:22

As a secondary maths teacher I’d say that question was rubbish! 3:8 would be 3/11 of the Children in ks2 had blue eyes and therefore 6/11 in ks1- which doesn’t fit any of the answers. They must mean 3/8 which would mean 6/8 of ks1 had blue eyes (135). Primary schools are often rubbish at ratio, students get some weird ideas and always try and use it for probability (incorrectly!) hmm

Lougle Mon 30-Apr-18 19:32:12

I think they mean ⅜ of KS2 children have blue eyes which is 240÷8= 30; 30×3= 90 children.

They then want you to realise that 6/8 can reduce to ¾ and they are writing it (wrongly) 3:4, so 180÷4= 45; 45×3= 135 children.

FiveMoreMinutesPlease Mon 30-Apr-18 19:39:33


Tomorrowillbeachicken Mon 30-Apr-18 19:55:20

I’d say 135 as it’s 3/4

JustCallMeJones Mon 30-Apr-18 20:34:57

Thanks for clarifying. I was trying my hardest to understand but it didn’t make sense.

OP’s posts: |

Join the discussion

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

Join Mumsnet

Already have a Mumsnet account? Log in