I realise this has been done before, but want to get some current thoughts. What are people's experiences of moving a child into school pre-school class and would you recommend it or not? What are the main considerations.
DS has been offered a place in the pre-school class at our local 'good' primary school, to start in September. He'll be going there for reception in 2014 for sure (we live practically next door, so we will get in if we apply!). He's currently in a private day nursery 8am-6pm on the 4 days/week I work. He would do 5 mornings at the school. I am seriously considering the school option, so he develops friendships that will continue with him into school years and also gets used to the 'structure' of school, the building etc. I can just about make the logistics work with some school wrap around care (breakfast club/after school club plus some childminder time) to make the two options work around my job.
Is it worth disrupting him with the move? He loves nursery and is very clear what he would rather do. But, most of his best friends will be leaving for school in September (he is an October baby and his 'class mates' are between 3.0yrs to 4.6yrs). Having been at the same nursery since 9mo I think he might be ready to move on.
Pros and cons: child/adult ratio is slightly better at the day nursery, but the staff are more highly qualified at the pre-school. Both places follow the EYFS so technically the same 'curriculum' but I think the way this is delivered is a bit different. So far as I can tell, the day is a bit more structured at the school nursery and they have 'school-like' facilities like interactive white boards, PCs, which the day nursery doesn't have. Both nursery and pre-school do phonics and numbers within their activities as well as lots of child-centred free flow play. Slightly bigger outside space at the pre-school but 'nicer' outside space (e.g. garden with planters) at the nursery. Nursery is OFSTED 'satisfactory', the school is 'good' (but I am sceptical about Ofsted reports). He's quite bright for his age (natch) - knows all his sounds, numbers into the 30s, generally interested in the world, and quite sociable. His nursery class will constantly be refilled with children turning three (who will come up from the younger rooms in the nursery), whereas the age band will be narrower, with fewer younger children in the pre-school - which probably has pros and cons.
I always thought we would stick with the nursery, because the logistics are a lot simpler however, I have been somewhat dissatisfied recently with the way they communicate and they are pretty sloppy at completion of children's records (explains the ofsted!). They have a pre-school teacher, and their understanding of EYFS is good so far as I can tell, however I think there's some underlying issues with the staff and I suspect there'll be some turnover in the next year which could be disruptive.
So, what did you do? What do you think about this situation? I am in a total quandry and need to decide before the end of the week. Argh!
Also does anyone have experience of a three year old in the after school club? Does it sound like a crazy idea? We'd have to use it if we are to make the pre-school option work.
Please or to access all these features
Please
or
to access all these features
Join our Primary Education forum to discuss starting school and helping your child get the most out of it.
Primary education
Stay at day nursery or move to school nursery class? (sorry long)
14 replies
ManchegoandChutney · 18/03/2013 20:39
OP posts:
Please create an account
To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.