Talk

Advanced search

8yo DD's homework based on Bond films - WIBU to complain?

(143 Posts)
QueenOfFeckingEverything Mon 23-May-11 19:51:28

DD's class are basing this term's work on 'Spies'.

She has come home today saying she doesn't know how to do her homework because she doesn't know who James Bond is. Apparently the homework is to find out about a villain from a Bond film and then write about them - she's left the sheet at school so is unsure of the details though.

Now I am Not Happy with that. Bond films are not suitable for 8yo children - aren't most of them 12 or 15 rated? Surely the school should not be basing homework round films the children should not have seen - obviously I am aware that most of them will have done but it shouldn't be assumed.

Plus as far as I am aware (not a film watcher myself really) they are somewhat sexist, or at least Bond's treatment of women is, and I don't really want the films and their messages given tacit approval by school tbh.

So I am thinking I might write and state my objections...

cat64 Mon 23-May-11 19:56:09

Message withdrawn

TheMonster Mon 23-May-11 19:57:17

I would hold off complaining until you have seen the sheet. Maybe it included Bond as an example.

lovecheese Mon 23-May-11 19:57:39

Bond films do have some cracking baddies, but I would not want an 8 year-old to watch them.

cat64 Mon 23-May-11 19:59:21

Message withdrawn

PanelMember Mon 23-May-11 20:01:03

Before you object, perhaps you should read the sheet to check exactly what's required? I would guess that half the point of the homework is to do some independent research, which you can do without watching the films. There's a wiki page for Ernst Stavro Blofeld, for example.

If you really can't bring yourself to have anything to do with Commander Bond, perhaps you could base the homework on one of the Alex Ryder books, which are very popular with my similarly-aged dd and her friends.

southeastastra Mon 23-May-11 20:04:09

my ds(9) would love homework like this! it would fire his imagination.

they're just fun films, don't over analyse them too much

QueenOfFeckingEverything Mon 23-May-11 20:07:19

I'm not over analysing to point out that many of them have 12/15 certificates.

It won't fire DD's imagination as she, quite rightly IMO, has no idea who the hell Bond is.

GypsyMoth Mon 23-May-11 20:07:32

think they are 12 certificate???

southeastastra Mon 23-May-11 20:09:08

oooh that told me then!

maybe some of the boys would like the homework though - school is so girl centric these days

pozzled Mon 23-May-11 20:09:11

I would check the details first, but I wouldn't be very happy about this as a homework. I certainly wouldn't be showing a Bond film to an 8 year-old. I suppose they could look up some info on Wikipedia but it's still not something I'd particularly want them learning about.

thebestisyettocome Mon 23-May-11 20:12:49

Weird. For one thing a lot of people find Bond films very sexist. Asking an 8 year old girl to critique them is odd hmm

DamselInDisguise Mon 23-May-11 20:13:02

The earlier films are PG rated and they show them on daytime tv all the time. I'd seen bond films at that age (although I didn't like them).

southeastastra Mon 23-May-11 20:13:15

most of them are Pg according to this site btw

PanelMember Mon 23-May-11 20:16:05

I haven't checked them all, but Diamonds Are Forever (one of the films in which Blofeld appears) is PG.

Southeastastra is right, I think, that boys may well like this homework and, as I said earlier, the Alex Ryder books are very popular with this age group. You're entitled to your views, but I'm a bit baffled by the argument that because a child hasn't heard of James Bond they shouldn't be asked to find out about him. What else does that argument apply to? Homework isn't always going to be about something the child already knows.

DamselInDisguise Mon 23-May-11 20:20:19

To be honest, James Bond is a big part of British culture and I see absolutely nothing wrong with learning about him in school. Its a completely legitimate way to learn about the spy genre in fiction, and will help the kids to think more about the spy books written for their age group.

I think you're being quite precious.

pointydog Mon 23-May-11 20:32:00

Do you know any Bond villains? You could describe one to her. It's another way to find out about something.

mrz Mon 23-May-11 20:32:32

The early Bond films are rated PG with the most recent rated PG-13 and you really don't need to watch the film to do the homework.

entertainment.timesonline.co.uk/tol/arts_and_entertainment/specials/for_your_eyes_only/article3660946.ece

www.youtube.com/watch?v=qIZcChkEs5k

southeastastra Mon 23-May-11 20:32:40

loads of bond villans were also women weren't they

mrz Mon 23-May-11 20:37:38

www.whsmith.co.uk/CatalogAndSearch/ProductDetails.aspx?productID=9780198472193

BelovedCunt Mon 23-May-11 20:42:56

get her to write about pussy galore and how hilarious it is that her name means that she has a big fanny and likes to put it about.

goingmadinthecountry Mon 23-May-11 20:47:23

Never really thought about age rating of Bond films - they've always seemed pretty family type stuff to me. I woulldn't complain, but I'm pretty open minded about most things as it leads to interesting discussion with my children. Mind you, with my teacher hat on I wouldn't mention Bond in homework for 8yos as I know it would create controversy.

megapixels Mon 23-May-11 20:48:43

I wouldn't like it too, and yes I find it very sexist. How on earth is it appropriate homework for an 8 year old? Mine would have no idea who or what James Bond is, and rightly so I think.

megapixels Mon 23-May-11 20:50:05

Bond films seem pretty family type? confused I haven't seen the old films but the newer ones (and this is going back to Pierce Brosnan) are anything but.

IvyAndGold Mon 23-May-11 20:51:36

bond films? she's not being taught by alan partridge is she?

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now