My Y2 comfortably reads chapter books at home, usually in about an hour, with very strong understanding.
At school they probably read about 3/4 book bands below where they 'should' be I think. Haven't said anything as up until now I've thought they get the stretch they need at home and it really isn't a problem.
With end of KS1 coming up next year I am now wondering if I should have flagged it with the teacher? I do trust the teacher and think if my DC has been assessed at this level there must be a reason for it?
I have noticed that other children who started ahead continue to stay ahead in terms of book bands etc. I go in and help and if I am honest I think my DC reads better and has better understanding then many I hear that are much higher up in terms of the reading system. But then again, I know my DC well and I don't know the children I hear :). Does it matter anyway?
DC when asked questions by the teacher, when heard read, goes to pieces a bit and frequently does not show what they can understand etc. My judgement has always been in time they will show what they can do etc. When we had parents evening the teacher was quick to tell me that DC couldn't understand something small in a recent book, I got the feeling they wanted to keep DC where they were. As I say I do trust them but was a bit puzzled by this. I got the feeling they thought I might challenge the book band/reading level so had a counter argument pre-prepared. As it was I never asked.
So, upshot is this. My DC reads very simple stuff at school, very basic text and at home can read Swallows and Amazons & 'get' it, well not quite but it's increasingly close :). So far I've said and done nothing. If it isn't going to have any impact in terms of schools view and development going forward then happy to still say and do nothing for now :). WWYD?
Please or to access all these features
Please
or
to access all these features
Join our Primary Education forum to discuss starting school and helping your child get the most out of it.
Primary education
Reading again, does this matter?
8 replies
NorhamGardens · 30/11/2010 11:10
OP posts:
Please create an account
To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.