Talk

Advanced search

Fish Oils? which one safe in pregnancy

(21 Posts)
Lulu41 Fri 23-May-03 14:06:06

Does anyone know of a brand made for pregnancy as keep reading about the need to increase intake in third trimester and cant find any Omega/Fish oil supplements that are geared towards pregnant women?

chanelno5 Fri 23-May-03 14:11:00

Hi lulu41 - this is something I've been wondering about too. I'm sure on the Eye Q website it said that it is safe to take during pg, but nothing on the box. Also, Boots do a Mum To Be supplement that contains EPA and DHA from tuna oil. Someone else might beable to tell you more, but HTH.

Marina Fri 23-May-03 14:18:11

Lulu, I have found it REALLY hard to get sensible advice about this one too. One brand, Efanatal, has apparently been discontinued by the makers (cheers Efamol).
The only one I can find is the rather expensive but safe Zita West Vital DHA and that is what I am using. Unless you can get to John Bell and Croyden on Wigmore St in London you have to use her website mail order service, which is very prompt and helpful.
I actually went as far as posting about this on a women's health website and the obstetrician (well-known and respected as far as I know) said he recommended NO supplements in pregnancy, which was not helpful, frankly!
I will be well chuffed if someone on here can come up with a cheaper, safe brand for pregnant women...

Marina Fri 23-May-03 14:20:17

Ooh, Chanel, thanks for the Boots tip. Now I just have to find a branch of said shop in the City that sells *anything* acknowledging the existence of pregnant women in the Square Mile...how are you keeping?

chanelno5 Fri 23-May-03 14:39:10

Hi Marina - I'm ok, though my mind is in a total pg fog and I seem to spend most of my time talking gibberish (Hey, what's new!) Hope you're ok and looking after yourself. Not long to go for you now, you lucky thing , I've got ages Any progress on the nasty email incident? Hope you're feeling better about things and able to put the horrible business behind you.

Yes, was quite a lucky find, the Boots Mum To Be capsules. Only £6 for 30 one a day caps, so probably cheaper than the Zita West ones. EPA content is 31mg and DHA is 122mg, how does this compare? Also, can sometimes get them on offer (BOGOF etc) and can use Boots points to pay for them. Can you tell I love a bargain?

Marina Fri 23-May-03 14:46:36

I'll check the bottle tonight for contents (after the trip to Ozer) but on the ££££ front there is a definite balance in favour of Boots. Am also a big fan of Boots for its BOGOFs and points.
The DHA should help our poor old brains as well as our babies'. Wish I could detect any improvement in mine so far. Good to hear from you again!

Marina Fri 23-May-03 14:47:43

Off topic but not much progress on nasty e-mail, thanks for asking. No-one has topped me yet, though, so trying to stay sanguine about the whole thing.

nobby Fri 23-May-03 14:58:08

I'm taking the Boots capsules but wondered re. the tuna oil as we're supposed to be avoiding tuna whilst pg because of the mercury etc. How does it work? I'm assuming that as Boots hasn't withdrawn the capsules they're fine

Marina Fri 23-May-03 15:04:02

Nobby, that's a fair point...I think the reason for using tuna oil in these supplements is that unlike cod liver oil (the usual supplement source of DHA) it is not high in retinol. Retinol, derived from animal sources such as fish and meat, is contraindicated in pregnancy in high doses. You have given me pause for thought, I wonder whether there is somewhere on the Boots website where we can ask about this.

nobby Fri 23-May-03 15:20:57

Well, I've emailed Boots - I'll let you know if I get a response.

Marina Fri 23-May-03 15:22:14

That's great, I'd be very interested to hear. Thanks!

NQWWW Fri 23-May-03 15:39:20

Why not try flaxseed oil (sometimes called linseed oil) instead? It has the omega 3 and omega 6 fatty acids in exactly the right ratios. You can buy it from health food shops, and you keep it in the fridge and use it cold - ie not for cooking, so in dressings or mixed into food once you've cooked it.

vkr Fri 23-May-03 15:59:27

The ones I took were Boots Super Strength Concentrated fish oils. These did not have any CLO in and the pharmasist at boots did call HQ for advice. They are not specifically marketed to pregnant women, but were available at Boots in High Holborn and Waterlo station !!
ds is 10mo and only a genius in my eyes so who knows if they worked

aloha Fri 23-May-03 16:21:00

The only thing you are advised to avoid is retinol (vit A) so as long as the product does not contain retinol they are safe. I recently read that after further research scientists beleive that tuna is not a hazard (ie no probs with babies at all).

aloha Fri 23-May-03 16:24:15

The only thing you are advised to avoid is retinol (vit A) so as long as the product does not contain retinol they are safe. I recently read that after further research scientists beleive that tuna is not a hazard (ie no probs with babies at all).

aloha Fri 23-May-03 16:25:42

The study was, I think, of babies born to mothers who ate tons of tuna! Can't find it at the mo though, but think I remember it correctly.

BTW did you know some large studies showed that taking probiotic supps or drinks during the last trimester and while breastfeeding cut the risk of asthma by up to 50%?

BIBIBOO Wed 26-May-04 14:47:16

does anyone know of a substitute for fish oil that is veggie friendly, but will still do good things for my baby's brain?

gloworm Wed 26-May-04 14:50:11

bibiboo, you can you flax seed oil (also called linseed). comes in seeds, which you need to crush, or in liquid. Also comes in capsules, but these are usually geletine.

gloworm Wed 26-May-04 14:51:09

forgot to mention "Higher Nature" is a really good quality one, available in health shops.

Jimjams Wed 26-May-04 15:52:42

Any eye Q type product should be fine. As long as it isn't fish *liver* oil you are OK. In previous pregnancies I have taken the efantal, this time I am taking one from a US company.

Doesn't have to be fish oils, flax oil etc is fine as well - hemp oil even better (although rather green)!

Jimjams Wed 26-May-04 15:54:09

Good quality fish oils are purified and tested for mercury content. That's why I ge thr stuff from the states, but I think eye Q is OK

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: