Advertisement

loader

Talk

Advanced search

Would you like to be a member of our research panel? Join here - there's (nearly) always a great incentive offered for your views.

Chinese chart??

(48 Posts)
AnotherHelen Fri 03-Jun-05 10:39:30

Has anyone tried the chinese chart gender prediction? if so was it correct?

Janh Fri 03-Jun-05 10:59:28

There are at least 2 different charts, AH - one of them was dead right for my kids and the other was completely wrong!

This one from babyworld is the one that was right for me. This is the other one. If you open them side-by-side and compare them you can see the differences (look at age 30 particularly).

Pamina3 Fri 03-Jun-05 11:16:19

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Hazellnut Fri 03-Jun-05 12:34:58

Can't remember which one I looked at but it was correct and only that and the wedding ring said she would be a girl..... Everything else said boy !! So must be true then

logic Fri 03-Jun-05 12:35:54

It was right the first time and wrong the second. Hmmm.

jessicasmummy Fri 03-Jun-05 12:38:29

OMG - according to this i will be having another girl - NO!!!! I want a boy?! Why couldnt i wait an extra month!!!!

PiccadillyCircus Fri 03-Jun-05 12:39:22

First one wrong for DS, second one right.

For DS2/DD the first one predicts girl, the second one predicts girl.

So who can tell .

Trix1 Fri 03-Jun-05 13:38:40

The first one was righ for me and the second one wrong as well. I am trying to conceive now and according to the first one is I conceive this month it will be a girl which would be perfect.

swiperfox Fri 03-Jun-05 14:03:43

I tried to concieve ds to a chinese chart to make sure we got a boy. At the time we actually did concieve I had messed up and got the dayes wrong so it said we would have a girl.

We had a boy lol phew!!!

Chuffed Fri 03-Jun-05 14:06:42

As dd could have been conceived at end of June beginning of July that would make the first one right and the second wrong. For this one all going well by the first we are having another girl, by the second a boy so time will tell for us.

expatinscotland Fri 03-Jun-05 14:08:19

It was right w/my DD. Says this one is a boy. Guess we'll wait and see.

Tessiebear Fri 03-Jun-05 14:18:01

i used the gender charts to try for a girl with this pregnancy (both charts said it was my girl month) And ............. its a boy

Trix1 Fri 03-Jun-05 14:33:53

Thinking about this it means that everyone who is a certain age and conceives on the same month will have the same sex child. I dont think so - I suppose its just harmless fun.

AnotherHelen Fri 03-Jun-05 17:01:42

I really want to know the sex of this baby now! i had my 20 week scan about 3 weeks ago and never asked, but i would just like a clue as to what the sex is if u see what i mean - sorry if i sound crackers! i have 2 boys and would LOVE a girl!! im just torturing myself i think

bonym Fri 03-Jun-05 17:17:44

1st chart - right first time, wrong 2nd

2nd chart - wrong 1st time, right 2nd!

It's a load of rubbish

rodeo1 Fri 03-Jun-05 18:50:40

Well I've just done the one that JanH says was right for her, and it's right for me 2 too (got 1 dd and 1 ds) predicting a dd for me this time round - will have to wait and see for that one!

Whizzz Fri 03-Jun-05 19:04:55

The 1st chart was right for me when I had DS !

Trix1 Fri 03-Jun-05 20:43:46

It seems the first chart is right for most of us.....

Frizbe Fri 03-Jun-05 20:47:03

Yep 1st chart was right for me 2!

rodeo1 Sat 04-Jun-05 12:58:00

AnotherHelen, what do the charts say for you this time?

AnotherHelen Sat 04-Jun-05 13:23:35

Hiya well the first chart is wright for my first and wrong for my second but the second chart is wright both times! for this baby however, both charts say a girl!! which would be great!!! but i dare not raise my hopes just in case!! i know it sounds cliche but the main thing is a healthy baby! - boy or girl!! i tried the needle test years ago and it said i would have a boy another boy and then a girl and i already have the first 2 boys! so it kinda just makes u wonder??? xxx

hunkermunker Sat 04-Jun-05 13:36:53

I'll be having a girl following either of these charts!

The first time, I conceived on my birthday - so I was either having a boy or a girl depending which age I was - lol! I had a boy

KMS Sun 05-Jun-05 16:04:34

Tru this questionare for a bit of a laugh.
here

rodeo1 Sun 05-Jun-05 18:48:27

Wow! That's one long test! Very quick to do though so don't be put off! I like that, how funny.....anyway I got 52% boy 48% girl!

I'll go and tell the girls about it on the antenatal thread!

Trix1 Sun 05-Jun-05 19:04:24

I have kep this questionaire to do when I am pregnant as I am currently trying very hard to conceive. I guess I am on the wrong thread here.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now