Advanced search

Pregnant? See how your baby develops, your body changes, and what you can expect during each week of your pregnancy with the Mumsnet Pregnancy Calendar.

Can I eat scallops?

(12 Posts)
Jasmum Fri 11-Feb-05 11:11:51

Might be an obvious answer, but should I eat scallops whilst pregnant? Planning a valentines day meal and was thinking of serving these as a starter.....

Cod Fri 11-Feb-05 11:14:04

Message withdrawn

colditzmum Fri 11-Feb-05 11:15:48

I don't think so. I think they are filter feeders, which means they eat all the rubbish that floats to the bottom of the sea.

That, coming from me, is very hypocritical, because one of my favorite dishes whilst pg was a pint of unpeeled prawns!!

Cod Fri 11-Feb-05 11:16:12

Message withdrawn

Tessiebear Fri 11-Feb-05 11:16:56

Dont think you should - but i am pg at the moment and never rule out seafood

colditzmum Fri 11-Feb-05 11:19:49

Because all the crap in sewage and stuff like nuclear waste can build up in your system, ajnd IF they cross the placenta (which I can't remember if they do, btw) they will be building up in a very immature system. I think it's something to do with mercury.

Also, the amount of sewage they eat has got to be a food poisoning hazard.

colditzmum Fri 11-Feb-05 11:22:19

I ate loads of seafood when pregnant, it is full of selenium and other healthy things. I knew I wasn't supposed to.

Roobie Fri 11-Feb-05 11:24:28

I think you should avoid seafood that is mainly eaten raw - as long as the scallops are cooked (ie opaque and firm) I don't see the problem.

SofiaAmes Fri 11-Feb-05 23:29:14

I think that the only reason for avoiding scallops while pregnant would be if you think there might be a chance that you could be allergic to them (ie family history of food allergies).
For example, my father is deathly allergic to all mollusks (scallops, oysters, squid etc.) and he developed this allergy in his early 30's. I developed the same allergy in my early 30's too. (luckily, I was aware of the possibility and as soon as I noticed a few hives, I got tested and am able to eat some mollusks, but not scallops, in moderation). If I had had children in my 20's before I developed my allergy, then it would have been wise for me to avoid scallops during my pregnancy given my father's allergy.
sorry, it's a little complicated, but does that make sense?

sweetkitty Sat 12-Feb-05 18:29:09

you should avoid scallops as they are filter feeders this means that they can accumulate toxins from algae found in their feeding waters that can cause diarrhoea, vomiting and even a nasty paralytic shellfish poisoning.

in saying that all British scallops have to come from category A waters which means they are very closely monitored for the algae and for bacteria and viruses from sewage. they are usually picked far out to sea away from any sewage. the cooking instructions should also eliminiate bacteria and viruses. In addition, the part of the scallop that acculates these toxins is discarded at sea. Yes I am very sad in knowing the insides of a scallop but it's my job!!

As long as they are bought from a reputable source (supermarket) and are cooked according to pack instructions they should be OK.

sweetkitty Sat 12-Feb-05 18:29:45

only seafood to be avoided is oysters as these are generally eaten raw.

franch Sat 12-Feb-05 18:35:12

I was very gung-ho about seafood, which I love, last time, but learned the hard way - got nasty food poisoning twice from scallops (you'd think I'd have given up after the first time, wouldn't you?). DH ate the same both times with no reaction - he does have an iron stomach but I'm convinced my system was more sensitive due to pregnancy and just chucked out anything doubtful, as I've never experienced this from seafood before or since.

This time round, I'm avoiding seafood altogether

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: