Talk

Advanced search

Can you just confirm with me that this is not a good name

(48 Posts)
hotcrumpets Mon 09-Jul-07 13:15:25

We have two so far

Harry or Max (both of which I love so don't mind which one)

but DP won't move off

Troy

he really want's it and i'm sorry to anybody with DC named it but I can't stand it

it isn't a good name is it?

TutterJane Mon 09-Jul-07 13:15:52

no its odd

funnypeculiar Mon 09-Jul-07 13:16:33

Yours are better.
Of course.

NAB3 Mon 09-Jul-07 13:16:35

Whether it is a good name or not I feel you have to both agree and be happy with what you choose. You aren't so you both need to think again. Maybe suggest something really ridiculous so Harry/Max sound fabulous.

tiredemma Mon 09-Jul-07 13:17:01

Troy is not a fave of mine.

(Harry is! Ds1 is HArry!)

bobsmum Mon 09-Jul-07 13:17:09

Tempest?

Not a good name.

tissy Mon 09-Jul-07 13:17:17

Don't like it myslef. Can't you have it as a middle name, and hide it away?

funnypeculiar Mon 09-Jul-07 13:18:21

(Agree with NAB3, btw - dd's name was more dh's choise than mine, and I STILL slightly regret it...

sweetkitty Mon 09-Jul-07 13:18:34

I personally don't like Troy either and I know a Troy and it doesn't suit him little rough and tumble boy.

Prefer Harry TBH it's so hard trying to agree on a name isn't it?

Slubberdegullion Mon 09-Jul-07 13:18:40

I like your choices. Please vito Troy.

doughnuts Mon 09-Jul-07 13:19:02

yes, Troy Tempest ! Have it as a middle name as a compromise ! Max is nice. There are quite a lot of Harrys still around though.

SecondhandRose Mon 09-Jul-07 13:20:13

Isn't that the name of the gorgeous plastic surgeon in the US thing with Joely Richardson?

Stargazing Mon 09-Jul-07 13:21:47

love Max, ambivalent about Harry, hate Troy. What is it with these blokes? Mine kept going on about the name Stanley!! Stanley, I ask you!

doughnuts Mon 09-Jul-07 13:28:53

what is it with old blokes names - eg Stanley ?

Stargazing Mon 09-Jul-07 13:32:40

I know! awful. He justified it on the basis of the link to Stanley knives - he kept saying "Stanley! Sharpest tool in the box!" to me, over and over, as if that was going to convince me. Wally.

hotcrumpets Mon 09-Jul-07 13:35:00

DP does that with Troy

"But like Troy Bayliss, he's really cool"

um no

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

doughnuts Mon 09-Jul-07 13:39:17

like Des ..troy

KerryMum Mon 09-Jul-07 13:39:58

Troy - No

Yours are nice.

Pruners Mon 09-Jul-07 13:43:56

Message withdrawn

bohemianbint Mon 09-Jul-07 13:44:47

Troy sounds a bit porn star - ish....

hotcrumpets Mon 09-Jul-07 13:48:06

I knew it was horrible, it sounds really hard (not in a tough kind of way) to me.

I will show dp the thread when he comes in, this should convince him

Miaou Mon 09-Jul-07 13:59:59

Don't like Troy - the others are fine

(now come and add your opinion to my name thread please

tortoiseSHELL Mon 09-Jul-07 14:01:44

Troy is the name of Laura Palmer's horse in Twin Peaks.

Harry and Max are both great names!

cupcake78 Mon 09-Jul-07 14:04:12

Troy

It just reminds me of The Battle of Troy.

Please don't call your baby after a Battle. If DP insists on it then you could suggest Waterloo, Falklands etc for a middle name .

Your names are lovely, stick with them!!!

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now