Advanced search

Baby names - is this a complete no no!?

(22 Posts)
chloechloe Fri 21-Oct-16 12:46:49

We're expecting DD2 in December and pretty much the only name DH and I both like is the middle name we gave to DD1!

DH doesn't see why we can't use the same name for DD2 - after all it's just a middle name written on the birth certificate but not otherwise used.

To me though it just doesn't seem to be the done thing. Then again we're at a loss to find another name we both love.

GreenGoblin0 Fri 21-Oct-16 12:58:33

don't see anything wrong with it. I really like my dd's middle name and might use it if our 2nd DC due in April is a girl

GinIsIn Fri 21-Oct-16 13:01:13

Well, it is a bit unoriginal. I think I'd be quite put out TBH when I got older if my parents hadn't given me my own name but just recycled part of one they'd already given my sister.

Oysterbabe Fri 21-Oct-16 13:55:39

I think it's a bit odd and would come up with another name.

NameChange30 Fri 21-Oct-16 13:58:29

I think it's a shame you used for DD1's middle name, but if it's the only name you both love, just give it to DD2!

Would it be really silly to give her DD1's first name as a middle name?!

I would never use the other names on my shortlist as a middle name - middle name will be a family name that I wouldn't use as a first name!

kikisdelivery Fri 21-Oct-16 14:00:52

My OH's middle name is the name his younger brother ended up with (albeit in shortened format), so I don't think it's a bad thing! His mum obviously didn't!

Kittenrush Fri 21-Oct-16 15:33:01

Of course it's fine! If you like the name and it suits then why on earth not? It'll be nice when they grow up that they have that connection!

Lizb1990 Fri 21-Oct-16 16:04:09

I would have quite liked having my big sisters middle name as my first growing up smile would have felt like I was named after her, I think its quite sweet smile

BikeRunSki Fri 21-Oct-16 17:08:58

My sister and I have never got on. We'd hate to share names. (She speaks very highly of me too wink)
Really, of the many 💯s of girls names out there, there is only 1 you both like?

BadToTheBone Fri 21-Oct-16 17:28:29

I don't see an issue with it. I know siblings called Nicola Sarah and Sarah Nicola (not real names), you'd never know unless they tell you.

albertcampionscat Fri 21-Oct-16 17:32:37

Could you change the first one's middle name (or just get rid of it)?

sycamore54321 Fri 21-Oct-16 18:52:31

No, it is disrespectful to their individual identities and I would find it very hurtful if I were either child, particularly the younger. They will presumably share a surname, that is enough. They each deserve their own name.

SnookieSnooks Fri 21-Oct-16 19:03:05

You don't have to have a middle name..... my mum doesn't have I one. I would avoid giving both DCs the same name unless it's one that is passed down the family

chloechloe Fri 21-Oct-16 22:05:00

I know it seems ridiculous that we're struggling to find another name! But we're both expats living in a third country which means our children will grow up with 3 languages. It's not so easy to find a name that works well in all 3 - some names are lovely in English for example but then pronounced completely differently elsewhere.

Interesting to see how divided opinions are! It seems to be going a bit far to say it would be disrespectful to my DD2 though!

MrsGsnow18 Fri 21-Oct-16 22:29:46

I don't think it's the worst thing you could name your child but maybe not totally ideal.
Some people end up using their middle names more than others e.g in professional way when older.
However the majority of people's middle names stay fairly hidden away and are never used.

When the time comes I'm sure you and your DH will know what feels right.

ShowOfHands Fri 21-Oct-16 22:33:50

I know two families who have done this. The children don't give a flying fig.

oleoleoleole Fri 21-Oct-16 23:00:04

I would feel like you had lacked imagination and couldn't be bothered to choose another name

Kittenrush Mon 24-Oct-16 18:46:55

I totally don't think it would be like you'd lacked imagination or was at all disrespectful. Especially having to translate the name to three different languages! I know it isn't the same but my niece is named after my middle name. I was thrilled when I found out and she absolutely loves that we have this little thing we share. She's 17 now and has no issue with it at all xxx

Sheddie Mon 24-Oct-16 18:56:45

My younger sister has my middle name as her first name and it has never been an issue at all. In fact I don't think it has ever really been discussed except Mum saying when they unexpectedly had another child it gave her a chance to use the name. Go for it I say.

WaitroseCoffeeCostaCup Mon 24-Oct-16 18:57:31

I don't think it's odd. We're expecting #4 and I was keen on one of the boys middle names for this one of its a boy but Husband thinks it's weird!

SimonNeilshair Mon 24-Oct-16 19:00:02

I know two families who have done this, I don't think there is anything wrong with it. It's better to choose a name you both really love than one your not that arsed about.

Beeziekn33ze Mon 24-Oct-16 21:37:48

I knew a family where two brothers had the same 3rd name, I never asked why. Years later one brother had sons, one of them had that same name as his first name. Odd but that name must have been important to the family I suppose.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now