Talk

Advanced search

New Catholic, do you (lifelong Catholics) go to Confession for missing Mass before taking holy communion again?

(36 Posts)
Otterspotter Sat 13-May-17 12:23:35

I have recently converted through the RCIA process.

We are going camping in Cornwall at half term and it is going to be extremely impractical to go to Mass for the two Sundays of half term.

I understand that missing Mass is classed as a mortal sin. Do I need to receive Reconciliation before I can receive communion again?

BawbagBiggins Sat 13-May-17 12:32:09

Missing Mass is not a mortal sin.

Go and enjoy your holiday and take communion as usual when you return smile

MaybesAye Sat 13-May-17 15:31:57

Missing mass IS a mortal sin. Yes. Go to confession upon your return before you receive communion. OR make a heroic effort to get to mass. If it's genuinely not possible and you tried then you haven't deliberately gone out of your way to miss mass.

SwedishEdith Sat 13-May-17 15:36:52

Oh, my gosh, yes. We were always dragged to Mass even when on holiday. It's Bad. Black mark on your soul Bad.

NannyR Sat 13-May-17 16:38:16

Does anyone have the bible reference for where Jesus said missing weekly mass was a mortal sin?

ollieplimsoles Sat 13-May-17 19:01:42

I understand that missing Mass is classed as a mortal sin. Do I need to receive Reconciliation before I can receive communion again?

Why on EARTH would you chose to pander to a belief system with this rule in place. Its ridiculous, 'a mortal sin'.

Why is this a 'mortal sin', I'm genuinely interested.

MaybesAye Sat 13-May-17 21:01:38

Good grief. Someone comes on to MN to clarify something about their faith and it's practice and the anti Catholics come out to slate everything. No one dragged her to RCIA. The OP was asking for clarification. Her decision re her faith and religion is already made.

Btw NannyR you can google the answer to your question for yourself.

LauraMipsum Sat 13-May-17 21:06:39

Because there is grave matter, full knowledge and full consent ollie - two out of three gets you only a venial sin.

In the unlikely event that you actually wanted to know, that is.

reallyanotherone Sat 13-May-17 21:14:49

This was taught in my dad's days, c.1930.

When I took fhc in the 80's was no longer taught that you needed to go to confession (as reconciliation was called) if you missed mass.

So I wouldn't worry about it. My dad would though.

Luckystar1 Sat 13-May-17 21:18:22

I'm a lifelong Catholic and it would never in a million years cross my mind to go to confession for missing mass.

Enjoy your holiday!

LedaP Sat 13-May-17 21:20:22

I had an entirely catholic education and studied theology. One of my closest friends is a priest.

No one expects you to go to confession for missing mass.

Waterlemon Sat 13-May-17 21:27:01

So this is taken from DS book that he is using for his First holy communion programme.

Missing Mass is not a sin!

NannyR Sat 13-May-17 21:28:27

maybe I did Google before I made my post. I found reference to a passage in Hebrews (10;26-31) which a priest had loosely interpreted to fit his argument and lots of references to the Catholic catechism and Canon law, written by man, but nothing referring to what Jesus himself actually taught in the gospels.

MaybesAye Sat 13-May-17 22:10:39

Well then Nanny nothing I provide you with will answer your question. Ask your local parish priest. I googled too and found a tonne of info. Mass isn't just any old church service. It's the celebration of the Eucharist. Catholics believe that this is the body, blood, soul and divinity of our lord Jesus Christ. The bible is part of the revelation. There's sacred tradition too.

Waterlemon Sat 13-May-17 22:27:43

The first part of Sunday Mass is the Penetintial act, so by taking part, you would have confessed your sins anyway.

www.ourcatholicfaith.org/mass/penitentialrite.html

NannyR Sat 13-May-17 22:29:57

I was asking specifically about where in the Bible does Jesus say that missing weekly mass is a mortal sin?

I was baptised and brought up in a Catholic family, educated in Catholic schools, I went to mass every week as a child. I know about the sanctity of mass and what Catholics believe about the eucharist, I just wanted to know if there was any Biblical basis to not fulfilling your Sunday obligation being a sin, as I don't remember being taught it. I will ask my vicar in the morning though.

Radishal Sat 13-May-17 22:33:52

I'm a Catholic. Relax.
My Mum used to follow that sort of rule. I know of no Catholic (and I know plenty who aren't as rubbish at it as I am) who does it now.
If it makes you feel better then best yourself up about it. It's not a mortal sin.

Napoliforte Sat 13-May-17 22:35:11

Catholicism doesn't have a huge lot to do with the bible, which you'd know, NannyR if you were Catholic!wink

I was raised as a highly trad Catholic and we were taught that missing Mass is a mortal sin, and you can't take communion if you've got a mortal sin on your soul, because if you do, it'll burn through your tongue.

Fact.

Radishal Sat 13-May-17 22:35:53

I meant "beat yourself up" not "best yourself up". Freudian slip of the post.

imip Sat 13-May-17 22:36:32

Hmmm, I was brought up catholic but am now an atheist. My uncle is a priest, has been for 50 odd years. He often stays with us when in the UK. I've never seen him go out of his way to go to Mass when with us. He's not a parish priest as he is retired, but he does supply, when priests are on holidays, so he still often says mass.

We live in London, lots of chances to attend mass. Interesting thread....

Radishal Sat 13-May-17 22:38:33

If your uncle is over 80 , I think he isn't under an obligation . Something like that.

Friendofsadgirl Sat 13-May-17 22:39:35

This is taken from Catholiceducation.org :

Of course, serious circumstances arise which excuse a person from attending Mass, such as if a person is sick, has to deal with an emergency, or cannot find a Mass to attend without real burden .

If there is nowhere you can feasibly go to attend mass while you're away, I'd say you were excused? There's a list of Catholic churches in Cornwall here.

Radishal Sat 13-May-17 22:45:07

My atheist Dad would make a point of finding Catholic Churches for my mum on holiday. He found one when in Sri Lanka. It was like a challenge for him.
I won't tease you, op, because you are a newbie and it's obviously very important to you.

imip Sat 13-May-17 22:54:54

Not 80 yet 😃 I know he is very religious but I also think he is progressive (we don't really talk religion). However, he has stayed with dh and I before we were married, and he is very close to his brother (my other uncle), who is gay. So I suppose he has been aware or mortal sin (I guess homosexuality and sex before marriage is a mortal sin?). I'm in my mid 40s googling catholic catechism on a Saturday night 😃

Luckystar1 Sun 14-May-17 07:13:25

Didn't Jesus say in the bible about wherever 2 or 3 gather in my name I am there? Say some prayers with your husband.

Unless you attend mass and take communion every day, then you are just missing another daily mass surely?

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now