Skip to main content
Skip to main navigation
Skip to talk navigation

Active discussions

Please or to access all these features

Add post

Watch this thread

Save thread

Start a new thread

Flip thread

Hide thread

My feed

Saved Active Unanswered threads

Getting started FAQ's

Unanswered threads Acronyms Talk guidelines

Hide shortcut buttons

Talk

Flip

Join our community on the Pet forum to discuss anything related to pets.

1 2 3

Join our community on the Pet forum to discuss anything related to pets.

Pets

Not fit to own a gold fish

57 replies

handlemecarefully · 14/02/2005 13:44

Recently on a whim I bought a gold fish starter kit for £9.99 (it consisted of a goldfish bowl, plastic plant, small book on keeping goldfish, a container of fish food, and water conditioner). I was told I couldn't buy the fish at the same time, but needed to fill the goldfish bowl with water and use the water conditioner, and then take a sample of the water back to the pet shop 48 hours later to be tested.

Well we went back to the pet shop on Saturday en famille, and the 4 of us waited with bated breath whilst the water was tested.

I knew it was bad news when the girl who had disappeared with my water came back mob handed flanked by a colleague. I think she was expecting trouble...

They were brandishing 4 colourful test tubes, and told me that they couldn't release a gold fish to my care because my water was high in nitrite and nitrates.

I have to add still more water conditioner and return in another couple of days with a fresh sample.

What am I doing wrong????

OP posts:

Report

handlemecarefully · 14/02/2005 13:45

P.S

Despite being unfit to keep goldfish, I allowed to keep my two pre-school children.....

OP posts:

Twiglett · 14/02/2005 13:47

you appear to be shopping at 'fishmafia-are-us'

are there no other shops?

FGS its a fish

gingerbear · 14/02/2005 13:49

HMC.
Oh, there was a thread about the merits and demerits of different types of fish as pets a while ago.
Goldfish are big poo-ers apparently. Will search...

charleypops · 14/02/2005 13:50

gingerbear · 14/02/2005 13:53

first fish

handlemecarefully · 14/02/2005 13:54

Lol Twiglett
Those were my first thoughts...but then I begrudgingly acknowledged that a dead goldfish would be a bit of a downer!(and apparently my water would kill them off in time)

Thanks gingerbear - I don't know why but I never seem to be able to find what I want when I do a search...

OP posts:

gingerbear · 14/02/2005 13:59

Couldn't you go out and find some frogspawn / tadpoles instead? I am sure they could handle the nitrates.

handlemecarefully · 14/02/2005 14:02

Have you done this gingerbear?

What's the plan of action. Do you watch them develop and then release them into the 'wild' when they are jumpy frogs?

I haven't quite given up on the fish though...I might get some distilled water (as per that thread you attached for me)

OP posts:

gingerbear · 14/02/2005 14:14

I have - years ago. I think I kept them in a round goldfish bowl - mainly pond water and weed from the pond for them to eat. Changed half the water with fresh tap water (allowed to sit for 24 hrs) every week. About 50% of them died or were eaten by other tadpoles. Took them back to the pond when they got their legs.

guess what - have found a /link{http://web.ukonline.co.uk/conker/pond-dip/tadpoles.htm\tadpole link} !

gingerbear · 14/02/2005 14:15

am crap at links today

handlemecarefully · 14/02/2005 14:17

Thanks gingerbear. I am tempted to try this! It sounds fun.

OP posts:

SeaShells · 14/02/2005 14:22

I've never heard of this, I thought you just go in and buy a fish! That's what we've always done, why not just go to another shop?

hercules · 14/02/2005 14:23

Cant you "borrow" some water from responsible fish owners and pass it off as your own?

handlemecarefully · 14/02/2005 14:38

Seashells - because if my water is dodgy I don't want to kill off the fish....

OP posts:

SeaShells · 14/02/2005 14:47

The shop is probably being over cautious, but I can see what you mean, it'd be upsetting for your children if they were to die straight away. Seems such a carry on just for a goldfish, I won one at a fair when I was younger and it lived for years. The tadpoles sound like a great idea, it'd be very interesting watching them change.

misdee · 14/02/2005 14:48

get a filter.

gingerbear · 14/02/2005 15:12

Misdee is the FishMaiden

misdee · 14/02/2005 15:14

haha. maybe i should change my name.

goldfish are dirty fish tho, would invest in a cheap filter, less water changes and means u can keeop the water at the right level easier.

handlemecarefully · 14/02/2005 15:36

Okay - will look for a filter. Will they do one small enough for a goldfish bowl (estimated capacity circa 2.5 - 3 litres)?

OP posts:

misdee · 14/02/2005 15:37

should do. just a basic one will do.

marthamoo · 14/02/2005 15:37

Can't believe they do this!

What happened to winning a fish at the fair and carrying it home in a plastic bag?

I was bought a goldfish for my 5th birthday and it finally carked it when I was 26. And no, it wasn't a case of it dying and being secretly replaced! For a long time it lived in a little circular bowl that only got cleaned out when I couldn't see the fish any more.

gingerbear · 14/02/2005 15:38

Think fish at fairs have been banned now moo. Health and Safety regs no doubt.

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Email address

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

misdee · 14/02/2005 15:39

apparently fish have rights too

it is a living animal like a cat or dog, and deserves a clean enviroment.

snafu · 14/02/2005 15:39

Marthamoo, I was just wondering if I should admit to only cleaning my goldfish tank when they can write their own names in the crud... Had 'em for 4 years though - they seem quite happy.

God, am I going to get the RSPCA on my doorstep now?

marthamoo · 14/02/2005 15:44

I think they like it mucky. The vet said that our fish would be fine when we went on holiday so long as we hadn't cleaned the tank out for a while. They suck the gunk off the little stones at the bottom. Yes, fish eat their own poo.

Flip

1 2 3

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.