Advertisement

loader

Talk

Advanced search

Trade Union - plural?

(7 Posts)
tribpot Tue 08-Sep-09 20:15:43

All,

I should probably be more incensed that my council has written to tell me that basically there will be no refuse collection service from here to eternity and I need to be turning the garden into a landfill site. But I can't help but wince at "Trade Unions have announced ..."

Now, I was taught it was Trades Union like Directors General and Courts Martial but instinctively it doesn't feel the same. General and Martial are adjective, Union isn't? Wiki reckons the proper plural is Trade Unions particularly as most represent a single trade rather than a group of trades?

gscrym Tue 08-Sep-09 20:25:46

I thought it would depend if there was more than one union involved as there can be more than one trade within a union. The one I'm in has a load of different trades in it. It may involve Unison and possibly Unite - so two unions.

Or my lack of grammatical ability may now be glaringly obvious.grin

Pyrocanthus Tue 08-Sep-09 21:24:29

Fowler's Modern English Usage: 'trade union (not trades union). Pl, trade unions. But Trades Union Congress, abbrev. TUC.'

Trades union doesn't make sense as a plural for several unions, as trade is an adjective here, so it isn't analogous to courts martial. There's something historical going on here though, because you're right, trades union used to be common. Possibly the TUC is a union congress for different trades, and trades union became current because of that? Waffle, ramble.

Trade unions, anyway.

cattj Tue 08-Sep-09 23:11:26

Trade Union - One Union for a single trade.

Trades Union - One Union for multiple trades.

No?

Why not?

Pyrocanthus Tue 08-Sep-09 23:26:51

Yes, possibly, cattj, but the plural of trades union would then be trades unions - multiple unions for multiple trades.

LyraSilvertongue Tue 08-Sep-09 23:35:28

Pyrocanthus is right.

cat64 Tue 08-Sep-09 23:59:33

Message withdrawn

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now