Talk

Advanced search

on line 1 / in line 1

(10 Posts)
AuldAlliance Mon 01-Jun-09 11:54:29

When quoting from text, what preposition do you use:
"on line 1, the author expresses his awe...." or
"in line 1..."?
Will explain why I'm asking once I get feedback!

TIA

MaryHuff Mon 01-Jun-09 12:02:37

In line 1

I would only use "on line 1" if referring to a telephone call (i.e. when people dial in to a switchboard)

gerontius Mon 01-Jun-09 22:57:51

In

BoffinMum Tue 02-Jun-09 13:29:43

In

PuzzleRocks Tue 02-Jun-09 13:47:13

in

Iklboo Tue 02-Jun-09 13:48:12

In

jumpingbeans Tue 02-Jun-09 13:48:44

out out , shake it all about sorry

WhatFreshHellIsThis Tue 02-Jun-09 14:08:33

In

AuldAlliance Tue 02-Jun-09 14:34:03

Aha.

Thanks everyone. <<smug emoticon>>

Was worried that I was losing my English after so many years abroad.

(Boring explanation: I teach students in France who are preparing for the competitive exams to become English teachers. Every year I spend ages correcting them and saying that it's "in line X" and not "on". Have just read the report on last year's exam and it says in sniffy tones that students really ought to have mastered basic constructions and know such simple expressions as "on line X", instead of all using the incorrect form, "in line X".
While I am glad to be proved right on here, I'm p'd off at the report: do I now teach them 2 versions, one for use on the day of the oral exam, and one for using when they want to speak correct English?)

BoffinMum Tue 02-Jun-09 18:45:56

I would teach them the two expressions. For our German AL we were told to say "Ich habe Hunger" rather than "Ich bin hungrig" as the former sounded more Germanic and therefore would impress the examiner more.

However on the day my German was better than hers, 'cos my mum is German, and I learnt it over there on holidays and so on, so I needn't have bothered. wink But the principle stands, I think.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now