Talk

Advanced search

Whooohooo 'ten items or less' [itchy teeth] is

(35 Posts)
BoysAreLikeDogs Sun 31-Aug-08 11:35:22

being phased out by tesco to be replaced by 'up to ten items'.

smile

Jbck Sun 31-Aug-08 13:29:47

I saw this earlier and thought of 'The Pedants' grin

onebatmother Sun 31-Aug-08 14:40:52

Me too! Hurrah!

(I too? shock)

forevercleaning Sun 31-Aug-08 14:43:31

sorry but can someone explain what is wrong with saying 10 items or less? Been thinking about this since the old lady arguing in tesco thread, and I just cannot seem to see what is wrong with it!

wheresthehamster Sun 31-Aug-08 14:44:38

But shouldn't it be 'up to eleven items'? Or am I over-thinking it?

BoysAreLikeDogs Sun 31-Aug-08 14:46:44

Should be ten items or fewer, FC.

Don't overthink, Hamster.

<<high-fives OBM>>

grin Jbck

forevercleaning Sun 31-Aug-08 14:50:46

oh i see, so 'ten items or less is not correct English?

I still dont see it, even with my grammar school education! I must think about it some more..

onebatmother Sun 31-Aug-08 14:53:24

If something can be counted, it must be 'fewer' forever.

If it can't, then 'less'.

May I have less cake?
May I have fewer peas?

(say it in 1950's radio voice for extra kicks)

onebatmother Sun 31-Aug-08 14:55:15

actually, to avoid any confusion, that should have been 'May I have less custard, Mother? But fewer prunes, please' (I'm working this 50s thing..)

forevercleaning Sun 31-Aug-08 14:57:50

should we not say "Please may I have less..." grin

Thanks for that though, I have found it quite interesting.

onebatmother Sun 31-Aug-08 14:59:25

the 'may' contains a 'please', imo smile

BoysAreLikeDogs Sun 31-Aug-08 15:00:52

grin

Millarkie Sun 31-Aug-08 15:02:39

So 'up to ten items' means 'up to and including ten items' or 'nine items or fewer'?

I would prefer 'ITEMS<10' I think

forevercleaning Sun 31-Aug-08 15:03:03

oh, I see! I think I shall have to scuttle off and study my old English Language books a little bit more before I show my face again in Pedants.

Thanks for clarifying the 10 items or less/fewer question though, and you are all very friendly and helpful too!

onebatmother Sun 31-Aug-08 15:06:55

grin Millarkie

you are very welcome here, forevercleaning.

StarlightMcKenzie Sun 31-Aug-08 15:07:59

Message withdrawn

forevercleaning Sun 31-Aug-08 15:10:40

Yes Starlight, i even sat upright at the computer, you know, nice straight back and polite thoughts going through my mind!!

Such a terribly nice bunch of people.

Now i shall return to the chat/unreasonable threads where I can freely talk a load of old bollocks grin

jojosmaman Sun 31-Aug-08 15:13:26

God I heart mumsnet, you literally learn something new every single day! I have a degree in English (albeit Lit.) but didn't know about the fewer/ less thing, thanks guys!

BoysAreLikeDogs Sun 31-Aug-08 15:14:05

You are welcome.

smile

Igotwheels Sun 31-Aug-08 15:14:47

Finally the itchy feeling when I occasionally enter the store is diminishing!

StarlightMcKenzie Sun 31-Aug-08 15:23:10

Message withdrawn

StarlightMcKenzie Sun 31-Aug-08 15:25:21

Message withdrawn

forevercleaning Sun 31-Aug-08 15:26:37

grin

forevercleaning Sun 31-Aug-08 15:28:20

But would a Pedant really shop in Tesco, I would have though Waitrose may be more their ticket?!

I would not have the problem in Waitrose, I would would not be able to afford the 10 items, so could proceed with a clear conscience through their til!

Jbck Sun 31-Aug-08 20:00:52

I prefer asda's 'Around 15 items' thinking myself, although I was once reprimanded for having 32 items in my basket. 14 were tiny Haribo bags and I'd counted a 3 for £5 cold meat purchase as 1 item in my head.

Good job the SA wasn't a pedant she'd have had me banned grin

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now