My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Pedants' corner

Is there a difference between these phrases?

11 replies

HoollyWugger · 30/12/2020 09:30

" Schools are not expected to open ..." and "Schools are expected not to open..."

It's turning my brain to mush trying to explain a possible difference!

OP posts:
Report
Palavah · 30/12/2020 09:39

The first suggests we don't think schools will open (reporting the likelihood).

The second could mean the same, but suggests we think schools should not open.

Report
Palavah · 30/12/2020 09:40

There's something jarring though, isn't there, like a split infinitive?

Report
Redcrayons · 30/12/2020 09:45

It is different, but the more I read the less I can explain.

Report
StealthPolarBear · 30/12/2020 09:46

First is absence of expectation
Second is expectation of a negative event

Report
yossell · 30/12/2020 09:47

Logically speaking:
If I toss a fair coin, I don't expect it to land heads. After all, it could equally well land tails: expecting it to land heads would be irrational.

But that doesn't mean that I thereby expect it NOT to land heads. After all, not landing heads would mean it landed tails, and I shouldn't expect it to land tails any more than I should expect it to land heads.

But, pragmatically speaking, I'll bet the ordinary user of these sentences isn't making these kinds of fine distinctions.

Report
StealthPolarBear · 30/12/2020 09:48

Excellent example :)

Report
PegasusReturns · 30/12/2020 09:51

First: the author is telling you that their or the general perception is that schools will not open.

Second: can be read as above or additionally the imposition of an expectation on the school, with the decision now resting with them.

Report
HoollyWugger · 30/12/2020 10:04

Thank you so much!

OP posts:
Report
HoollyWugger · 30/12/2020 10:07

Although I've read the word "expected" so many times now it's turned into a nonsense word Grin

OP posts:
Report
PegasusReturns · 30/12/2020 10:38

Although I've read the word "expected" so many times now it's turned into a nonsense word

When I read your OP I thought oh that’s straightforward. By the time I revisited it to check my understanding it had turned to nonsense Grin

Report
MotherExtraordinaire · 30/12/2020 12:08

Schools are not expected to open ..."
They don't have to and probably won't open.
"Schools are expected not to open..." schools won't open. Eg not permitted.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.