On one level I think the answer must be yes.
"We ask that you be aware of these issues" sounds much better than "we ask that you are aware of these issues."
My problem though is that because verbs in English don't have much variation in endings, the subjunctive is largely invisible so can't have the clout as in, for example, French.
So to take the verb "to understand"
Indicative Subjunctive
--- ---
I understand understand
He/she understands understand
We understand understand
You understand understand
They understand understand
It's only in the third person singular that there's a difference.
In this case, you can express a difference of meaning:
"If he is to win the next election it is important that David Cameron understands the hardships felt by poor people."
What this means is that DC does, in fact, understand these hardships and this will be important, will stand him in good stead, at the next election.
But
"If he is to win the next election it is important that he understand the hardships felt by poor people."
This suggests that he may no but that it is important that he should do.
But in anything other than the 3rd person singular there's no difference in inflexion.
I think this is actually a weakness in the otherwise wonderful English language.
Would anyone like to comment?
Please or to access all these features
Please
or
to access all these features
Pedants' corner
Is the subjunctive mood useful?
6 replies
somebloke123 · 25/01/2013 13:56
OP posts:
ImNotDrunkIJustCantType ·
25/01/2013 14:00
This reply has been deleted
Message withdrawn at poster's request.
Please create an account
To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.